No. 47. — "Die Welt" — 13.
CORRESPONDENCE
(This column, for which the editors do not bear responsibility, is, as we repeatedly remark, open to letters from our readers and to the free exchange of opinion.)
On the Latest Balance Sheet of the Jewish Colonial Bank
Dear Sirs,
It is much to be welcomed when the management of the Colonial Bank draws up the balance of its business activity at intervals shorter than a year and publishes the result, as was done in Number 43 of Die Welt. Interest in the bank is thereby kept alive and understanding of its activity increased. But the publication of the balance sheet can fulfil this purpose only if it is so clear, detailed and easily intelligible that it can be read even by the uninitiated — and such persons come into consideration far more with the Colonial Bank than with other banks. In this respect the last publication still leaves a good deal to be desired. To pick out only a few points: among the assets of the balance sheet is found the item: Securities 65891 pounds; there is no specification whatever of this, and yet it is of the highest interest to know whether the securities are English consols, or shares of the Anglo-Palestine Company, or share certificates of the Palestine Trading Company. It is similar with the creditors, where it is surely very essential to learn with what amounts the National Fund or other properties subject to the administration of the Colonial Bank are concerned. Besides greater detail, the addition of a short explanatory and supplementary report would also be valuable, one which would bring in the figures of earlier balance sheets for comparison and so allow the development of the business activity and the places of its operation — England, Russia, Palestine — to be recognised. By such measures, which are not difficult to carry out, understanding of and interest in the Colonial Bank can be materially furthered.
And now a few remarks on the balance sheet itself: the most significant item is no doubt the one that shows the amount of the paid-up share capital, since this is the most essential factor for the importance and purpose of the bank. The balance sheet shows the figure of 252463 pounds, an increase of 637 pounds over the last statement — to 31 July 1905. In a letter in Number 22 of Die Welt I, together with Dr. Straus, already pointed to this significant fact of the steady decline in the sale of shares. To recapitulate briefly once more. The sale of shares amounted, in the years:
| 1902 | . . . . . . . . | 19000 Shares! |
| 1903 | . . . . . . . . | 6000 ” |
| 1904 | approximately . . . | 3000 ” |
| 1905 | incomplete | 2000 ” |
| 1906 | (to I. X.) . . . | 637 ” |
These figures speak for themselves; they need no commentary. They show clearly and inexorably that along the path followed hitherto any sale of shares worth considering is out of the question, in spite of share clubs and circulars and exhortations. We emphasised in the letter mentioned that a change is only to be expected if the bank grants a steady, moderate interest on the shares, and if the management of the bank shows by deeds its earnest will to maintain such moderate interest permanently. Only then, at least among the Zionists, will the confidence arise which is the first condition of the Colonial Bank shares' being fit for investment. To bring about such moderate interest is, of course, in the first place the business of the person entrusted directly with the conduct of affairs; an able commercial head is the first condition of progress. But the balance sheet, too, shows the possibility of working in the manner indicated. Among the liabilities there figures an item: Unclaimed Dividends, which shows the sum — not inconsiderable for the circumstances of the bank — of 7779 pounds. So long as the dividends can still be claimed subsequently, this item does indeed represent a real debt of the company; but upon the lapse of the unclaimed dividends — the lapse occurs under German law within 4 years — it becomes free, disposable property of the bank. The wish has already arisen to use these sums, as they become free, for Zionist purposes for which the necessary amounts cannot otherwise be raised. Such proposals are to be rejected absolutely; they show that an understanding of the character of the bank has by no means yet penetrated Zionist circles. As against this I should like to propose that out of the lapsed amounts, which, given the dispersal of the shareholding, will presumably become available fairly regularly, a dividend supplementary fund be formed, which would make it possible to give a dividend, if only a moderate one, even in years of poorer business results. The direct benefit of such a fund, which would in a manner take over the guarantee of a steady, even interest on the shares, is surely evident without more ado and needs no further argument. But indirectly, too, the fund can achieve something of value, since the mere fact of its foundation will, more than all assurances, create, or at least strengthen, confidence in the earnest will of the management of the bank to be mindful of a steady interest on the shares.
With Zion's greeting!
Ernst Goitein, Heidelberg.
Vienna and Berlin
Dear Mr. Editor,
On Saturday, the 3rd of November, the solemn consecration of the newly opened Bet-ha-Midrasch took place. To this celebration came the Vice-President of the Jewish Community, Provincial School Inspector Dr. Gustav Kohn, with several members of the Community Board and a number of notabilities of the Community. Rabbi Dr. Adolf Schmiedl delivered a stirring festal address. A few days earlier the new premises of our Community Library were opened, but without song or sound, in all quietness. The Community Library feeds professors, private scholars, rabbis, publicists and students; it gives them abundant intellectual nourishment and stimulus; it cannot be ignored by anyone engaged on a work of Jewish learning; it is a Bet-ha-Midrasch in the truest and fullest sense of the word — and nevertheless it is a stepchild of the Community Board, which pays it not the slightest attention. In these grave times, when Viennese Jewry is moving along a very steep downward path, offering the world the sad spectacle of an ever-spreading disintegration, when baptism and desertion of the flag are among the most everyday occurrences, the Board is intent upon saving Judaism — but passes its library heedlessly by. Truly, the ways of the gentlemen who lead the greatest community of the Continent are past finding out. That knowledge is power seems to be all Greek to them.
They have shown their solicitude for the library solely by calling a Library Commission into being. An excellent measure, if it is carried out with skill and tact! But the Board, to vary a saying of the Community Board member Baurat Oskar Marmorek coined upon the much-discussed Viennese community rabbi Dr. David, "has unhappily proved once again that it has a peculiar talent for saying the most unseemly thing in the most unseemly place and at the most unseemly time." The Board has committed the unseemliness of electing to the Commission, beside the tried but unhappily ailing old master Abraham Epstein, the aspiring scholar Seminary Professor Adolf Büchler, the many-sided, large-minded and bee-like industrious Rabbi Dr. Grunwald, and the well-known man of letters Dr. Kaminka, such men as the above-named schoolboyish bungler Dr. David and Moriz Altschüler, recently removed from the editorship of the "monumenta Judaica." Is the Viennese community then so poor in men of Jewish learning, is that learning, so far as it is pursued in Vienna, really so sickly, so mortally ill, that the Board could find only four representatives of it? Things are surely not so bad as that in the city of the Phaeacians; but the Board is blind, colour-blind. And why did it not make every effort to persuade, say, Chief Rabbi Dr. Güdemann — who, by virtue of his position and learning, is surely called above all others to it — to join the Commission? It is downright irony, a bitter irony, that a layman presides at the head of that advisory council as its chairman. Under such circumstances it is no wonder that the Commission, despite its two-
