The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 2 · August 1902
83printed page
scan 25 of 56

Q. With regard to assimilation as a remedy, as I gather from you, it neither could be expected, nor, from the Jewish point of view, is it to be desired? A. I myself was an assimilated Jew, and I speak from experience. I think the Jews have rather a natural tendency to assimilate. There arrives a moment when they are in a very good way. And just at that moment comes anti-Semitism. The whole of history has taught us that never have Jews been in a happier condition than they were in Spain before the Inquisition and expulsion of the 15th century. They were then all they could be, and they had all they could have.

"A TROUBLE AND A BURDEN"

Q. In fact, a vital difference of point of view between yourself and certain other influential Jews, is that they rather desire the process of assimilation, whereas you desire the persistence of Jewish nationality? A. I think that is like what the Roman Church calls a question of form, forum internum. You must leave that to every man for himself, and he must himself decide whether he will assimilate or not, whether he will go to another nation or belong to his historical nation. I say it is not right to influence a man to do it, except by putting arguments before him, or letting the forces work.

Q. In these notes you freely admit that "as soon as these immigrants become a perceptible number they become a trouble and a burden." Those are your words? A. There are economic reasons which have been explained at length before you by men who know well the condition of the East End.

Q. I merely wish to get out once more the fact that in your opinion also this increase of numbers produces "trouble and burden"? A. Yes; but not because they are Jews with special Jewish characteristics. Perhaps you will remember what happened in 1892-5 in France. There were very serious riots against Italian workingmen. You had there two peoples of very near historical and racial kinship, and they had such troubles, for economic reasons, about bread.

Q. Entirely apart from any question of race or nationality of these immigrants, they do, when their numbers increase, as you have said, become "a trouble and a burden," quite apart from any question of race or nationality? A. For this well-known economic reason, that they can work cheaper because they come under unspeakable conditions.

Q. But the fact is so? A. The fact is so everywhere where you have too many competitors.

Q. You hold that the "trouble and burden" can only be dealt with at the source, by diverting the stream of immigration? A. By diverting the stream in such a way as each would take. This diversion, in my idea, must not be forced upon them.

Q. It must be in a manner acceptable to them? A. Yes; and to bring them under happier conditions.

Q. But, at any rate, it cannot be dealt with in your opinion, at the place itself where the trouble and burden occur. I gather that is your opinion? A. Yes.

Q. It must be dealt with far away, where the trouble begins, where, according to your own simile, the wounded man lies? A. Yes.

Q. Therefore it follows logically from that that you would regard any regulations about overcrowding, sanitary regulations and regulations of a purely local character——A. As insufficient.

The Chairman: As insufficient to meet what? A. To meet the difficulty by measures against overcrowding.

The Chairman: Do you mean the difficulty throughout Europe?

Mr. Norman: No; in East London, to meet the difficulty of the trouble and burden. The chairman desires me to ask you whether you mean the trouble and burden on the Jewish race, or the trouble and burden on the community here? A. On the general community.

Q. In England? A. Yes.

Q. You mean the local burden? A. I think if you could succeed in bringing a remedy