No. 37 — "Die Welt" — Page 20.
(continued from page 19)
…Japanese war touched. There in Manchuria, said the deputy, the military had not been so brave as in Bialystok. This remark of Jakobsohn's was attacked at the time from several quarters, which led him to make a declaration in the Duma in which he explained that it had been far from his intention to accuse the army as a whole of cowardice, and he withdrew his general assertion. This declaration of Jakubsohn's, however, did not pacify the officers' circles stirred up by the "Novoye Vremya" and other reactionary papers, and soon a young lieutenant named Smirnsky was found who challenged Jakobsohn to single combat. Jakubsohn declined, since a duel was contrary to his convictions. Smirnsky did not let the matter rest and had a threat against Jakobsohn printed in the "Novoye Vremya." To this a young officer responded by publishing a letter in the newspaper "Oko." In this letter the officer stated, among other things: "I am, on grounds of principle, of the opinion that the former Duma deputy Jakubsohn was right in all his actions, and I offer Lieutenant Smirnsky my services. I take over the challenge which he addressed to Jakobsohn and place myself at the disposal of the challenger."
Simultaneously with the officer's letter there appeared in the newspapers a second communication, signed by a Mr. S. Alapin. In this interesting document Mr. S. Alapin writes, among other things, the following: "I take the liberty of proposing myself to Lieutenant Smirnsky as his adversary. I too cannot approve the murder of innocent and defenceless people . . . There are several millions such as I in Russia, but I am the first to make the proposal, and therefore I have a prior right in this respect . . . Should I succumb in this combat, it will have no further consequences, for I have nothing in common with the revolutionaries, and no one will wish to take revenge for me. But it may also turn out otherwise: although I am already grey and have never held a weapon in my hand, yet I believe that God is not in force but in truth! . . . I should not wish, to be sure, that the 'terrorists of the Right' should perhaps seek to avenge my opponents. It would only be right and fair if this loyal condition were acknowledged by some influential organisation of the 'Union of Russian Men.'"
The exchange of letters has understandably aroused great interest in Russian public opinion, and the outcome of this affair is eagerly awaited; it is especially noteworthy for the religious feeling that finds expression in the second letter.
BOOK REVIEW
On the History of the Jews in Bohemia*)
Under this title there has appeared in Prague, the venerable city that once bore the beloved name of "Little Mother in Israel," an interesting and instructive work which is of great importance for research into the history of the Jews.
"On the History of the Jews in Bohemia," a work in two volumes, contains 1346 collected documents and regesta, materials for the history of the Jews in Bohemia, Moravia and Silesia from the years 906—1620. An exceedingly large number of sources had to be used, and these are also recorded under each individual number. Among others, the following were searched: the archives of the Lieutenancy for the Kingdom of Bohemia, of the capital Prague, of the Bohemian Provincial Museum, the Royal Bohemian Provincial Archive, the Imperial-Royal State Finance Archive and the Imperial and Royal Joint Finance Archive and the archive of the Imperial-Royal Ministry of the Interior in Vienna; further, the archives of the Prague Archbishopric, of the Wyschehrad Chapter, of the Lieutenancy at Innsbruck, of the towns of Pilsen, Böhm. Budweis, Kolin, Kuttenberg, Eger, the Count's archive at Neuhaus, the Provincial and Lieutenancy archive at Bruenn, the State Archive at Breslau, the archive and library of the Prague Jewish community, and others.
Of printed sources the following were used: Archiv český, Codex diplomaticus Moraviae, Fontes rerum bohemicarum, Regesta Bohemiae, Monumenta Boica, Codex juris municipalis regni Bohemiae, the papal bulls concerning the blood accusation, the Municipal Laws of Bruenn, Monumenta Egrana, the proceedings of the Bohemian Diet, the Archive for the Knowledge of Austrian Historical Sources, the Charter-Book of the Town of Saaz, the Bohemian Chronicle, the Charter-Book of the Town of Budweis, The Exalted Rabbi Löw by Dr. Grün, Emek habacha by R. Joseph ha Cohen, translated by Dr. Wiener, Zemach David by Dr. Grünwald, Gal-Ed by Koppelmann Lieben, the Testament of Mardochai Meysel by Dr. Wisch, Codex juris bohemici, the Town-Book of Brüx, Materials for the Statistics of Bohemia, Listář města Plzně, Dějepis města Prahy (History of the City of Prague), Memorabilia of the Town of Falkenau, Hormayr's Archive, Kniha pamětní města Plzně (Memorial Book of the City of Pilsen), Chronicle of the Town of Trautenau, History of the Town of Reichenberg, Regesta on Silesian History, Communications of the Society for the History of the Germans in Bohemia, Liben historicky nástin, Fasciculi diversorum jurium, Journal for the History of Judaism, and much more.
The collection is preceded by a preface by the editor Bondy and by the Director of the Provincial Archive, Dvorsky, who collected 996 of the 1346 numbers. In his preface Dvorsky attempts to give a survey, from the standpoint of the history of civilisation, of the life of the Jews in Bohemia. The work closes with a chronological index. Of the materials collected, not all, of course, are of equal value. In particular, a number of errors have been taken over from the printed sources; but that is not meant as a reproach; it remains for critical historiography to judge and sift the collected material according to its worth.
That, moreover, with so vast a body of material some sources were overlooked is already proved by the supplements that became necessary. Dvorsky himself says: "It is surely unnecessary to remark that, like other collective publications, the present collection too cannot be regarded as complete. In the course of time other written and printed monuments will certainly come to light which, despite inquiries at home and abroad, could not now be obtained, and which will form a welcome supplement. On the historical appraisal of the sources . . . a separate work is in preparation."
From the great abundance of regesta a few may be cited here: No. 1. Year 903—906: The Jews had their seat in Bohemia and Moravia even in the most ancient times. No. 10. Year 1096: Persecution of the Jews. No. 14. Year 1161: The Jews are said to have poisoned the people. No. 26. 12 May 1267: Cardinal Quido, in his encyclical issued from the Council of Vienna in the name of Pope Clement III., ordains, among other things, and brings this to the notice of the Bishop of Prague: That the Jews, under penalty of a fine, shall wear pointed hats to distinguish them from the Christians. No. 75. Year 1338: The Jews were tortured and murdered in Bohemia and in other lands because they were alleged to have desecrated a Host in Kauřim. No. 82. Information about the Jewish cemetery in Prague, 1341. No. 92. List of the revenues which the town of Breslau drew from the Jews in the years 1345—1349. No. 139. In Iglau there appears in the year 1362 a medicus judaeus. No. 153. Jewish names in Prague, 1378. No. 171. Misfortune of the Jews in Prague, 1389. No. 212. Information about the plundering of the houses of the Prague Old Town councillors and of the Jews, 1422. No. 354. Information about the negotiations concerning the provisional retention of the Jews in Prague, 1518. No. 372. The social conditions of the Prague Jews in the years 1420—1526. No. 868. Jewish oath, 1589. No. 1088. Jewish oath, 1616. No. 1202. Information that the Jews were to be expelled from Prague, 1507. No. 1339. Information about the audience of Rabbi Löw with the Emperor Rudolf on 23 February 1592. No. 1346. Information about the Jewish chronicler David Gans, 1613. If the book has been described by an expert as a "standard work" of its kind, that is not saying too much. On the basis of this collection those who are called to the task will be able to set about writing a history of the Jews in Bohemia. Everyone who acknowledges the value of history, whether as a means of national education or for other reasons, must heartily rejoice in the book, and owe very special thanks to the editor. For the publication of this work Bondy was decorated with an order by the Austrian Emperor. It is to be wished that we Jews also should honour Bondy, in our own way: by studying much in his book and by taking care, as far as possible, that it becomes the first in a series of works of its kind.
Ernst Gütig.
*) On the History of the Jews in Bohemia, Moravia and Silesia from 906—1620. Edited by Gottlieb Bondy, former President of the Chamber of Commerce and Trade in Prague. Prepared for publication and supplemented by Franz Dvorsky, former Director of the Provincial Archive of the Kingdom of Bohemia. 2 vols. Large 8º, XII and 1149 pages. On commission: German edition with Gustav Neugebauer in Prague; Bohemian edition with Fr. Rivnač in Prague. Price K 20.—
Editorial Letter-Box.
Ivria-M.Ostrau: Heartfelt thanks and best wishes. Zion's greeting. W.
Dr. A. M. Neuilly. — Unfortunately arrived too late. Will appear in the next number. Greetings.
