The Rationale of Modern Judaism
ON what basis do we justify our separate existence as Jews? What place does Judaism seem destined to fill in the economy of this modern world?
To ask these questions is not to repeat the childish hunt after a definition; it is to search for the rationale of modern Judaism—in other words, for the aims and methods, the views and hopes which justify the separate continuance of Judaism as a system.
There is endless confusion regarding the real center and core of this philosophical justif- cation of our present distinctness; the various parties exchange battle-cries and confuse standards in the chaos of discussion; we ought to understand, at last, on what opposing grounds the warring battle-lines are arrayed.
I can see but two systems of interpretation which lay any legitimate claim whatsoever to logical cohesion; I shall try to set these forth as impartially as I can and to let them be tested by actual conditions.
Here is system No. I which I will call the diffusive system. Judaism is a body of religious and moral thought; a mere religion, like Presbyterianism or Unitarianism. It developed its highest form in the universalistic ideas of the prophets. Having been bound up by the isolations of Palestine and the narrownesses of the priestly cult, it was providentially freed by the dispersion which scattered Israel as teacher among the nations and emancipated him for his world-task. That task could be performed only indirectly, so long as Israel pined in medieval bondage; in the free intercourse of our century is Judaism's great opportunity to win the world to its lessons, to transform itself into a “house of prayer for all nations.” A Jew is, therefore, he who accepts our body of truth; there never has been a Jewish race. We Reform Jews are much nearer, in all that concerns religion, to the Unitarians, than we are to the orthodox Jew. The newspaper has as little right to call attention to the one thief's being a Jew as it would have to point out another thief as a Universalist.
I call this, for obvious reasons, the diffusive system, and it seems to me consistent in theory. If we are a religion, pure and simple, preaching universal brotherhood and peace, then must we look upon ourselves as having been dispersed out of the missionary college of Palestinian prophetism in order to forget our origin, except in so far as it yielded forth our lesson, to lose our identity, except for the propagation of our teachings. We must, then, strive ardently for sincere proselytes, as many as possible; the prohibition of intermarriage has, then, no sense whatever for a mixed race like ourselves; being the divinely appointed missionaries of the prophetic faith, we need not fear being swamped by other faiths. The Sunday Sabbath becomes, then, an integral portion of our missionary system; our historical holidays must adapt themselves to latter-day convenience. Whatever smacks of race, tradition, exclusiveness, the Orient, our national past, must recede, lest it obstruct the conquering march of our disembodied faith toward genuine, absolute universalism.
In this radical form, its only consistent form, this system is accepted by no one; in all likelihood I shall be accused of having set up a straw man for easy demolition. I must insist, however, that no man may smuggle a racial element into this theory of thought diffusion without at once confusing its aims and standards. The race is here an incident of time and place; the idea is the sovereign purpose, the sole criterion of right and propriety. How any man can claim that Judaism is not a religion, but a task; that the Jew is born such, and therefore, precluded from shirking the task, and how such a man can cry out at the same time against our being spoken of as a social class, rather than a religious denomination, passes my comprehension. Either our Jewish birth determines our faith; then is our past and the individuality it created an integral element of that faith; or else the faith, being a complex of ideas for mankind's guidance, it must drop all individual accoutrement as an incumbrance.