DIE WELT
=== COLOGNE-ON-RHINE, UBIERRING 23 / APPEARS EVERY FRIDAY ===
CENTRAL ORGAN OF THE ZIONIST MOVEMENT
10th YEAR / COLOGNE, 16 November 1906 כח״ חשון א״התלח לחורבן / No. 46.
OUR NEW SHIBBOLETH
The storm-flood — in the inkwell — is roaring in. Pilpulistic hair-splitting, carping mistrust and the spirit of coterie are striving to inflate misunderstandings into differences of opinion, and such nuances as may actually exist, and are justified in their existence, into dividing chasms. Let us for once survey these differences from a general Zionist point of view.
In Palestine and for Palestine a period of Storm and Stress is beginning. People wish to accomplish something practical, and believe they have found a welcome field for an activity yet to be shaped. The red blood of real life is to pulse in the idea. One is to awaken from the dream of fancy and begin a work that attracts and enthrals and uplifts. The national estate is to be extended, as much land as possible acquired, and a footing gained at all events, for otherwise the soil will fall into alien hands. In an age of nervous haste and bustle one should not content oneself with the forging of plans. Abstract political speculation is fruitless; in proportion to the mighty run that was taken, what was sufficient has not been attained. We languish for deeds: the land is to be tilled by Jews at once, and, if possible, set with factory chimneys as well. The colonies, woven about with a wondrous enchantment, will shed their radiance upon us. There life flows, and at this prospect the heart beats higher. So say the so-called Practicals.
The so-called Politicals, on the other hand, reply: The colonies are in themselves children not carried to term. Cut loose to a full life of their own, they would rush towards an abrupt end. Proof: the earlier stage. Zionism is no work of a day. It springs from the feeling of the people, from its longing and its ideals. To be imbued with a consciousness of political purpose and to follow political methods are the decisive factors that can enable us to the highest achievement. Zionism does not swing the great torch of the Jewish future in order at once to build a few villages, which, as artificial or philanthropic experiments, must of necessity languish without it, but in order at the fitting moment to create a State, and until then to influence the whole of Jewry in an epoch-making manner. It must not, therefore, let all its means be dissipated in a manifold splintering. Regard for the political chances must be decisive. The aim is not to settle a few thousand families, but to form a secure commonwealth which shall be a clear mirror of our national personality and shall let the Jewish genius flower. This thought alone is the uniting bond which can encompass us and give our movement colour and life.
That these nuances exist holds no danger. The danger lurks only on the side of absurd exaggerations and of an inclination towards a purposeless guerrilla war. Shallow and stereotyped is this new kind of confessional dogmatism, for in truth it is impossible to confine ever-flowing life within a dogma. The idea is eternal, but practice must be subject to constant change. One should not, in rigid constraint and ossified obstinacy, judge according to this or that scheme and dance to the beat of this or that drummer of phrases. For God's sake let us not form compact, close-knit masses of believers in words, who will swear by, or rail at, small colonisation on the one side and politics on the other. Let us keep a clear eye for every project. Immediate work has a deep justification, if only it is undertaken in the right way. No practical man will deny that the undertakings require long and thorough preliminary study, that every precipitation would mean a mistake that could inflict incalculable harm upon the prestige of our movement. As soon as one has once recognised what one really wants, and what one can do, it will not be impossible to create this or that. But of course one must not demand too much nor expect too much. Immediate work has its practically conditioned and limited justification. And the main thing is and remains political Zionism: the great longing for union, the idea which Jews of different par-
1*