No. 39. — "Die Welt" — Page 27.
On 26 September the interesting trial of the former Vice-Governor in several governments and official for special missions to the Minister of the Interior, Actual State Councillor Lawrow, is to take place in St. Petersburg. Lawrow is accused of having distributed 25,000 proclamations in which, among other things, agitation is carried on for a pogrom against the Jews. Twenty-five members of the "Union of the Russian People" will appear as witnesses.
At Lochowitz (Government of Poltawa) the trial over the October pogrom has taken place. 34 peasants were charged. The trial lasted 5 days. 12 persons were acquitted; the others were sentenced to terms of imprisonment of varying length, up to 3 months. The monetary losses were reckoned at 40,000 roubles.
It is reported from Kishineff that 24 defendants and 80 witnesses took part in the trial over the October pogrom at Strascheny. The priests testified that Jews and Christians had always lived on the best of terms. The pogrom was instigated by agitators who spread rumours of an imperial order to beat the Jews. The court sentenced 2 of the accused to 2 years' and 2 to eight months' imprisonment. 18 persons were acquitted.
The chief of police of the 1st district of the city of Bjelostok, Scheremetjew, who took a prominent part in organising the recent pogrom there, has now received a post in the St. Petersburg police. A distinction, in other words!
The "Glos Zydowski" has been suspended by order of the Governor-General of Warsaw.
No. 35 of the "Jewreskaja Shisn" has been confiscated by order of the City Governor of St. Petersburg.
The Struggle against Pogrom Literature
The Literary Commission in Kieff has sent the following appeal to the editorial offices: Of late a wide dissemination of pogrom literature has become observable, aimed at a renewal of the October pogroms. This evil must be counteracted; a humanitarian literature must be set against the inflammatory pamphlets. To this end a literary commission has been formed in Kieff. Since the beginning of its activity, that is, since the middle of July, the commission has distributed 6000 pamphlets in Kieff, 1900 pamphlets in the Government of Kieff, 3160 pamphlets in the schools of the Government, etc.
On the Legalisation of the Jewish National Fund
2 Reports, presented to the Annual Conference.
I.
Report of Mr. HERBERT BENTWICH
It is the duty of the present Conference to decide the legal constitution of the National Fund, and that in accordance with the intentions of the founders and of the subscribers to the Fund.
What this intention was is a question of fact, the answer to which emerges from the published plans and from the resolutions duly adopted in that regard. It is not here a matter of opinions, which subject the declared intention to divers interpretations according to the prejudices of the individual person; and still less is it a question of what the purpose of such a fund ought to be, for on that there might be as many different opinions as there are persons at this Conference — quod homines, tot sententiae. — It is solely a question of fact.
The material difference in all the forms of legalisation which have been unfolded and discussed lies in the greater or lesser attention paid to these guiding propositions. And so long as we do not confine ourselves to the simple question of fact, and do not treat this matter in a deliberate manner instead of in a political or partisan sense, we shall never arrive at a satisfactory solution of the difficulty, since this difficulty, after all, is not to be sought in the matter itself, but is for the most part called forth by outside considerations.
The decision of the question of fact is not only important as a guide for our deliberations, but is also absolutely necessary for the protection against, and release from, legal liability of those members of the A.-C. upon whom there now rests the heavy responsibility of carrying out the duties imposed upon them by the subscribers to the Fund and undertaken by them. These are very great, since it concerns a fund which has already reached the considerable sum of £50,000 and over. As regards this side of the matter it suffices to cite here the opinion of Counsel (Mr. Armitstead) of 27 December 1904, which on this point reads as follows:
"The point (the conditions under which the contributions were received) is a most important one, because by English law the Fund can be dealt with only in a manner authorised, expressly or by implication, by its subscribers, and the employment of the Fund in England in any other manner would expose its administrators to the danger of being sued in the English courts to make good the Fund. Their liability, in the event of such proceedings against them, would be joint and several."
I venture therefore to request the Conference to subject to earnest examination the principal stages in the development of the plan for the National Fund, as these are set forth in the official minutes of the proceedings of the Congress and in the reports of the National Fund Commission, which, briefly summarised, are the following:
a) I. Congress (1897), Prof. Schapira (founder of the Fund): "I should only like to emphasise . . . . . that, besides the other funds, a territorial fund is to be created; secondly, so that this territorial fund could not later be employed for other purposes, that provisions to that effect be incorporated in the statutes; thirdly, that this fund should never be exhausted at all. Those are the three fundamental principles from which I should not wish to depart." Resolution thereon: "The Assembly declares that it holds in principle the creation of a national fund and the foundation of a Jewish bank to be necessary, and that the A.-C. to be elected should therefore lay before the next Congress a thoroughly worked-out plan for this". (Minutes, page 166,67).
b) IV. Congress (1900). Resolution: "The Congress declares the creation of a National Fund to be desirable and instructs the A.-C. to take the preliminary steps". (Minutes, page 274).
c) V. Congress (1901). Plan of the A.-C., submitted by Herr Kremenezky. Purpose: "The Jewish National Fund shall be an inviolable property of the Jewish people, which may be employed only from the moment when a sum to be fixed by the Congress has been attained, and then exclusively for the purchase of land in Palestine and Syria. The employment of the Fund is conceived in such wise that half of the said sum may be used for the purchase of land, while the other half must be put out at interest". (Minutes, p. 266). Administration: "The A.-C. of the Zionist Congress is the body which has to pronounce whether the conditions have arisen that entitle the National Fund to purchase lands, and which also has the decision upon the purchase of land." (Minutes, p. 270.)
When Dr. Bodenheimer proposed that these proposals be allowed to stand only as provisional ones, Dr. Herzl, as President, said:
"This must be something definitive. The Congress, however, which indeed . . . . . remains the permanent master of this National Fund, can certainly make such changes as later become necessary. But it is unjuridical and impractical to call such a draft a provisional one." (Minutes, p. 280.)
Dr. Bodenheimer opposed the view of the President and insisted on his objections in words which are of significance with regard to the question of present responsibility:
"If we accept the draft today without this emphasis (as provisional), then hundreds and thousands of people will make endowments on the basis of this draft, and the
