The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 1 · July 1902
41printed page
scan 37 of 54
Facsimile · scan 37 of 54
Scan of p. 41
Text · transcribed from the scan

the J. C. A. labors "imperial." For our part we think a less grandiose adjective would be in place. The new report, reading as much as we have received of it, contains a great mass of details on petty things. It does not show in the introduction that one big idea, equal to a percentage of the financial position of the J. C. A., has been thought of. There is no reference to a single new plan, and altogether we believe this report will require as much attention on the part of the Zionists as previous documents of a like character.

A CLOSE CORPORATION.

BUT perhaps nothing is more characteristic of what the J. C. A. is, what it amounts to as a living, vital force, than the description offered us of its annual meeting by the Jewish Chronicle. We are told that the annual gathering is "a mere formality." The writer believes "perhaps there is no other public corporation in the world, having millions sterling at its disposal, the statutory meeting of which is so purely formal and occupies so short a time."

In all eleven gentlemen were present who managed these "imperial affairs" in some few minutes, and we owe it to the Jewish Chronicle that we even know this much. As long as the J. C. A. adopts the policy of secluding itself from the world and allowing one newspaper to be present at its gatherings, and to hold exclusive rights over the publication of its report, so long we think the amour propre of the journalistic profession demands that Jewish writers everywhere should use their pens to teach this great body with such a little head that before it can be trusted as it desires it must court a good deal more publicity.

NOTHING DONE.

UNDOUBTEDLY the criticism that can be offered to the Jewish Colonization Association's report is that during the past year, during which the conditions of Jewish life in Eastern Europe have become dangerously critical, nothing has been done by the Council to bring about a better state of affairs. The report suggests, indeed, that the Council has taken not the slightest notice of the terrific change in Roumania and the impending disturbances in Russia. It records,

with significant satisfaction, that it has jogged along the beaten track quite indifferent to the fact that no one can accept adhesion to that narrow policy as sufficient effort in the Jewish cause on the part of men who control millions of Jewish money.

So inadequate is the whole document as an expression of understanding of the vital needs of the Jewish people that one journal in New York has almost apologized for devoting space to it. If the journalist who has no opinion on the Jewish question, except that he believes that something ought to .be done, feels that the report of the J. C. A. is not worth newspaper space, what can we say who have a practical and serious view of the solution of the Jewish trouble?

It is to be hoped that those of our colleagues who are nearer the center of the J. C. A.'s inactivity, and therefore whose criticism must be more effective, will take steps to demonstrate further that the Jewish people feel keenly that the present Council of the J. C. A. is unequal, and, honestly speaking, incompetent to fulfill its trust.

There is nothing more tragic in modern history than this record of nothing thought out, nothing done.

JEWISH REVIVAL.

WE have built better than we knew. That is, if everywhere deeds follow words. The B'nai B'rith and the new Theological College and the still newer Jewish World —a promising daily—have all undertaken the task of acting as Jewish missionaries to the Jews. Everywhere it is being recognized that the nadir of indifference has been reached, and that Jewry must either be conquered or conquer.

As long as only Zionists pointed out these simple truths, that the general current of thought is dangerous to the future well-being of Jewry, they were treated as scoffers, visionaries, faddists, men who had axes to grind, or beery people, as the Scots say, "with a bee in their bonnets." We claim nothing for having pointed out the truth. We are glad that, although the word Zionism is not mentioned in all these new revival schemes, the necessity for restoring Jewish ideality to Jews has caught on. We have always believed in measures, not men;