The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 2 · August 1902
93printed page
scan 35 of 56
August, 1902.]
THE MACCABÆAN.
03

mission any evidence of anti-Semitic feeling arising in this country, have you? A. I have seen those things, and I remember the time before the beginning of anti-Semitism in France. I was present at the beginning of the Dreyfus case, and then there was no anti-Semitism, but it came in, and I do not believe that it is good for a country to have anti-Semitism; not only for the Jews, but it is bad for the country.

Q. I have before me a statement, and I should like to know whether you agree with it or not. "The outcry against the pauper alien"—speaking mainly of the Jewish alien—"seems in fact to be the commoner, on the whole more bitter, in political than in industrial circles." A. That is the statement of a gentleman who has made a good deal of a study of this question.

The Chairman: Does it refer to this country?

The Chairman. Does it refer to this country?Sir Kenelm Digby: Yes; it is an extract from Russell's "The Jew in London." Ithink it is in the nature of a fact that political movements are always a little exaggerated.A. It is in the nature of political proceedings.

Q. I gather from your evidence that the opinion you have formed as to the danger of anti-Semitic feeling in England is rather derived from the evidence given before this Commission which you have read? A. Yes.

Q. One word in regard to dissemination. You have been asked a good deal by Mr. Norman about dissemination. Do you understand by that coercive dissemination, that is to say, dissemination by operation of law? A. I understand by that, that if these Jewish gentlemen who propose it would carry it out, it would be as great a fault as it was to send back these Roumanian Jews, because they would prove that Jews themselves use a kind of restrictive means against Jews.

Q. Supposing there was legislation here preventing overcrowding, or supposing steps were taken under the existing law to prevent overcrowding, that would naturally spread the Jews rather wider, and send them to other parts because they could not get taken in, as there would not be sufficient lodging? A. As I say in this evidence, the overcrowding restrictions are the most easily evaded. I read it in the evidence of several witnesses that there is a system of housekeeper and an owner, and it makes it impossible to prevent.

Q. That would depend to some extent on how the law is administered; but however that may be, supposing the housing restrictions were enforced, that of itself would cause dissemination, would it not, because they would have to spread over a wider area of ground? A. I think so.

Q. You would not see any great evil in that? A. I would not see any evil in it when there is not pressure upon a man to go to a certain point, if by the working of the surrounding conditions he is obliged to go elsewhere, where there is nothing against freedom.

Q. Taking dissemination in that sense, as the natural result of ordinary causes, you would see no objection to it? A. No; I could not.

LORD ROTHSCHILD'S QUESTIONS

Lord Rothschild: I propose recalling to your mind some of the evidence you gave Major Gordon. I am afraid you did not quite understand some of the questions he put to you. I am going to put them in rather a different way: Do you think it possible that a Jew should be a disciple of Dr. Herzl and a Zionist, whatever that may mean, and at the same time a good citizen, and a good Englishman, or a good American, or a good Austrian? A. I am deeply convinced of it, and you have the proof of it in the last war. I know of Zionist societies who belong to the Zionist groups who as a body were in your army.

Q. I am obliged to put that question in that way because I think you misunderstood Major Gordon, although I think he meant to put the question in the way I did, but he was rather more polite than I was. It was stated here at the beginning of this Commission that the fact of a man being a Zionist precluded him from being a good citizen and rendered it imperative that he should be excluded from the country. I want to put it to you so that you may explain to the Commission how it is compatible for a man to have