The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 2 · August 1902
78printed page
scan 20 of 56
Facsimile · scan 20 of 56
Scan of p. 78
Text · transcribed from the scan

the Commission must either recommend restrictive legislation or not. If the former, and its recommendations are given effect to by Parliament, then England will break away from the great principle of free asylum to the oppressed, which hitherto has been its glory, although the endeavor to keep out the poor oppressed Jews cannot, I believe, be successful. But if restrictive legislation is not recommended, the mere fact of this Commission having sat will give an impetus to immigration to England; it will have formed an additional notification of the desirability of England as a place for emigration.

“ I cannot regard the question before the Commission as a small one in comparison, a question, for instance, of local housing or local overcrowding. As to these, I know little so far as they affect the districts of the East End of London. The most I know is what I have read of the evidence placed before the Commission; and that evidence tells me quite plainly that questions of overcrowding and of housing are at most incidental, that the forces at work are the identical forces at work against our people elsewhere, the forces which I have denominated ‘forces of common trade jealousy, of inherited prejudice and of pretended self-defense.’ These forces are at work here, and mask it in any way you choose, the cry of restricting alien immigration arises from the presence here of a perceptible number of Jews, and the desire that that number shall not be perceptibly increased. You have had witnesses before you who have explained to you the reasons which induce Jews from Eastern Europe to come to this country and to America. Permit me to say that it is not by any means chiefly material advantages that draw them either. Moral advantages play the larger part—a desire to live in conditions compatible with human aspirations—a desire for the freedom of life and soul which the Jew cannot under present conditions know in Eastern Europe.

“ELEND”

“ Whether the immigration is in itself desirable for this country or not, it is not for me to say. I am at best a partial witness, and just because they possess distinct virtues, such as remarkable industry, sobriety and thrift, these immigrants are possibly no more welcome than if they had vices unalloyed. And so far as Eastern Europe, which, because it contains so large a proportion of the whole of Jewry, regulates the whole of Jewry, things, as I have said, are becoming worse and worse day by day. I need only point to Roumania as a very present instance of the method by which Jews are forced from their homes; even after they have served in the army they are still aliens in the land of their birth. For the Commission must understand that Jews more than other peoples—certainly not less—are attached to their homes. This fact makes their lot more tragic. In mediæval German the word “ Elend ” means both misery and exile, and the two have ever been synonymous for the Jew. So you must not imagine that the Jew has rushed from the land of his birth immediately conditions were made unfavorable for him, and that you here in England have got to the end of the question. Indeed I must congratulate this country upon instituting an inquiry into it at what hereafter will, I have not much doubt, be regarded as almost its inception.

“ The perceptible number of Jews, of which I have spoken, is most likely to increase, and to increase from immigration under present circumstances, because I notice that even Mr. Arnold White would not try to exclude those immigrants who are victims of persecution. That limitation, if adopted, and it is impossible to think of England doing otherwise, leaves free entry for our people from Eastern Europe. I read the evidence tendered to the Commission by Mr. Llewellyn Smith, in which he stated that as many as 58,000 Jews migrated to the United States last year. The numbers to me are appalling, because I can form an estimate of the misery and the wrong that has driven these people forth from the places in which they were born, always remembering that the self-imposed sentence of exile is not with the Jews, as with those of other nationalities, for a term of years. With the Jews it is a life sentence.

“That a serious pressure already exists in England, the fact of your Commission sitting is full proof.