No. 26 — "Die Welt" — 11
(continued from page 10)
…into which I do not wish to enter further here. The Sanhedrin further resolved that every Jew, rabbi or layman, was forbidden to bless a marriage religiously unless it had first been concluded before the civil registrar. Concerning mixed marriage, finally, it reads: "The Great Sanhedrin further declares that marriages between Jews and Christians, contracted in accordance with the provisions of the civil code, are binding and civilly valid, and that, although they cannot receive the religious consecration, they may not be laid under the ban." This paragraph too has a somewhat sharper wording in the official Hebrew translation*).
The Jewish Parliament, and later the Sanhedrin opened with such pomp, created, as was only to be expected, a great stir in West European Jewry and awakened far-reaching hopes. For the people, enslaved and humiliated for centuries, the time of splendour and glory seemed now to have come once more. In those circles which were enthusiastic for a form of Judaism suited to the age, it was hoped that the Sanhedrin would satisfy these wishes. Men therefore watched the development of affairs in Paris with great suspense.
In Berlin, to be sure, in the circles of Friedländer and Bendavid, no great confidence was placed in the activity of the Sanhedrin. There men had the right feeling that reforms commanded from above, and not arising out of the people through an inner development, can be of no great value. Moreover, Berlin Jewry by no means shared the rapturous enthusiasm for Napoleon. It may further be remarked that the Prussian Government, too, regarded these proceedings with displeasure and was very unwilling to issue passports to its Jewish subjects for the journey to Paris for the purpose of taking part in the assembly of the Sanhedrin. This refusal can have availed it little, since the Jews could easily procure such passports from the French Residents. A victim of these extravagant expectations was the last Chief Rabbi of Silesia, Lewi Saul Fränkel, who on this news hastened to Paris in the hope that the time had now come when the dividing wall between Jews and Christians would cease to be. This gifted but mentally not quite sound enthusiast, whose father Saul had already, in the last years of Mendelssohn, presented a picture of inner disruption and divided mind, went over to Christianity after the closing of the Sanhedrin. He later repented of this step, however, and died poor and forsaken in the Jewish hospital at Frankfort-on-Main, and was buried there in the Jewish cemetery in all quietness.
For Judaism the Sanhedrin created nothing lasting, unless it be the consistorial constitution of the Jewish communities in France, whose worth and significance one need not rate too highly. On 1 January 1906, after an existence of nearly 100 years, it ceased to exist with the separation of Church and State that has taken place in the French Republic. Napoleon appears later, when his interest was claimed by weightier matters, to have paid little attention to the Jewish Parliament and the Sanhedrin. These bodies did not meet again. On the other hand, a law was nevertheless issued in the year 1808 by which full civil equality was withdrawn for a period of ten years from the Jews in Alsace and in the former German provinces. The boundless incense-burning before Napoleon was thus in truth useless.
*) Much was later said and written about this resolution of the Paris Sanhedrin. It was widely asserted that the Sanhedrin had permitted Jewish-Christian mixed marriage, for which it was praised on the one side but sharply censured on the other. I therefore give the French wording in its official text: "Le grand Sanhédrin déclare, en outre, que les mariages entre Israélites et chrétiens contractés conformément aux lois du code civil sont obligatoires et valables civilement et que, bien qu'ils ne soient pas susceptibles d'être revêtus des formes religieuses, ils n'entraîneront aucun anathème."
A "German-Jewish" Party
The Hamburg Israelitisches Familienblatt has taken a position on the creation of a "German-Jewish" party, allegedly intended on the Zionist side, in a lucubration which was made the subject of a rejoinder by the chairman of the German Landsmannschaft and at the same time relegated by its organ to the humorous corner. It is not my intention to consider which mode of treatment was the more justified, just as I do not wish to concern myself here with the Familienblatt at all. But it may well be fitting for once to come to terms with the idea of a Jewish party in Germany itself: Is it advisable, is it possible, to create a political party of the German Jews?
The Jews of Germany are at present represented neither in any of the German Diets nor in the German Reichstag. The Social Democratic party of the German Reichstag does indeed harbour a few Jews, while, significantly, all the remaining parliamentary groups have not sent a single Jew into the Reichstag. But no one will assert that the Jewish members of the Reichstag were elected by the Social Democratic party as representatives of the Jews. In the Prussian Diet Jews sit in 2 groups, naturally in the two Freisinnige ones. Among the 25 members of the People's Party 4, among the 8 of the Union 3, are of the Jewish faith. Thus, while all the other parties, the National Liberals included, are wholly and entirely Jew-free, 16 per cent of the People's Party and even 37½ per cent of the Freisinnige Union are Jews. That these gentlemen, too, were not elected as representatives of the Prussian Jews will be disputed neither by the leading lights of the Freisinnige parties nor by the Jewish deputies themselves; the latter in particular would probably protest emphatically against this "reproach." And even if the managers of the Freisinnige elections, after the experiences they have had in putting up their candidatures, may perhaps be inclined to ascribe the sending of Jews as representatives of the Freisinnige party to Jewish influence after all, no one will be able to deny that the Jewish gentlemen of the Chamber of Deputies have striven with all their might to wash this stain from themselves by a decided neglect of all Jewish interests and an equally decided championship of all non-Jewish questions.
It would be quite mistaken to suppose that the majority of the Jewish circles of Prussia and Germany here in question were not content with this state of things. The German Jews by no means wish to vote and be elected as Jews. Their ambition is satisfied when they are permitted to vote as members with equal rights of the Social Democratic and, in particular, of the Liberal parties. And if they are promised before the election that the party concerned will exert itself to see that somewhat less harm befalls the Jews than hitherto, then let anyone come to them with the assertion that the interests of the Jewish population are not sufficiently safeguarded by the existing parties! For, as the facts have shown, they are only too willing to give their Jewish vote even to an antisemite and Jew-devourer, if in return they receive from the National Liberal papers the testimonial that they have given a praiseworthy example of setting aside their own interests in favour of national considerations, an example which, unhappily, one often misses in others. The ill-humours which then regularly arise in the course of the session, because even the National Liberal Jew does, from time to time, distinctly have the feeling that he has been given a kick, or even a box on the ear, with the help or with the consent of his party, are then usually smoothed away at the party congresses and party dinners, and for the next session neither the Jewish vote nor the Jewish purse is lacking. But if things once grow altogether too bad, then at last a few Jewish deputies are accepted for a session too, so that it to the rule to
