and we shall be only too pleased to recognize the success we desire to see accomplished, whoever may achieve it.
HOW TO DO IT.
THE protagonists of the new-old idea of bringing culture to the old-fashioned Jew and Judaism to the new type of young Israelite must, however, remember that the regeneration of a people does not proceed by mere phrases. Such a movement must have a logical basis and in addition have some strong sentiment which will move the people to action and unite them. The new culturists not being religious and not always appealing to religionists, cannot make a plea from the religious point of view, nor will they succeed in arousing interest in education merely for the sake of education.
They may go a long way round, they may attempt much; but we prophesy that ere long they will be using the national idea, and speaking in those very terms which have made enthusiasm for the Zionist movement. The turns of the wheel are interesting; the nationalists in order to make a future for the people are preaching education and culture. Culturists in order to educate the people will have to teach them Jewish nationalism. In the long run the difference will be as between tweedledee and tweedledum, so far and so rapidly does the great ideal of Zionism advance.
This is but natural, after all, as we are a peculiar people in many senses of the term; and it is only because the Jew recognizes the kinship of Jew, whatever his beliefs and opinions, that it becomes possible for those who religiously are avowedly antagonistic, agnostical and even atheistical, to work with those who are religious and observant of the old forms of Judaism.
WHY NATIONALISM?
WERE the non-national idea accepted in Jewish education there would be the danger of secularization. We are saved from the materialization which is so often brought by higher knowledge by the fact that at root the Jew is instinctively spiritualistic, and it needs but a slight encouragement for this latent power for good to give expression to itself. What nationalism exactly means to
the Jew it is sometimes difficult to say. It is a trite saying that we are the most complex of peoples. Undefined the idea is still clear enough. The speeches for which B'nai B'rith orators were responsible in New York at the beginning of the month on this question of culture might have all been spoken by Zionists, for they contained nothing but Zionist ideas. It was a case of extract of Zionism poured into a B'nai B'rith mold. Excellent! Presently, if the new scheme for New York's amelioration is intended seriously, we shall witness the general acceptance of the first principle of the "Cultur" platform passed at the last Zionist Congress—Jewish education must proceed on a national Jewish basis.
IN DARKEST ROUMANIA.
VERY little change has taken place in the condition of the Roumanian Jews since our last issue. Preparations are still going forward for their westward emigration, and in several parts of the States arrangements are in hand for receiving possible immigrants. It is satisfactory to us to learn that our appeal for concerted action has met with quiet but adequate response.
Sooner or later the result of the efforts that are at present being made from this side to relieve the pressure in Roumania will be known; the results will show themselves in such form, we hope, as will teach the Roumanian Government a lesson on the inexpediency of making promises to the ear and breaking them to the hope. Roumania cannot stop the truth by expelling Jewish journalists. Bad news knows no frontier.
ANOTHER BLACK MARK.
THE wise men of Butow in Pommerania have prohibited the Jewish ritual method of slaughtering cattle. This veto on Kashrus will not greatly affect the Butow-vian Jews, since they will be able to obtain Kosher meat elsewhere. It is, however, important to us to notice this act of Anti-Semitism.
There is still a crowd of misguided Jews who believe that Anti-Semitism was a temporary phase of European restlessness. They speak of it in the past tense, ignoring events in Russia and Roumania, because they flatter
