The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 2 · August 1902
87printed page
scan 29 of 56
Facsimile · scan 29 of 56
Scan of p. 87
Text · transcribed from the scan

Q. Is it not compatible with the perfect freedom of the Jews? A. I would not be the Crown witness for anything against Jews.

Q. Are not the two positions perfectly compatible? A. That is a question of execution.

Q. I put it to you that the Jewish community themselves have been hitherto the only restrictionists—it is they who have sent the Jewish people back to these countries, as you describe them from better conditions to worse, but you cannot say that the Jewish community are anti-Semitic in any way? A. Certain things you may do with a member of your family which would be an offense from another.

Major Evans-Gordon: That is a refinement. My point is that nobody has ever hitherto sought or suggested that a single privilege enjoyed by the Jews in this country to-day should be even modified or removed, and I say that position as one of the leaders in this controversy is perfectly compatible with the desire not to allow too many of them to come in.

The Chairman: Not only too many of them, but too many of the alien immigrants of all kinds.

A QUESTION OF SELF-DEFENSE

Major Evans-Gordon: I was coming to that. It is a perfectly reasonable position on my part. You opened your statement by saying that you understood this to be a Jewish question entirely, but I would remind you in that respect that we are only unfortunately at the outset of our inquiry, and we have been dealing with the East End particularly where most of the people who come do happen to be Jews, but that does not say we are not going to inquire equally closely into the coming in of people of all other nationalities. Do not take it, therefore, as a Jewish question. A. You will have a witness who can give you details from those people.

Q. I do not want you to go away thinking we are merely approaching this question from a Jewish point of view. Now, in another part of your evidence you say, in quoting your article, that our people are acting on pretended self-defense? A. Yes.

Q. Why do you say pretended self-defense? A. Because self-defense is always a question of judgment. I do not know when the moment of self-defense comes for you, but I know when it comes for me. Therefore self-defense is always pretended.

Q. I rather take exception to the word "pretended" self-defense. A. Always pretended, but in one case justified and in the other not.

Q. Surely men who are driven out from their homes by people who come from abroad, and are competed with in their employments and so forth, have got a right to defend themselves? A. I confess I understand that feeling. There is no pretense whatever with regard to their hardships.

Mr. Norman: I think you use the word in the sense of the French word prétendre? A. Yes.

Q. Without a moral reflection on anything, because with us the word "pretend" implies rather an offense? A. No; I would not put it offensively in the evidence I give to you.

Major Evans-Gordon: Whether it is what you say, prétendre or “pretense,” there is as a matter of fact, and must be a real source of grievance, when people crowd into one district and crowd others out. A. I think that is a question that answers itself.

Q. You regard this rightly no doubt from a purely Jewish point of view, from the point of view of your own people? A. Yes.

Q. But we English people, have we not a duty to our own people as well as to the poor and oppressed of foreign countries? A. No doubt.

Q. Would not a cry for restriction equally arise from the presence of either of a perceptible number of any foreigners, particularly non-assimilating foreigners—say Chinese—or the inflow of a foreign people into a country? Will that not lead to a cry for restriction, irrespective of their being Jews or whatever they are? A. But what makes