Page 16 — "Die Welt" — No. 25
(continued from page 15)
…being fêted like a sovereign. After Lueger and the Christian-Social Director of the Vienna Magistracy, Deputy Weiskirchner, had been received in audience by the King on Saturday afternoon, Lueger visited the Exhibition. On his arrival he was greeted with salutes of honour. In the evening a banquet in Lueger's honour, given by the Bucharest municipality, took place in the great hall of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. After the Mayor of Bucharest, Cantacuzene, the son of the Prime Minister, had toasted the Emperor Francis Joseph, Lueger proposed a toast to King Carol and extolled the fact that His Majesty was closely acquainted with the conditions in the Vienna Municipal Council. Mayor Cantacuzene then assured Lueger, in German, of the love and veneration of the Roumanian people. Lueger replied that great difficulties had been put in his way to keep him from the journey to Bucharest; he had come nevertheless, since he knew he would find sincere friends here. The day of his arrival in Bucharest was the happiest day of his life.
In Vienna, however, nothing is known of any such alleged difficulties. Several Roumanian speakers then fêted Lueger as a great politician and statesman. When the Viennese antisemite Schneider thereupon spoke in French, he caused great merriment by his pronunciation and because he kept calling the Emperor Francis Joseph Monsieur l'Empereur. In conclusion Lueger and Cantacuzene embraced each other amid stormy enthusiasm."
Hitherto people have spoken of "Jewish solidarity." From now on one will be able to speak of "international antisemitic solidarity." Trepow-Pückler-Oldenburg-Cantacuzene-Lueger-Drumont... "Great minds meet" — but so do wicked ones.....
"THE POSITIVE ELEMENT IN POLITICAL ZIONISM"*)
"And it is remarkable," — says Mr. F. in his report on the German Delegates' Conference, No. 24 of this paper — "that it is precisely the staunchest 'anti-critics' of former days who stop at nothing and hold back no final conclusions, even when the foundations of the edifice of Zionist thought begin to tremble....."
If this reproach, addressed to the political Zionists, is to have any meaning, it can only be this: that the same men under the same circumstances have changed their course of action — for that altered circumstances call for an altered position is, after all, self-evident.
Do the political Zionists in fact deserve this reproach of inconsistency? By no means. The allegiance we rendered Theodor Herzl was no blind, dogmatic swearing in verba magistri, but the expression of an inner agreement with the aims and methods of our leader. Nor were they anything new to us. We had advocated the same ideas in the "Selbstemanzipation" and in the "Jüdische Volkszeitung" long before Herzl. Only we lacked the strength to turn the idea into the deed. For us Herzl was not an annunciation, but the beginning of fulfilment.
But when the great Master had died and other masters mounted the chair, who dethroned the truth of yesterday and raised that of the day before the day before yesterday upon the shield, then we "anti-critics" became critics; then we, who had been the most faithful support of the leadership, began to form an opposition to the old-new tendency.
It is not we who have changed our views, but the great majority of those who today would be regarded as the only genuine Zionists. And nowhere is there to be seen any corresponding turn in circumstances that could justify this change of mind. The inclination of the Porte to meet our wishes is certainly no greater since the Sixth Congress; the protection which the Russian Government is in a position and willing to afford us (for it is, after all, almost exclusively Russian Jews who come into question) has not become more reliable since the Japanese war and the pogroms of last year; the Turkish laws and administrative practices that obstruct civilisation are the same as before — nothing has occurred in the last three years that could justify our now extolling, as the right road leading directly to the goal, the path which until then we had considered impassable, nay, dangerous.
And yet — one thing, to be sure, had occurred which was calculated to reopen the whole complex of questions of Zionist tactics and in a certain respect to bring about a parting of minds. After years of fruitless efforts Herzl had come to the conviction that the resistance of Turkey to the Zionist plans could not be broken within any foreseeable time. And since the flight of the Jews from the Eastern countries was assuming ever greater proportions, while the countries of immigration were beginning more and more to close themselves to the immigration of Jews, Herzl entered into negotiations with the English Government in order to obtain a land in which a part of the Jewish refugees might found a Jewish commonwealth on a national, autonomous basis. Although I was from the beginning an enthusiastic adherent of this project, and in principle (as soon as the suitable land is found — that is to say: "land-seekers!") still am, I can nevertheless understand the standpoint of those who offered it vehement and successful opposition. I grant that one may hold the view (I do not share it) that the work for the Uganda project would have drawn off all its forces from Zionism, whose task is the recovery of the land of our fathers; that success on any soil other than that of the ancient national home is altogether out of the question; and whatever else is brought forward against the Uganda project and "Itoism." But that, together with the rejection of this project, the watchword could be issued to create a platform in Palestine itself — once more, as formerly, to bring people into the country by back doors, to found agricultural and industrial undertakings, on however shaky a legal basis — that is something for which, even after the Hanover Delegates' Conference, I still lack all understanding.
I already hear the objection, to be sure: that is written nowhere! Certainly. But let us not deceive ourselves: in reality it cannot happen otherwise. The prohibition of immigration exists, after all, so that immigration, though possible, is nonetheless not legal. And is it not a shaky legal basis when the land bought, or to be bought, with the means of the National Fund belongs not to the National Fund, not to the Jewish people, not to the Colonial Bank, but to Chaskel and Sorach? Chaskel and Sorach are very trustworthy people; of their possible legal successors we can no longer be so certain; but all these intricate Levantine business manipulations do not look like the road that leads to the liberation of a people.
Now Mr. F. reproaches us with offering only negatives, while they, the Zione Zion, possess a positive programme. That may in a certain sense be granted. But what matters is not that something be done, but that something purposeful be done. In medicine one has the "ut
*) Editor's note: As Mr. F. has left for Bjelostok, his reply will not appear until next week.