Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 39 · 28 September 1906
28printed page
scan 26 of 32

Page 28. — "Die Welt" — No. 39.

(continued from page 27)

…endowers will then, should an amendment of the statute be resolved upon, be in a position to say: it was not on these conditions that we made our endowments. On these legal grounds we object to the amendments of the statute". (Minutes, p. 236).

In the end the original plan was adopted with the following additions, and a commission of jurists was elected to carry it into effect:

"The A. C. is instructed to see to it that the legal basis of a juristic person be created for the N. F. by the next Congress."

d) First Annual Conference 1902. Proposal regarding a Swiss co-operative society, submitted by Dr. Farbstein as President of the N. F. Commission (under revision of the A. C.), with the following purposes: To purchase in Palestine and Syria building, arable and garden land as well as woodlands, to have the purchased land built upon or cultivated, or else to lease it to Jews, sub-letting excluded." (Report of the N. F. Commission, p. 33.)

Dr. Bodenheimer opposed the proposed form of legalisation on the following grounds: "This co-operative society seems to me a wholly unnecessary detour, which moreover is in my judgment also altogether inexpedient." (Report, p. 80.) He proposed the form of a German foundation and submitted the draft of a constitution for such a form of legalisation, with very much enlarged purposes.

Both proposals were, after full discussion, rejected by the Conference in favour of a proposal made by me (seconded by the late Dr. Isidor W. Marmorek), that the N. F. be founded as an English Trust (a foundation) on the basis of the Congress resolutions, in connection with the J. C. T., and, if desired, with a separate administration.

e) VI. Congress (1903). Report of the President of the N. F. Commission on the working-out of a plan for legalisation in the form of an English joint-stock company, but with the recommendation of the Commission (on the advice of the Russian delegates, who were of the opinion "that nothing at all should be resolved now") that the adoption of any constitution for the N. F. should stand over until the next Congress, but that the Congress should definitively and firmly declare the date of the commencement of the N. F.'s activity.

Accordingly 4 resolutions were proposed: 1. Postponement of the adoption of any constitution, 2. Purpose of the National Fund, 3. Commencement of activity, 4. Appointment of a new commission to fix the statutes. — With regard to the 1st, 3rd and 4th resolutions there was no significant difference of opinion, and there was a general inclination to the effect that the immediate activity of the Fund should begin in pursuance of the purposes previously decided. Dr. Tschlenow, as spokesman for the Russian delegates, opposed the original self-denying arrangement of reserving half the Fund for purposes of later mass colonisation, and he said:

"We have a far more important purpose still, and that is to transfer as much land as possible into Jewish hands, and therefore I am of the opinion that one should not set aside half of the income of the N. F. for this purpose, but only a fifth or a quarter." (Min. p. 283.)

Strong opposition, however, showed itself to the terms of the proposed resolution (2) regarding the purpose, which was contained in the very much enlarged terms of Dr. Bodenheimer's foundation project at the time of the preceding Annual Conference.

At the end of the sitting, which lasted 5 hours on the 5th day of the Congress (the day after the debate on the East Africa project), Dr. Bodenheimer, who as Vice-President was in the chair, said, after an unsuccessful attempt to have the resolutions voted upon en bloc:

"During this uproar I have come to an understanding with Herr Tschlenow and one other member of the Commission, and we are of the opinion that the Congress should pass resolutions only on the 1st, 3rd and 4th paragraphs of the motion, but not on the second, because there are still motions pending on this 2nd paragraph which have been referred to the Commission, and because the wording of this paragraph still depends on the form and the seat of the foundation."

The Congress was then adjourned, but a night sitting took place, which began at 11 o'clock and at which Dr. Bodenheimer again presided. On taking the chair he declared: "I proceed at once to the vote on the motions of the N. F. Commission. It was declared earlier that the N. F. Commission withdraws No. 2 of its motions. It is therefore now only a matter of Nos. 1, 3 and 4."

In spite of this express declaration of the Chairman, which confirmed the agreement reached during the day sitting, No. 2 of the motions, which consisted of the strongly opposed statement of the purposes of the N. F., was brought to the vote and declared carried, without any further opportunity being afforded to consider or to discuss the matter. (See pages 303—306 of the Min.)

This point was no longer on the order of the day, and it is obvious that a large number of those who had an interest in the matter, and who would have continued their opposition to the proposed statement of purposes, were satisfied by the assurances given by the Chairman during the day sitting that No. 2 had been withdrawn, and therefore did not attend the night sitting, during which less contentious matters came up for discussion. One may therefore declare without hesitation that a resolution adopted under such circumstances, if it was intended to exert any effect upon the statement of purposes adopted and confirmed at earlier Congresses, could be of no binding force or of no value as against the Congress or the Commission which had been elected for the final settlement of the N. F. statutes. The only considerate opinion, and, as I hope, the correct one, which can be formed regarding a resolution concerning the purposes obtained in this way, is that there was no intention of altering in any way the decisions already maturely considered, but that a vote upon it took place either in consequence of a misunderstanding as to its effect, or with the intention of formulating phrases which might be taken into consideration by the Commission, without imposing any fresh rights or obligations upon it, and still less upon the subscribers or administrators of the Fund. This, however, is the resolution which has brought about the whole confusion of views and the difficulty of reaching an understanding, a fact which emerges clearly from all the expert opinions, statements of opinion and letters in Documents Nos. I to XVI (collected in a supplement for the information of the members of the Conference). It may, and indeed must, be set wholly aside in the decision regarding the purposes which we have to carry into effect.

So far goes the significance of the proceedings in the Congress, which proceedings ended with a resolution, in so far as form or purpose was concerned, for nothing further took place regarding the legalisation of the Jewish National Fund at the Annual Conference (1904) or at the VII. Congress (1905).

There can be no doubt for anyone who treats this matter in a deliberate manner that the net result of the facts here stated is this: that the original purposes of the National Fund remain untouched, and that the formal statement of them in Herr Kremenezky's draft is the only binding one which has been pronounced by the Congress in that regard.

I now turn to the question of the form of legalisation, which can only be properly settled when the purposes have been clearly ascertained, for the form must depend upon the purposes, and not the purposes upon the form, as appears to have been the case with various proposals which were recommended for examination.

It emerges from the documents of the supplement, I to V, that after the Congress attention was given to the work of legalisation, if not by the new commission then appointed, at least by the Actions Committee or its recognised officers. The deliberations of the Committee ended at the close of 1905 with the result that the matter was taken up again where it had been left after the Annual Conference of 1902, at which our former highly esteemed leader Dr. Herzl presided, at a time when my proposals regarding a trust foundation were first brought forward and approved.

On 3 December 1905 I received from the new President, Herr Wolffsohn, an official letter in which he informed me of a resolution passed by the A. C. concerning the National Fund, and communicated to me "that this Committee entertained the wish to legalise the National Fund on the basis of a Trust Deed (deed of foundation), since the Committee had arrived at the conviction that the intended form of a Limited Cy. would be bound up with too great difficulties for the movement. To this end the Inner A. C. had resolved to appoint a commission, which should, if possible, lay before the next sitting of the Greater A. C. a draft for legalisation on the basis of a Trust Deed." I was invited, at the