Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 27.
(continued from page 7)
…from the new feeling. If we are a nation, then we must have what constitutes the first mark of all nations, a house of our own, a land of our own. And so they all professed themselves for Zionism.
In this sense all of us, from the late Theodor Herzl down to the youngest student, have regarded the Jewish-national profession and the Zionist final goal as a unity, as a logical structure in which not one little stone might be loosened without setting the whole tottering. This unity, however, I found torn asunder at the students' meeting of last Sunday, and from the speeches of the young people there spoke a spirit which may perhaps be called modern, but certainly neither far-sighted nor Zionist. The students' demand was in many cases supported with arguments drawn from the narrowest horizon, and the tone in which they were advanced betrayed a deep passionateness such as is always wont to belong to local politics of a personal colouring. The very toying with political alliance gave the students' demand a flavour which betrays to me anything rather than a large-minded Zionist consciousness of aim. We Jews have no business in the struggles of the nationalities among themselves, and nothing to gain. To-day we regard it as the greatest mistake of the Liberal Jews that they helped to inflame national passion in Austria to white heat: let us beware of committing the same mistake in the Bukovina, which stands in urgent need of peace and quiet labour. Whatever everyday successes of a political nature might be won would be bought far too dear at that price.
I sum up. The complaint of the Jewish-national students is in its essence perfectly well founded. If they are compelled to state "German" as their mother tongue without being permitted a mark by which their distinctiveness as against the Christian Germans finds expression — say, "German (of Jewish nationality)" — they are wantonly forced into a false, ambiguous, unworthy position in which neither the students nor the academic authorities can feel at ease. But what is to be done if the Jewish-national students find no redress? To this one can only give them the old answer which the Zionist idea gives to the Jewish Question as a whole: Strive towards the great goal, which will free you thoroughly from all false positions, ambiguities and oppressions. Every other way leads into the political quagmire or back into the Ghetto.
In one of the earlier numbers of our paper we had occasion to reproduce, from the reports of H. M. Smeljansky contained in the newly founded weekly "Das jüdische Volk", some interesting particulars on the colonisation of Palestine. Mr. Smeljansky now continues his interesting descriptions, from which we take the following in extract:
Remarkable in itself, and significant with regard to colonisation, is the immigration of Russian Jews of late. About 100 persons arrive in Jaffa every week. The greater part of them are young people and people of middle age. Many also come with smaller or larger capital. A contributing factor to the increase of the emigration to Palestine has been the circumstance that the ports are entirely open to the landing of Jews. The immigrants' passports are, it is true, taken from them and retained, but the newcomers themselves are otherwise exposed to no inconveniences whatever. Of course the number of immigrants is vanishingly small in comparison with the great Jewish masses who are leaving Russia; but for Palestine this small stream has a fairly great significance, and with good organisation much benefit could accrue from it to the country. Unfortunately this organisation is almost entirely lacking.
Whoever remembers the colonisation of the year 1890 will be able to observe much that is similar in Jaffa now. Again, as then, we see small groups of the new arrivals in various places, with a few natives mingling among them. Unfortunately one also notices a good deal of the old mischief: secrets, suspicions and petty intrigues. Some of the old heroes, too, appear on the surface, casting their nets and trying to catch new fish.
But otherwise the present immigration has much that is new and peculiar about it.
Above all a strong inclination towards trade and industry is to be noted, whereas the immigrants of the year 1890 strove almost exclusively after agriculture. None of the newcomers of means has stayed with farming, whereas industry and trade have after all drawn many to them.
It is further to be recorded that for a considerable category of the new immigrants the chief aim is a purely material one. The ideal side of colonisation plays almost no part at all for most of them.
Quite different, to be sure, is the relation to the land among the young people who come to Palestine to live here as labourers. It is characteristic that rich or well-to-do people, who could prosper in agriculture as well as in industry, nevertheless often leave the country disappointed and discontented, while the young labourers who earn 40 kopecks a day are content and do not think of departing. Idealism, then, holds its own after all as the more valuable force.
What at present most recalls former times in the colonisation is the want of any organisation whatever, the absence of the institutions necessary for the regulation of a colonisation.
Above all an agrarian bank is lacking, which should buy and sell land and should also grant long-term credit on land. Further, there ought to be a technical bureau which could give various technical advice and information, and likewise a commercial bureau set up for kindred purposes. Of course all this need not be created at once, but quite gradually; but it is beyond doubt that such institutions, if furnished with capital and commanding a rich experience, could accomplish a great deal and win general confidence.
Unfortunately there is almost nothing of the kind. What we possess is a very feeble beginning. We possess the Anglo Palestine Company, which does much good, but not enough — for that it lacks above all capital. We further possess a Palestine Commission, which ought to have created the necessary technical institutions, but it lacks a direct field of activity in Palestine itself...
Are there means, the author asks, whereby the present immigration to Palestine could be extended and furthered? He answers the question in the affirmative, pointing to the following circumstances:
Firstly, the number of colonies could be increased. Already the Ica owns much land in Palestine, namely in Galilee and in the land beyond Jordan. Immigrants could buy this land against long-term instalments. With a little energy much land could also be bought, and cheaply, in Transjordania, in the South and in the neighbourhood of Midbah etc. Among the young immigrants there are many who are especially fitted for a colonisation in these regions.
Secondly, commercial traffic could be developed and enlarged. There are products in many districts of Palestine suitable for export, such as cattle, horses, grain, vegetables, fish etc. Especially capable of development, he says, is the export of grain, leather, wool, raisins, olive oil, soap and oranges. The trade in these products is at present for the most part in the hands of the Arabs; one could, however, create a strong class of Jewish business men. The same holds of imports. They are already very large. Into the country are brought: sugar, timber, iron, rice, naphtha, ready-made clothes, various manufactures, machines etc. But like the export, the import too is dominated almost exclusively by Arabs. A great future awaits, among other places, the town of Chaifa. It is now connected by railways with Meschek, Mecca, and with the richest grain districts of Palestine and Syria. Moreover it will soon receive a harbour, on which building has already begun. Settlers who acquire land or houses in Chaifa may look forward to a good future. The third, exceedingly promising factor is industry. Many products are made in Palestine itself in a very primitive manner, as for instance soap, olive oil, dried fruits etc. Many other products which the country needs are imported. Raw materials are exported and finished manufactures imported. Hides, wool, grain, for example, are exported; leather, stuffs, beer, dried fish, herrings, sardines, candied fruits etc. are imported. To work up all these products in Palestine, to create an industry, many energies and much capital could be fruitfully employed.
More good will, more ability — so the author concludes — of work there is in plenty.