to this local question you would only cure a symptom and not the illness. I do not believe you could find efficacious measures against this overcrowding.
Q. When you spoke of “when there becomes a perceptible number of these immigrants here, then the trouble and burden arises,” what you had in mind was the trouble and burden in the community in which they found themselves?
Sir Kenelm Digby: I did not understand that.
Mr. Norman: I will refer to the passage. It is in the quotation, "This would mean the diverting of the stream of immigration from this country and America, where so soon as they form a perceptible number they become a trouble and a burden." That means they become a trouble and a burden here.
Sir Kenelm Digby: I understand the point of Dr. Herzl's evidence to be, that in order to deal satisfactorily with the Jewish problem it is desirable that they shall be diverted elsewhere than to countries where they will be aliens. I thought he was at no time speaking of the trouble and burden here, because he had no experience of it.
Dr. Herzl: I said that I knew about that only what I learn through the evidence given before this Commission. The local question and the London question you know far better than I do.
Mr. Norman: As regards the details, but as regards the general effect I presume you judge it from the results? A. I must confess I think it is a very commonplace saying, because it is the most natural thing in the world, that if you get too many shoemakers in one street, against the last shoemaker there would perhaps be a riot.
Q. You have said that this trouble and burden must be dealt with at the place where the burden is felt? A. Yes.
THE COMMISSION MUST ACT
Q. If you look at it for a moment from a purely English point of view, whatever the distant cure is, from an English point of view, it can only be cured by taking some step which will stop the influx of these immigrants into the country when they cause the trouble and the burden? A. That is the question before you to decide, whether you will be English or inhuman, if you will allow me to say so in my free speaking way; whether you will protect your native labor which pretends to be damaged, or whether you will close your doors on a very miserable and very pitiable group of men.
The Chairman: Does not the witness accept the old Latin saying, that you must go to the fountain to find the evil, melius est petere fontes quam sectari rivulos? A. Yes.
Mr. Norman: You would accept the Chairman's words, that to cure the evil you must go to the fountain? A. Certainly.
Q. You point out that the fact of this Commission having sat makes it imperative in our own interest that something should be done? A. Yes.
Q. Having begun in self-defense we must go on? A. In self-defense, or by way oi help; and I think the best self-defense would be a generous and broad-minded measure, which perhaps I could put in one way or another before you for consideration.
Q. Apart from the actual cure which might be adopted, you hold that the Commission having sat is, as it were, a great advertisement of this country to these immigrants everywhere, and if nothing is done their numbers will increase even more rapidly than before? A. I think in every case when a Commission comes together they must try to get a result. If you ask me whether you could do any efficacious work as regards the local question, I give you my opinion that I think it is not possible.
Q. I only desire to get your meaning quite clearly upon this point. I will put it in this way: supposing it were desirable for us to do something, having sat now, it becomes much more desirable than ever? A. Certainly.
Q. On the whole, you think it a good thing, and you congratulate us that the Commission has sat? A. Yes; because in other countries, even in free America they simply