DISSEMINATION SENSELESS
“It matters not whether the pressure that is felt ought to be experienced. If it ought not that makes it none the less severe, and, from what I know, I am certain that only a big measure will meet what must become a big question. The question will, naturally, always be a bigger question for the Jews than for those among whom they live, however big it may be for the latter, and the solution of the problem is primarily for Jews themselves; others can only help. I see that a proposal to remedy the evil complained of has been made for disseminating or dispersing our people by inducing them to leave the East End of London and settle in other parts of England. This appears to me at best a most shortsighted means of meeting the trouble. I agree with what Mr. Greenberg has written upon this point in the current number of the Jewish Year Book, that if to-day there is an evil in one spot, to-morrow, this plan being successful, the evil would be in many spots. But, above all, I object to any tacit arrangement whereby only a certain number of our people—and no more, for that is what it comes to—shall live in any given district.
“That Jews themselves should be devising means for excluding their own people from whole districts is, to my mind, monstrous. In principle they are pursuing the same policy as those who favor a restriction of alien immigration. I cannot say that I am altogether surprised at the despair of which this is indicative, which, at the very outset of the Jewish difficulty here, has settled upon the Jewish community in England. I have warned English Jews of their unpreparedness to meet a state of affairs they hoped could never arise, in speech after speech which I have made; and for the matter of that, others of our school of thought have made in England. What surprises me is the depth of the despair, the extent of unpreparedness which can propose only the senseless proposal of dissemination as a remedy for the evils which are fast gathering around Jews here in England, as they have gathered round them elsewhere.
“The fact is, that this scheme is conceived in the same antiquated spirit as what is known as Jewish charity. Jewish charity is still run upon lines that in the Middle Ages were ample. Alteration of conditions has entirely outgrown it.
JEWISH CHARITY BANKRUPT
“In old-fashioned times Jewish charity in various localities was instituted largely to relieve the needs of those traveling from other localities who had been rendered paupers by persecution, and the motive-spring was, to a considerable extent, the uncertainty as to how soon the charity giver of to-day might become the beggar of to-morrow. There was a kinship in misfortune; if not actual, then prospective. But in those days the space that had to be traversed by the wandering Jew was but a few miles, a walking distance perhaps, and the relief required was what was necessary to carry him a short way. To-day, however, the means of communication have outgrown the charitable system, so that London charity, for instance, is responsible for the moving on of Jews who wish to migrate from Russia to America, and to such a point of perplexity has the old system reached that it cannot any longer always employ itself to relieve the people. Thus it comes about that money intended to release Jews from their wretched state has been used to send them back into it. This was notably the case with the Roumanian refugees who came to England, and found their only reception in the one recipe, ‘repatriation’—repatriation to a place where the repatriated will arrive again as aliens. This is what I have meant when I have said that Jewish charity is bankrupt.
ASSIMILATION IMPOSSIBLE
“Its business is to move Jews from worse to better conditions. When it has to move them from better to worse it has failed and broken down.
“Then there is the proposal of assimilation, and, of course, those who put forward assimilation as a solution of the Jewish question do not mean merely an apish assimilation of slavish and often vulgar imitation. They mean, I suppose, assimilation by inter-
