Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 36 · 7 September 1906
6printed page
scan 4 of 20

"Die Welt" — No. 36

(continued from page 5)

…do something, at the mere wish of Mr. Ussischkin, who possesses no direct knowledge of conditions in Palestine, against which Mr. Levontin, who has a very exact knowledge of them, advises us. For us Mr. Levontin is the expert on whom we can rely. If we grant the workers in Palestine, in Mr. Ussischkin's sense, everything that is proposed here, it will come to an open scandal. The people will not keep the leases, and we shall suffer heavy losses. The distinction which Mr. Ussischkin made in a passing remark between Eastern and Western Europeans we shall not permit in Zionism. We are to work together, and yet we are continually reproached with lack of understanding on individual questions. . . . We wish to represent Herzl's pure ideal, but Chowewe-Zionism is nothing but Rachmones-Zionism, and with it Ussischkin would in the end destroy Herzl's heritage. I repeat: this whole matter must be fought out at the VIIIth Congress. I call my colleague Ussischkin's attention to this: we elected him because we believed that he would work together with us and would bring interest to the political matters with which we are occupied. But this is not so. As often as these matters are discussed, I have the impression that Mr. Ussischkin behaves with complete indifference. To his motions and his other labours we long kept silent or assented, although we were often not in agreement with them. But now we must come out against them. As long as I shall be at my post, I shall maintain my standpoint. When I see that things are continually being done which do not fit into our political programme, I say we are in the wrong waters. The Palestine Commission, which was appointed for the exploration of Palestine, but not for the founding of business undertakings, meddles in matters which are not compatible with its purpose, and so we have gone further and further, down to the present state of things. We have elected a committee in which not all the members represent the same political views. If Ussischkin thinks to act at the VIIIth Congress as he did at the VIIth, then the firebrand of strife will be flung into the Congress. We shall not permit Herzl's political ideal to be destroyed. I fear that at the VIIIth Congress we shall have to take up once more the struggle for the political principle. I repeat: either one is a leader of the Chowewe Zion or a leader of political Zionism. Perhaps Ussischkin, before whom the Russian gentlemen and even a character like Dr. Tschlenow bow, will be followed at the Congress too; then we stand before a great moment, and we have been forced into this struggle. If the Congress is a stormy one, we shall have Mr. Ussischkin and his activity to thank for it.

Dr. Hantke: The Palestine question is the most difficult question we have to solve. If we wish to be just, we must admit that in future one must be quite clear as to what attitude one is to take towards this question. For the present we are still seeking a formula for bringing our activity in Palestine into harmony with the "security under public law." I should warmly welcome it if this question were to dominate the VIIIth Congress. But I am firmly convinced that, even though there will be various views at the Congress concerning our work in Palestine, we shall nevertheless go home united. I am entirely against the Ussischkin-Warburg motions, because, if we agree to such exaggerated demands, the National Fund will slip out of our hands. The people, however, understand by the National Fund a compact mass, something tangible. They want an inviolable fund, visible to everyone, and not consisting of book entries.

Dr. Katzenelson: I can very well understand Marmorek's excitement. For it is sought to dissolve our great idea for us into trifles and pettinesses. But Marmorek has after all gone somewhat too far. For the Ussischkin motion is quite harmless; one may safely vote for it. The motion is to be handed over to the A. C., habeat sibi! The establishment of an agrarian bank in Turkey is bound up with such great difficulties that the plan becomes for us undebatable out of hand. And besides, millions are needed for it, and those we do not yet have. Warburg's motion, to be sure, is much more serious. I know it very well. We have often debated it in the woods of Kissingen. And there Professor Warburg told me that as a member of the A. C. he would very well vote for it; whether he could vote so as a member of the board of the Bank, that he would doubt. Hand on heart! Have we the right to take from the small people, to whom we have promised a dividend, that dividend, in order to form an Agrarian Fund with it? The Bank has a great task; it is one day to form the instrument of our movement. Have we not, then, to take care that it becomes stronger and mightier? Shall we take from it every possibility of this by binding it hand and foot? Once we have given up moneys of the Bank for colonisation, there will be no end to it. For colonising, other means are needed than those at our disposal.

Dr. Rosenbaum (Minsk): You quite forget that only yesterday you made an amendment to the statutes whereby the unclaimed dividends will in future no longer fall to the Bank. With that, therefore, this matter falls entirely to the ground. I urgently request you to reject the Ussischkin motion. By adopting it we should get on to dangerous ground, which has not been cleared up at all. The whole motion is altogether unclear. If Ussischkin moves that the matter be referred to the E. A. C., I should like to go still further and move that the E. A. C. refer it to Mr. Ussischkin. Still less sympathetic to me, however, is Warburg's motion. That means nothing else than making book entries out of the money of the National Fund. A word to you, Dr. Marmorek! You had absolutely no reason to speak as you have spoken. We were political Zionists earlier than you; it almost seems that you do not know the history of Zionism. The reproach that we let ourselves be schooled by Ussischkin I must reject. If Ussischkin's views are not right, we know how to reject them, on that you may rely. But, Mr. Ussischkin, this I must tell you, you are yourself to blame when such conceptions arise. Marmorek's remarks were only the echo of your motions. You should have consulted beforehand with us, with your Russian colleagues; then these motions would probably not have been brought in. The danger does not lie in the fact that the motions were made, but that they were made by you, when you knew what mistrust is felt towards you.

Levontin: Mr. Scheinkin has to-day repeatedly interpellated on the ground that the Anglo-Palestine-Company is indeed a good banking institution, but not a Zionist one, and does too little for the people who really need the support of the Bank. I will only communicate a few things: In the course of the three years of its Palestinian activity the Bank has bought 23 000 dunams of land for itself and others, and we are on the point of buying 6000 dunams of land. More, however, it may not buy, because it may not tie up its moneys in land to too great an extent, and because there are as yet no buyers. All the Jewish industrial undertakings which you find in Palestine, the largest as well as the smallest, have been supported by the Bank in some way, of course only those which rest on a sound basis and are financially secure. Only the applications of those were refused who wished to establish themselves with our money. That, naturally, we could not do. The wine-growers in Pethach-Tikwah and in Rechowoth have been supported to such an extent that they were able to build cellars of their own and to sell their wine independently. All the colonists in Kastinie, Chederah, Artuff and Ekron have received loans from the Bank at very low interest on their grain until the harvest, and thereby we have freed them from the hands of the usurers. We have given financial support to the larger Jewish landowners and put them in a position to enlarge their estates; we have supported the Jewish export and import trade to the best of our power and founded loan co-operatives for the small traders; in the course of the first six months of this year we discounted about 94 000 francs in 886 bills. You see from this that we have worked above all with the small people, and despite the great labour this caused us we have charged them only low interest. We have shown that one can very well work in Palestine while benefiting the country and at the same time gaining advantages oneself. Practical work in Palestine is only a business question. If works are proposed which have a good business basis, we should accept them. But to work merely for the sake of working will unquestionably lead to failures.

Moser: I am glad to have heard here a view of Dr. Hantke's which I should like to describe as reassuring. I associate myself with this view fully and entirely. The plan of an agrarian bank is certainly worth considering, but the matter is still very little cleared up, in particular not in the direction of whether such an undertaking is at all possible under the prevailing laws. The speaker further turns against Levontin's remarks on the matter of labour conditions in Palestine.

Weizmann: I am very glad that we can still discuss the Palestine question. For there reigns such obscurity that a full discussion is absolutely necessary. I did in part provoke this debate, and I am glad that Dr. Marmorek has given a clear answer. For until now the method prevailing among us has been, with difficult questions, not even to bro-