The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 2 · August 1902
86printed page
scan 28 of 56
Facsimile · scan 28 of 56
Scan of p. 86
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE ROUMANIAN QUESTION

Q. There is another cause at work for these people coming here. I have questioned great numbers of them, and I have been among them a great deal, and I find that there is a tendency to send for their relations to come over here? A. If you had a friend and you came here under a better climate and better conditions, you would write to your friend, “My friend! Here I am, more happy than I was yesterday.” But if you talk of sending for him, I do not know it.

Q. That tendency is at work which brings a number of people here? A. Yes; I think so.

Q. The one attracts the other? A. Yes; but that is rather a primitive means of announcing a thing nowadays. To-day we have newspapers, and all these people read the newspapers, and they know that you have such and such conditions of life here. It is not necessary that each man must write himself.

Q. You would say that to send those people back to their own country is persecution? A. It would be cruel.

Q. It is a cruel thing to do in your opinion? A. Yes.

Q. As you have said in your statement, you know that considerable numbers of them are sent back here by the Jewish community? A. I do not think that was done as wanton cruelty; they were so unprepared; they never believed what we had at the first Congress in Basle in 1897. Perhaps you will allow me to give you a very interesting statement. We had from Roumania alone 5,258 petitions of 37,043 people; they asked us to help them, as they were starving in 1897; and in 1900 only began this immigration of starving people—after three years. The cry for help was three years old when they started. The charitable bodies of the Jewish community did not take that seriously enough, they were wholly unprepared, and they could not help, that was the reason, and if my greatest foes did it I would not say it was done as an act of cruelty knowingly. They could not help themselves, they were perplexed.

Q. If the English government had done that, it would have been called restriction? A. That is a question I myself put to these people. They had the excuse of not being able to help, not having the means of a large empire. They had an excuse.

Q. To pursue that point further with regard to persecution, you say in your statement, "where it does not exist it is carried by Jews in the course of their migration. We naturally move to those places where we are not persecuted, and there our presence produces persecution." You say the presence of Jews in large numbers produces persecution. What evidence have you that there is any tendency to persecution here? A. Persecution must be taken here as a word of school language, if I may say so. That includes the several forms of animosity against Jews. I cannot write books about it, but I must take a general term for it, and I included in it slight anti-Jewish feeling in society. Persecution may be a smile in society, and a coup de poing in Stepney.

Q. You say it produces persecution, but we will modify that, and say it produces anti-Jewish feeling or anti-Jewish action. Have you any evidence that there is any anti-Jewish feeling or action here, or that their presence has produced that? A. I take it out of the evidence given by your witnesses before this Commission.

Q. Would you call a wish to exclude these people, or to restrict the number of them that come here, persecution? A. It depends on the way you take it. There is a loyal self-defense, and you may defend yourself in a rightful way, and even in a human way. I think you, Major Gordon, said there is a difficulty on humane grounds. There is a difficulty.

Q. Has anyone that you have seen in this controversy or agitation since it has been going on ever suggested the withdrawal of a single privilege enjoyed by the Jews in England to-day? A. I have not heard it.

Q. Is not what we believe, and I believe, to be the necessity for preventing an unlimited increase of the poorest part of our population perfectly compatible with the fullest religious and social freedom and equality of the Jews? A. I understand your point.