The Maccabaean · Vol. I, No. 1 · October 1901
14printed page
scan 12 of 54
Facsimile · scan 12 of 54
Scan of p. 14
Text · transcribed from the scan

them unreservedly, animated by at least as good intentions toward the majority of their own kith and kin as we are they are; all anxious to help. The only difference between them and us is that we wish to help, not only others, a few or a large number of our brothers in exile, but to reconstruct that unity which knows no distinction between the Jews of one continent and country and those of other continents and countries; we wish to help, not them, but us, all. We wish to remove the artificial barriers erected during the last fifty or one hundred years between Jew and Jew, and work out together our social and political salvation.

It is the most democratic movement the world has seen and it is the most ideal movement the world has seen. No wonder that an age which is gradually weaned from idealism stands and gazes open-mouthed at it; no wonder that those with new vested interests, who have worked in a contrary direction all that time, deluding themselves as to the consequences of their action, should now be reviving Don Quixote by their extraordinary opposition. Fair hearing has thus far been denied the Zionists, and trumpery charges have been advanced against the movement. I cannot call the charges by a better name, for even those who advance them do not believe in them. The best proof is that they shift their arguments from one platform to another, and if one does not answer, another is brought forward.

Lest it be said that I shelter myself behind the plea advanced before, that it is almost useless to try and convince people who refuse to read and to hear and to be convinced at all, and thus give up any further polemics, I will deal here with one of the latest and just as stale arguments that is being paraded again in the press for the purpose of showing the worthlessness of Zionism. I mean the accusation which is coolly advanced that Zionism is the outcome of anti-Semitism.

Assuming for a moment that this is so, what does such an argument prove for or against the value and worth of Zionism? Because a malady is being combated by a new remedy, therefore the remedy in itself is no good. Is quinine less efficacious or less good because it has been used only comparatively recently for the combating of fever? I know I. shall be answered quinine is efficacious, it is a proper remedy; not like your remedy, which is a quack nostrum. Agreed. But how did we learn to know the efficacy of quinine? Was it by declamations against it

from the tribune, by phrases and empty words,by the statements such as these: That fever hasbeen rampant for so many centuries and thatthough a few have succumbed, many were ableto drag along in an emaciated form; malaria isnot strengthening to the body as a rule. Our oldprescriptions proved sufficient to keep mortalitylow. And have people listened only to theshaking of the heads of the old "medicine men"and for that refused to accept the new remedy?No, quinine was put to the test, and thus itsremedial power has been demonstrated to thesatisfaction also of those who doubted andwavered.

Has any one as yet put Zionism to the practical test so as to show its futility, nay, its danger? Mere ex cathedra statements will not bring us one step nearer the solution, however many “medicine men” would shake their heads. We are told the experiment is dangerous. Our answer is, the patient is so far gone and all your old remedies have failed, that we are justified in giving him stronger doses and attempting a new cure; for it is not an ordinary case in its first stages. We are suffering of physical and spiritual consumption and we prescribe to ourselves the “Open air treatment.” Is this so dangerous, unless we cling to the old discarded theories, which saw in hemming in patients the only way for helping them. All the dangers conjured up by fertile brains of opponents are imaginary. None of the dreaded consequences are in any way to be compared with the actual dangers which our people are running all over the world. These are real dangers; the other futile imaginations. Shall I detail those dangers more fully? Paint the future in the colors which the actual situation demands? Those who have eyes can see for themselves what is, or may be, in store in a near future, with the new commercial wars looming largely on the horizon, with the growth of international brutality and egotism and with the disappearance of all idealism and humanity. The fact alone that amidst the settling gloom we are preparing one luminous spot upon earth, ought to ensure us the ready co-operation of all who are not yet quite deaf to the call of the inner voice. It will suffice for the Jew wherever he may find himself to know that there is one place upon earth whither he can turn his steps without fear of finding the door slammed in his face; to give him a different position in the world of nations. We shall no longer merely be “tolerated” or be satisfied to live on sufferance; the equality which we desire to find among the