Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 40.
(continued from page 5)
...powers sufficed, have represented. The Zionists are indeed already represented in the Union today, and some of us are also members of the Central Association. Our endeavour, which must be directed towards a unified gathering-together of all the Jews of Germany, will be able to manifest itself precisely in this field in co-operation with the other Jewish groups, without our having to give up even a jot of our principles; and we shall bring nearer to us those elements which still stand aloof from our movement but take an interest in Jewish affairs, if together with them we champion our common interests and have shown ourselves in this contest to be clear-thinking, calm and reasonable men. We can go together with the Union as with the Central Association all the more readily since the founding of both already represents a great advance in the organisation of the German Jews. From a higher point of view both are already national elements, as against the absolute want of principle and of organisation of the seventies and eighties. For we must bear in mind that both societies are not led by actual assimilationists at all, but by gentlemen who, even if they are not National Jews, are nonetheless proud of their Judaism, are conscious Jews and wish to preserve Judaism in the future. In the Zionist movement the assimilationists are often railed at quite uncritically, without the critics knowing exactly who in truth the assimilationists are. The people with whom we used to fight, and still fight on occasion today, are not the real assimilationists at all, for they still have Jewish interests. Those who really strive for the extinction of Judaism, the conscious assimilationists — to them even the Central Association, which seems so harmless to us, is a thorn in the side, and they reproach it and us alike with strengthening the separation between Jews and non-Jews in Germany.
Through the founding of the numerous Jewish organisations of every kind in Germany, which today are positively waiting for systematic consolidation and direction, the structure of German Jewry has shifted materially in the last 30 years. We are no longer the will-less, formless mass of scattered individuals incapable of any unified political striving, but the Jews whom we can today draw into political activity as Jews and in the Jewish sense; and despite all indifferentism the overwhelming majority of all German Jews has nevertheless slowly become conscious Jews, proud of their stock. With these factors the parties of the Left, which wish in any way to count upon our support, must reckon; for even if we do not find excessively many traces of political, social and economic anti-Semitism on the Left, all the more widespread precisely here is what I should like to call cultural anti-Judaism. Judaism counts with them, the intellectual children of the Enlightenment, as something long decayed, consecrated to ruin. For them the share of Judaism in the culture of mankind ends with the birth of Christ, and what Judaism has accomplished later was, in their view, done by single individuals, while Judaism as a whole represents a reactionary element. For all these circles the baptised Jew, the Jew who had freed himself from all the bonds of tradition, was really the ideal man as such. Among the Liberals, Mommsen in his day, in the philosemitic pamphlet "Another Word about Our Jewry", spoke of the Christian foundation of our world culture. He directly recommended the baptism of Jews and condemned all Jewish cultural endeavours. Among the Socialists, Marx in his day denied outright the existence of Judaism as a cultural and religious factor. He regards it only as a narrow-hearted spirit of huckstering, of which the dictum holds: "The social emancipation of the Jews is the emancipation of society from Judaism." And Social Democracy everywhere still stands today hostile to all consciously Jewish endeavours, and full of utter incomprehension.
Thus the parties of the Left will have to revise their view of the value of Judaism as a cultural factor. They will have to reconcile themselves to the fact that the Jews desire the preservation of their stock in Germany too, and abhor dissolution in the general porridge of the nations. On the other hand, however, the Jewish organisations will have to dissolve the especially close political alliance hitherto existing with one particular faction of the Left, for which they have as yet been thanked from no quarter, in order to stand without prejudice towards all groups of the Left, in order in all election contests always to support the Left against all shades of the Right, and in order, so far as it lies in their power, to compel the parties of the Left to unity and to a common front against the Right, and so alone to afford the possibility of bringing about a more liberal régime in Germany, which we need as Jews as well as men who are most intimately interested in the prosperity and development of Germany.
II.
On the Political Attitude of the German Jews
By Dr. KARL KASSEL (Posen)
The discussion on the political attitude of the Jews in Germany will scarcely come to an end so soon. It has already had the result that many a one of the hitherto unwavering out-and-outers is beginning sceptically to revise his former views. The anti-Semitic doings of the Freisinn he might yet have got over — the party leadership, yielding at last to the pressure of its local agents, would in future have guarded against open betrayal. But the feeling is growing among the Jewish following that all firm ground has been withdrawn from beneath the party. They scoff at how Gossip Tailor and Glover of the Christian faith, when for business reasons, or he himself knows not how and why, he puts himself on good terms with the Jews, is stamped a Freisinniger and elected as quickly as ever possible to the committee of the Freisinnig district association, and so bound fast. This clinging of the Freisinnig party magnates to every non-Jew has awakened the mistrust of the masses; in them, the so very small Jews, it is beginning to dawn. And this dawning of self-consciousness we must foster. The independent Jews, so far as they are not chained to the colours by seats at the committee table, are moving away of their own accord from the ruins of the old Progressive Party.
This party can no longer return at all into the philosemitic waters of the good old Liberalism, because the Christian voters, so far as they have remained faithful to it, would then withdraw their following. Gambetta's saying, "that the Progressive Party had harmed itself with the lower classes of the people by its attitude on the Jewish question, for these hated the Jews," has come true. It is not doubtful to us, however, that even in the circles in which a spark of the old tolerance towards us is still preserved, the unswerving advocacy of the Freisinn by the Jews nevertheless signifies a danger for Jewry, because a gross self-deception is fostered in our masses by the close adherence to this political party and the merging of their interests in it. This becomes dangerous for the community wherever it does not stimulate the unfolding of fruitful activity, but rather, through constant barren negativism and unconditional opposition, keeps awake, precisely in the Jews, who are endowed by nature with a keen critical faculty, a wholly unjustified self-satisfaction at having already fulfilled their duty by criticism alone. The intolerance with which the Left constantly reproaches the Right has by no means been less developed in the former on that account. But all men without distinction of confession have the right to love and to hate. Of the latter the choicest spirits indeed make no use, but the masses need an object of hatred and contempt — and so even the noble example of the Christian religious communities has not been able to prevent hatred and contempt from being precisely Christian peculiarities. So it will remain as long as there are different confessions. In party questions, however, it is not a matter of hatred and love, but first of all of purely economic antagonisms, that is, of a struggle in which political questions are only means to an end. We cannot, however, get round the fact that the Jews today are represented in all circles of interest, that an honourable party shelter does not exist for them.
A remark which we find in Hohenlohe is very interesting for the judging of the Jews, whose social-ethical principles are as old as Judaism itself and who have given their ablest minds to the building up of social doctrines. He speaks of Lothar Bucher: "Bamberger wants the unrestricted rule of capital; Bucher, as a Socialist, will not let the power of the State be restricted by the Jews. Therein lies their antagonism." For the activity of the Progressive Party in social legislation its Jewish rank and file of that time will long have to do penance. And even of the old Emperor, to whom history will give the name of the Good, we hear: "The Emperor does not approve of the doings of the Court Preacher Stöcker, but he thinks the affair will peter out in the sand, and considers the uproar useful for making the Jews somewhat more modest."
