Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 40 · 3 October 1906
16printed page
scan 14 of 20
Facsimile · scan 14 of 20
Scan of p. 16
English · AI translation, checked against the German

16 — "Die Welt" — No. 40

CORRESPONDENCE

A Reply to Dr. A. Marmorek

To the passage concerning the Palestine Commission in the speech, and in the subsequently published letter, of Dr. A. Marmorek I should like to reply as follows:

Mr. Zangwill at one time defined the task of Zionism as the creation of conditions and not of things. Mr. Marmorek extends Zangwill's definition and declares that our national funds may be drawn upon only for such institutions as it is the duty and task of the people to create. But here the question arises in what respect the "Bezalel" sanctioned by our politicians, that is to say an "institution" for the introduction of arts and crafts, corresponds to political aspirations more than an industrial syndicate, i.e. an "institution" for the introduction of industries into Palestine. Moreover, Mr. Marmorek is in error when he supposes that the syndicate is to be founded with the help of national money. All the documents hitherto circulated in the matter of the syndicate state plainly that it is a quite ordinary, purely commercial private undertaking which is to stand in no relation whatever to Congress Zionism. It is true that the invitation to subscribe speaks of a prospective participation of the J. C. T., but in that the Commission has as yet committed no offence, for under a resolution of an earlier Congress our bank is not only entitled but expressly obliged to take part in undertakings of this kind, and a possible abstention of the Colonial Bank from the syndicate would therefore rather be regarded as an offence against the authority of the "sovereign" Congress.

On a critical examination of the arguments of our politicians one comes to suspect that these gentlemen are themselves still very unsure as to what is permitted and what is not. In what way, pray, does the discounting of bills in Jaffa hasten the obtaining of the Charter, and how is it that precisely this business, rather than any other commercial undertaking, is to be regarded as a "political path"? The gentlemen have an answer, no doubt, namely that non-Jewish banks already exist in Palestine; but they forget that, even if the industrial possibilities sketched in the narrower programme of the syndicate have perhaps not yet been taken in hand by non-Jews for the present, this may very easily and very quickly come about. The best proof of this is furnished by the "Agricultural Bank of Cyprus," recently founded by Sir William Willcocks (see "Altneuland," July-August number). How many verbal battles have Zionists fought over Cyprus — and in the end what is practically attainable in Cyprus is carried out by Englishmen and not by Jews. If we go no further than talk, such a case might easily occur in Palestine as well.

That would pain even Mr. Zangwill, to quote him once again.

That on the strength of the future Charter it will be possible to expropriate non-Jewish factories, let alone concessioned undertakings, is surely out of the question, and even Herzl's "charta magna" probably did not contain this point either.

As for the particular rôle of the Palestine Commission in the syndicate, it can by no means be described as a promoter in the ordinary sense of that word, for even when the syndicate comes into being it will draw no material advantage from it. The Palestine Commission figures in this merely as the preparatory committee, as the sole authority and European central office for economic affairs relating to Palestine.

Mr. Marmorek's apprehension that possible failures of the syndicate might harm the Commission, and thereby Zionism as well, is out of place for this reason alone, that the rôle of the Palestine Commission as preparatory committee ceases entirely at the moment the syndicate is brought into being, and it will have nothing further to do with it. Could it, moreover, occur to anyone to reproach the Palestine Commission because the Palestine Trading Company of Hamburg, which it called into life, brought its partners no dividend in the first period of its existence?

If Mr. Marmorek's apprehensions on this score were justified, then political Zionism, which in the decade of its existence has unhappily also had a number of failures to record, ought long since to have been "disavowed"; and yet all the world sees that the understanding of it and the recognition of its necessity grow greater day by day and hour by hour.

Will there, then, be no economic failures even after the Charter has been obtained? Can such failures be avoided at all? Why, even the Colonial Office of the old German Empire still stands far from the level the Germans would wish! And why should we Zionists, of all people, wish to be the infallible ones?

A. Awadiowicz.

Berlin, 25th September 1906.

FROM THE MOVEMENT

Appeal!

Shortly the anniversary will come round of the day on which our movement lost one of its best, Dr. Oser Kokesch.

His memory is still too fresh in the recollection of us all for it to be necessary to recall once more the eminent services he rendered our cause. His whole life was consecrated to Zionism. He stood at the cradle of our political movement, and it was granted him, as one of the most faithful and self-sacrificing fellow-workers at the Leader's side, to give proof of his pure devotion and his untiring capacity for work in unforgettable feats of organization. "To honour his memory" — so a friend wrote on the day of his death — "means to emulate him in love and devotion for Zionism, to carry on his work with his fidelity, so that the finiteness of his existence may not mean the forgetting of his endeavour." . . . . .

The return of the anniversary of this man's death has awakened in many the wish to manifest, by a visible token of love, their faithful gratitude for the labours of the departed.

The Actions Committee resolved unanimously at the annual conference to erect a simple memorial stone over his grave in the Central Cemetery at Vienna.

All friends of the deceased are to have the opportunity of contributing to this small work of piety. They are hereby cordially invited to send their contributions to the office of "Die Welt." Since, in view of the approaching anniversary of his death, the collection must be closed this month, contributions for the projected memorial stone are requested as soon as possible.

The Zionists' Journey to Palestine

Zionist circles are looking forward with eager interest to the Jewish party tour to the Holy Land, which, organized by the Zionist Central Association in Vienna, Türkenstrasse 9, leaves Vienna on 22nd October and Budapest on 23rd October. A large number of distinguished