Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 27 · 6 July 1906
1scan
of 22
Facsimile · scan 1 of 22
Scan of scan 1
English · AI translation, checked against the German

DIE WELT

COLOGNE-ON-RHINE, UBIERRING 23 — PUBLISHED EVERY FRIDAY

CENTRAL ORGAN OF THE ZIONIST MOVEMENT

10th YEAR. COLOGNE, 6 July 1906 / י"ג תמוז א"התחל לחרבן No. 27.


THE RECOGNITION OF THE JEWISH NATIONALITY

The sitting of the Austrian parliamentary Committee on Electoral Reform of 27 June acquired for us, through a small episode, the significance of a memorable event. The Germans were pressing their claims to a Galician seat; whereupon the Minister of the Interior, Dr. Baron von Bienerth, replied as follows:

"It has been pointed out that the deputy elected from this district — it being taken for granted that he would belong to the German nationality — would in a certain sense also receive the mandate to represent as well the remaining Germans living in Galicia. But this view, too, does not seem to me to be well founded in the actual circumstances. According to the latest official statistics there are, it is true, some 212,000 Germans in all in Galicia; among these, however, are about 140,000 to 150,000 Jews, who may surely not be reckoned without qualification to the German nationality. There are in Galicia in all 82 communes in which one can speak of a majority of resident German population; these are, by and large, without exception places in which Swabian colonists once settled, who have preserved their peculiar character down to the present day. The population of these places, however, amounts to only some 82,000, among whom again there are only 56,000 Germans. And if one deducts those communes in which the population is predominantly Jewish, one obtains for the whole crown land — and the communes enumerated in the motion of Kaiser and Demel are already included therein — still only a figure of some 45,000 Germans. On these material grounds the motion of Deputies Kaiser and Dr. Demel does not appear to be well founded."

The surprise in the Electoral Reform Committee was extraordinarily great. True — the Minister had not expressly spoken of a Jewish nation, and his remarks seemed, moreover, to have drawn in the Jews only in passing; but it was nevertheless the first time that the Jews had been designated from the Government bench as a factor distinct from the other nations. And the members of the Committee at once had the feeling, too, that the Minister's declaration, although, in order to ease the transition to the new conception, it made use of a cautiously negative form, nevertheless amounted to this alone: that the Galician Jews were to be regarded as an independent national element. The German deputy Ritter von Demel at once rose and declared:

"He must state with astonishment that in the speech of the Minister of the Interior the Jews are treated by the Government for the first time as a separate nationality in Austria. This must call forth a certain surprise, all the more so since this view does not, after all, exist among the gentlemen in Galicia (the Poles)."

And after him the German-nationalist deputy Kaiser gave expression to his astonishment,

"that the Governments had never before taken the standpoint of deducting the Jews from the Germans, — although he personally had no objection to make to this standpoint."

The German press had not yet properly recovered from its astonishment and had not yet got so far as to take up a position towards the new conception of the Jewish question, — it had hitherto been so convenient for the German Liberals to have themselves elected by the Jews, and for the antisemitic Germans to declare the Jews to be of a foreign nationality while nonetheless making use of them as "German voters" against the Slavs, — when the Jewish national problem once more emerged in the Electoral Reform Committee. The question of the Galician seats was under discussion. And there the minutes of the sitting record the following remarks of Deputy Dr. Bobrzynski: "The speaker points to the Zionist movement in Galicia and is of the opinion that the process of the assimilation of the Jews with the Poles has not yet advanced so far that one could count for all time upon the Polish sentiment of the whole of the Jewish population. It is therefore not out of the question that deputies may be elected who do not come forward as national Poles at all."