Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 46 · 16 November 1906
4printed page
scan 2 of 20

Page 4. — "Die Welt" — No. 46.

(continued from page 3)

...ties and of different countries binds to one another, the development of a national will, the unfolding of a great, collective strength of spirit, vigorous discipline within, the process of the further development of a tribal unity conscious of its goal and thirsting for the old homeland, and the creation of opportunities, as well as the seizing of given moments, to approach the external factors in the name of this unity.

We make no compromises, but it must be clear to every thinking man that Zionism signifies the synthesis of the practical and the ideal. Both tendencies must work with equal strength, and the Organisation is the authority that brings about the balance. It is in truth no contradiction, but a division of labour, and the labours stand in a quite definite relation to one another. The sphere of politics is the movement, the agitation, the building up of the institutions, the increase of the means, authority in face of the outside world, the process of further developing a unified world organisation for a clear purpose in harmony with the interests of the world and of civilisation: the creation of a Jewish State in Palestine. And for this politics needs certain practical points of support, certain experiments, preparations and embodiments on the spot. On the other hand, the practical work there needs the Zionist movement here, its cohesion, the mighty will of the people, the idea that stirs the imagination and quickens the national organism. The former must make certain sacrifices, and the latter — curb its impatience and renounce much.

The task of maintaining this equilibrium is enormously difficult and should not be made impossible by dialectical exaggerations. And for this there is but one means: no blocs, no cemented groupings of phrases or of persons! Let one submit to no dogma and to no phrase, but examine every thought and every proposal. Let us not allow our strength to be paralysed by a new schism.

A question more important than this shibboleth, filtered out of words and quotations, presses upon us with all its force. A period of Storm and Stress is in fact beginning in Palestine. It is like a new edition of the Bilu movement. A part of our youth from Russia comes, so to speak, romping in. One should learn to value this youth. By its intelligence, its activity, its staunchness of conviction, its joy in self-sacrifice it has defended and glorified the people; it is our pride and our hope, yet it does not always know how to find its bearings in new situations. It comes out of a seething rumble, out of the whirlpool of movements, after it lay gasping under the yoke, in a peculiar state of mind, at times in a paroxysm of rage which sees in every philistine everyday man a Burschuk (bourgeois), a brutal tyrant — rough and lawless, with a cynical contempt for authority, with a mocking superiority towards the courtesy customary among civilised people, armed with the devil's own courage and with an arsenal of the newest, gleaming weapons of socialist dialectic. One must understand how the contact of the socio-political Russian combustibles with the Jewish masses' consciousness of oppression, and with the so many precocious, over-ripe, déclassé and excitable members of our people, has produced these peculiar moods; and if one understands this, one will honour and love this poor, noble, but alas unnerved youth.

We must take the faults into the bargain, for they are our faults. So we are when subjugated in bondage, and so we are when we become free. We must first learn to be free, and to be free as Jews. We must first learn that the bridling and guiding of the impulses in earnest work is also freedom, indeed the only true freedom, and that a calm, free bowing to the common good and a modest, tactful bearing are not what they appear to be amid Russian conditions that mock at all civilisation, and in the conceited super-cleverness of the immature pocket-edition architects of the world — foolish convention — but that they are the product of long developments and wholly worthy of a free man.

Should we succeed in guiding the heroism of our youth into the right channels, the work in Palestine will indeed become great and fruitful. Heroes, perhaps martyrs too, we need for Palestine. What tenacity is required, and what reverses must be endured, to achieve anything of significance by way of colonisation, the history of all peoples proves. Our beginnings were feeble first steps; we had pioneers who suffered, we made certain sacrifices, but let us above all be truthful and not set these small things too loudly upon a high pedestal. . . Let us say it openly; most still lack the perseverance to sow, free of bitterness, steadfast as iron, devotedly, patiently, what only the grandchildren will reap. How many of the old Bilu men wavered to and fro, fell and were scattered like withered leaves in the storm! They overrated their powers, they willed much and soon flagged. They were like Ixion, who reached for the Queen of Heaven and held a cloud in his hands; the fair Fata Morgana melted away before their eyes.

To fill the new youth, steeled in hard struggle, with a glowing, unshakable love of Palestine, with an intense feeling that binds them to the land of the fathers, to inspire them with iron perseverance and energy — is a far more important problem than brooding over the catchwords of internal party life. And this is not to be bought with money. One should not approach the Organisation with impossible demands. The Organisation is nothing alien; the national property is not alien but our own possession. The little bit of means should not be quickly squandered, lest the movement be endangered. The very seriousness of this consideration should counsel caution before one lightly pronounces a damning judgment. But when such a judgment is called forth by the wounded self-esteem of an individual or of a group, one asks in astonishment what sort of idea these judges may have of national work intended for generations.

To raise capacity and self-confidence, to suppress impure and base selfishness, to allow criticism its due in practical undertakings and to bring deliberation to mastery, to do nothing without a firm fixing of the political goal, to make demands not upon others but upon oneself, the mania for crumbling apart as a