Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 45 · 9 November 1906
5printed page
scan 3 of 20

No. 45. — "Die Welt" — 5.

(continued from page 4)

…hitherto, working for their co-religionists in Morocco, but independently of the Alliance Israélite. The Jews of Morocco are to be stinted of none of the advantages they have hitherto enjoyed. On the contrary, I am convinced that they will only receive the greater support from German Jewry — which ought to set itself the aim of surpassing the work of the French Alliance by the work of an independent German society — when the German Jews know that in supporting their co-religionists they are not at the same time furthering a national-French and, in certain circumstances, anti-German work. If the Alliance Israélite pursues a French, in certain circumstances a chauvinist, policy, it thereby commits a wrong against those of its contributors who are not Frenchmen, and likewise against the Jews who are educated in the French spirit without regard to their particular circumstances and needs. No policy of chauvinism would be furthered by a German society, and the Jewish association we have in mind would, in our view, rather have to be guided by the principle of exerting its strength on behalf of German schools only where the need for German schools should arise in the interest of the Jews themselves. The Anglo-Jewish Association, too, in its day left the Alliance simply because the latter attended solely to French and, in particular cases, anti-English business..."

Finally the writer touches on the disproportion between the contributions that flow to the Alliance from Germany and the expenditure it makes on German instruction, in order to close with an emphatic invocation of Don Caballero as an ally (at least against the French Alliance).


If one of those pitiable Jewish slaves down there in Morocco who, as the Alliance reports, "prolong their lives by gathering up a few lost grains of corn in the granaries, or by stilling their hunger with camel-dung if such a Jew were to learn how highly his friendship and that of his brethren is valued in Europe, he would no doubt fare like the good Bonze Schweig in Perez's story, who would not believe that he, the poor devil on earth, could be the one honoured in Heaven. To be sure, if in the end, like the worthy Bonze, he were to ask for a little piece of bread, French, German or Spanish, every morning — he would come off badly. On earth people are not so generous.

But let us leave the sorry jest! We know that politics is no matter of sentiment, of pure kindness of heart. And we understand quite well when the Powers interested in Morocco wish to exploit every means of strengthening their position, and when each, in the heat of their mutual rivalry, strives to wrest the political trumps from the others and get them into its own hands. Nor are we surprised that in this political game it was very soon discovered how serviceable the Jews of Morocco in particular might be.

We understand, then, the cold moves of politics. But if in this case we find them particularly ugly and disagreeable, it is because in this game of Morocco everything is shot through with the spirit of dishonesty and hypocrisy.

Spain, the most noble Spain of Isabella and Torquemada, all at once remembers her sons, the bearers of her "language", and counts it to herself as a title of possession that the Jews have kept faith, in customs and in language, for centuries with the land that drove them out.

And Germany! The semi-official diplomat is quite indignant at France's attempt to discredit Germany among the Jews of Morocco and of the whole world. What delicate solicitude! A pity only that it is voiced in the same paper in which the cruel mass expulsions of the poor Russian Jews were defended with brutal matter-of-factness as a self-evidently necessary measure. Where, then, was Germany's sense of shame before these Jews and the Jews of the whole world? What right does this Germany — which has the glory of having qualified the poor Jew outright as "schnorrer and conspirator", which of all the countries of the world has perhaps decreed the sharpest measures of exclusion against the Russian-Jewish emigrants — what right does it derive from its relation to the Jews to graft, now, in the north of Africa, the blessings of its culture upon Moroccan Jews who have never heard its language? Superficial observers of the Russian Jews, who took the Jewish language for bad German, believed they could establish how greatly these Jews strengthen the German element in Russia. Certainly, despite the philological confusion mentioned, this is true to a certain degree. The Russian Jews have favoured the German language as the language of trade, and the German market as a source of supply, far above the others. And the reward for it? Contempt, expulsion, deportation under escort. And now it is seriously demanded that German Jews, who daily feel German intolerance towards Judaism in their own persons, should as "patriots" grow enthusiastic about rearing a German-Jewish generation, a generation of agitators against France. And that is the second and still greater ugliness in the whole affair: that the "co-religionists" on this side and the other of the Rhine are to be played off against one another by driving them on with the patriotic whip. If you won't do it, you are the international, the unpatriotic Jew — do you understand?

A miserable spectacle. And the saddest thing is that the Jews themselves are to blame that people take the liberty of playing with them, north and south, as with marionettes. It has often been said and proved, and can therefore here only be briefly stated once more: the Alliance has disowned the spirit of Crémieux; it has falsified from the ground up its purpose of being a general Jewish organization; it has become a tool of French assimilationist policy and is in danger of falling apart into sections which for their part wish to pursue a German or English assimilationist policy. This policy has also depressed the relation of the European states to the Jewish question to the sorry low level which the Morocco controversy indicates. So long as governments do not learn to respect the Jews for their own sake, so long as the Moroccan or Russian or Algerian Jew does not appear worthy, as a Jew, of awakening the interest of a state, so long will all Jewish policy lead only to preparing another kind of misery for Jews filled with an alien spirit — proof: the Algerian Jews.

England was the first state that was magnanimous enough to understand that the direction of Jewish policy must lie along the line of what is Jewish. That does not prevent, and is not meant to prevent, the gov-

2