The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 2 · August 1902
92printed page
scan 34 of 56
92
THE MACCABÆAN.
[August, 1902.]

way: the immigrant must show a certain amount of money at the moment of his landing.

Q. You are aware that the stream of immigration into the United States is twice as much as the immigration into the United Kingdom? A. I know that. New York has now the greatest Jewish population of all towns in the world.

Q. And the actual exclusion is the actual exclusion of a small proportion? A. Yes; but they go, however, to America. I think it is so easy to evade such a prohibition. For instance, if they joined a small company, it would lend the necessary amount to each emigrant, and the emigrant shows it and comes in, and sends back by post the amount he has borrowed. There are no efficacious measures to prevent that.

Q. I took it that your reference to the United States was an approval of the action of that country as an act of self-preservation. A. No.

Q. With regard to the scheme which you propose to submit to the Chairman of the Commission, can you state in a few words broadly in what direction your scheme would work? A. It would work in creating a center of sufficient attraction that would induce men to come there. I beg you to allow me not to go further now. There will be time to enter into details later.

Q. Anything that is in your mind is in the direction of an attractive force, in another direction? A. Yes.

Sir Kenelm Digby: You do not advocate the exclusion from the countries to which Jews go at present from your point of view? You do not advocate any restrictive measures being adopted by the countries to which Jews now go? A. No. There are countries of bad feputation which can do that, and those who have not such a jealousy of conserving their renown and their old ideas of freedom as exists in England. They may do what they believe right.

AVERSE TO EXCLUSION

Q. At present those Jews who from one cause or another leave Roumania and Russia, and other places in the East, go partly to England and partly to America, and I suppose to a great extent to South Africa? A. I think so.

Q. And to other places? A. Yes; other parts.

Q. I do not understand that you desire at all to influence that by legislative measures, but you would advocate attraction elsewhere? A. I would only advocate attraction to make the channel. I think that is the only way to direct the stream of migration.

Q. But even if your ideas were successful and had practical effect, that would not, as a matter of fact, would it, entirely stop the Jews going elsewhere, and I do not suppose you would expect that? A. I think it would not only stop, but call there those who feel themselves, or were rather felt to be superfluous, who were not desired.

Q. You think, in fact, the moral and religious ideas as well as their material advantage would attract them? A. As a whole, the whole block of advantages.

Q. You do not advocate, in order that that idea may be carried out, that other nations should exclude Jews from their countries? You do not consider that a necessary step in carrying out your ideas? A. That the others may exclude?

Q. Yes. A. I should not like to exclude. I should prefer to be a dreamer of dreams, and the facts not proving that I have seen justly.

Q. Do you really anticipate danger from any rise of any anti-Semitic feeling in a country like our own? A. Yes; there exists a French proverb, "cet animal est très impatient; il se défend quand on l'attaque." If the Jews are attacked they will defend themselves, and you will get something like internal troubles.

Q. Do you anticipate any serious danger of their being attacked? A. Unfortunately I know anti-Semitic countries. I will not give examples. But I may state not only the Jews feel that they are uncomfortable there, but there is difficulty even for anti-Semites. There comes a time when even anti-Semites regret that they go against the Jews.

Q. You have not as yet, except in the evidence you have read, given before this Com-