The Maccabaean · Vol. I, No. 1 · October 1901
15printed page
scan 13 of 54
Facsimile · scan 13 of 54
Scan of p. 15
Text · transcribed from the scan

nations will then be a true one, not one full of mental reservations.

What security shall we have in the new, yet old country? weare asked. The very same we have had for the last two thousand years, the same that we have now all over the world. Who can guarantee the position of the Jew anywhere in the world for the next fifty years? A bold man he would be, indeed, who would venture to prophecy or to guarantee! I do not wish, however, to discuss all the points raised in the controversy, not even to allude to all the honest doubts of many an earnest man. If he be so inclined, let him only read the Bible; that will set his doubts at rest. For argument’s sake I have admitted for a moment that the Zionist movement is the result of the anti Semitic movement. In reality, however, they merely succeed one another in chronological order only. The one appeared before and the other assumed a more tangible shape soon afterward. This does not mean, however, that the one is the product of the other. The difference between superstition and science is that in the former a causual zexrzs is assumed between two events only because they succeed one another. Because a man has killed acrow once änd it rained soon afterward, the superstitious mind constructs a causal connection between the two events and reasons that whenever a crow is killed it is sure to bring rain. This is somewhat like the attitude taken by some of the opponents of Zionism, who see,the two events succeeding one another and jump to the conclusion that the one is the father of the second. I do not deny that there is a certain connection between the two, but it is the connection between illness and cure. The cure may have existed long before this kind of illness has manifested itself, long before it has been recognized in its virulence and malignant character. And thus it has happened with Zionism. It is an old panacea. That it should appear quite new, that Jews should believe it to be a quack nostrum produced by the virus of anti-Semitism as a kind of attenuated serum, but still partaking of the character of being a new invention or discovery, speaks volumes for the whole intellectual change that has overtaken Jewry. The geographical home of this allegation is of no slight importance. It tallies with that of the home of the new Jews whose knowledge of Judaism has sunk to the lowest ebb, to whom the Bible is known merely as a book with seven seals, representing, as we are told, a past phase in human evolution; who have totally for-

gotten the past traditions, hopes and yearnings of their race, and whose religious conceptions are an emasculated Comteism without his cosmopolitan tendencies. To these Zionism must appear a new-fangled whim, a quack nostrum, a dangerous experiment.

Not so to the millions whose heart still beats in harmony with the old throb of Judaism, to whom the Bible is the open book, the Prophets living messengers of God, the hope and yearning of centuries, the treasure of the past, the sustaining power and the vivifying promise. To them Zionism is the old hope kindled anew, and this explains the sudden enthusiasm with which they rallied round the movement the moment they recognized it to be the old call to self-help, the guide to the old land of their forefathers, the beginning of the realization of old dreams and visions and of the sacred words of the Bible.There was nothing new in Zionism that required explanation. It is merely the announcement that the time has come when the attempt should be made to put into fact what hitherto had been only words. Has no one of the opponents yet asked himself the very simple question: How does it come to pass that so many have joined enthusiastically in the Zionist movement? Are the adherents all men incapable of judging for themselves, at least with as much acumen as those who hold the opposite view? Is wisdom and caution and care the privileged property of the few living in the West, and have the shrewd Jews of the East of Europe suddenly been smitten with blindness and deafness, especially in a case which concerns them in the first place where they would be the first victims to suffer?Do the opponents believe that they alone have discerned difficulties and have found out obstacles that lie in the way of the full realization of the Zionist program? Are all the rest not able to see those self-evident factors in the solution of the problem? Unless people are infatuated with the belief in their own intellectual superiority, and unfortunately many who happen to have lived for a short time in a land of freedom imagine that they really have such a superiority, they must concede that others are at least as capable to judge and to argue and to scrutinize events as they themselves pretend to be, that others can also see dangers and difficulties, but also a way how to overcome them successfully. If they should come to this conclusion, already an important point will have been gained in the controversy.

The moment in which one portion of Jewry,