the paganism which came in with the Renaissance, and which our higher education is still too conservative to shake off. The friends of literary education who rebel against the thought of so one-sided a culture have a definite issue to contend for: that at least Isaiah and Job should take their place beside Plato and Homer in the curricula of our colleges and schools.”
Now, if "the friends of literary education . . . have a definite issue to contend for," what should we Jews say? Shall we tread the old path, teaching our youth to despise themselves and their race, with its culture, and thus robbing them of all ethical and racial backbone, or shall we boldly reform what can be reformed yet before it is too late? And will a generation of Jews devoid of natural and dignified racial self-consciousness—will a generation thus afflicted be worthy of the rights and duties of sturdy citizenship?
The theory of Jewish self-abnegation is a product of conditions that exist no more on American soil; it is a product of European political despotism on one hand, and of misunderstood Judaism on the other. As long as the Jew was compelled to live in his Ghetto he had also his own intellectual and moral Ghetto. He lived in and for his religion, and regarded the civilized world very much as a Chinaman regards the “foreign devil.” The general emancipation of the European Jews, starting as it did with the French Revolution,- always happened at a time when the trend of literature in their respective countries was anti-religious, atheistic and revolutionary. And when the young Jew at once found himself face to face with European civilization and European citizenship, he could not help regarding himself as a sort of “foreign devil” among the European nations. All at once he became aware of the great pressure of universal ostracism. The rules and regulations of Judaism seemed to be a hindrance to him who wished to live the new life of a citizen of Europe. So “the Yoke of the Thorah” was cast overboard as a superannuated superstition; the eager Jewish youth, a “tabula rasa,” quickly absorbed the most radical and atheistic ideas of the hour, in order to drown that fatal weak feeling which manifested itself at the moment of the emancipation. Assimilation, identification with the ruling race became in every case
the watchword of the rising generation. But as it takes two to make a bargain, time showed that the ruling races of Europe never really meant to accept the “ Jew devil ”; at best he was regarded as an unavoidable evil. And so, while the Jew gave up his religion and traditions, he found himself, so to speak, an uninvited guest at the table. The Jewish youth having ceased to be a Jew at heart, devoid of all religious ideals, deceived in the fulfillment of his cosmopolitan ideals, was left without any moral support. From the ruling races of Europe he learned to despise everything Jewish, and as a change of race proved itself impossible, he could not but desprise himself. The only antidote in this case, a knowledge of the historical development of Judaism, and a rational study of the eternal principles of justice and mercy underlying Judaism, was neglected out of sheer ignorance. It required the work of two or three generations of scholars to popularize Judaism and Jewish history among the Jews; and it required the violent outbursts of European Antisemitism to bring the Jewish youth home; and to put him, morally, upon his own feet may require another generation of work, through a change in the system of education. That “ imported ” theory of self-abnegation has to be rooted out, if we wish to have an American citizen of Jewish race worthy of the liberty which we enjoy here, and capable of guarding it against possible encroachment. Let our youth learn to respect their race and religion; let them be brought up on our classical literature; let them understand the mighty power of Judaism. Let us follow Professor Moulton’s advice, for we have surely “a definite issue to contend for.”
We are in duty bound to take the initiative and to establish colleges where the ethical and literary training should be Jewish and American.
A Jewish college (not Theological Seminary), with a Jewish curriculum, can be established right here in New York; a college where Hebrew and Hebrew literature, Biblical and Post-Biblical, should be taught; a college, in short, where the education imparted should be broadly human and Jewish. An institution of this kind, by maintaining a high standard, could confer degrees recognized by other institutions of learning, and would form a center of Hebrew scholarship.