"Die Welt" — No. 25 — Page 17
(continued from page 16)
…aliquid fiat" long since abandoned, and the "ut aliquid fieri videatur" has already lost every vestige of credit.
Since, for the reasons indicated above, we do not consider colonising work in Palestine at the present time to be purposeful, and since the resolution of the Seventh Congress concerning colonising work outside Palestine has not yet been rescinded, our programme is indeed of a merely negative kind insofar as we see no possibility at present for Zionism to perform practical work in the present. But we do not on that account lose heart or despair. The older men among us were for the most part Zionists already before there was a Congress, a Zionist Organisation or a Zionist press, and before the non-Jewish world and the great majority of the Jews themselves knew anything at all of our aspirations. Our chances then were decidedly much, much worse than now; in the meantime Herzl has, after all, led us a good stretch of the way further. But even then we had the certainty that we shall attain our goal, that we must attain it. We drew it from the recognition that the inner development of the Jewish people, as well as the development of the relations of the Jewish people to the other peoples, presses with the necessity of nature towards the solution of the Jewish Question in the sense of Zionism. This tendency of development appears more clearly in the present than ever; therefore, despite the momentarily unfavourable political constellation, we look into the future with the greatest confidence. Development goes on. We no more create it than Social Democracy creates social development. Just as the latter sees its most essential task in enlightening the masses about the tendency of social development, strengthening their class-consciousness and preparing them for the coming order of society, so it is also our task, by untiring agitation, to enlighten Jews and non-Jews (both are concerned in it) about the tendency of development of the Jewish Question, to prepare the Jewish people for the coming conditions, and to create and build up the organisations which are to effect the transition into the new conditions. Political negotiations cannot be carried on without interruption, but one must at all times be armed to take them up with success at the suitable moment.
That is our positive programme, and it seems to us not much poorer than that of our friends, the Zione Zion.
L. Estermann.
THE "NECESSITY"
I have no intention of polemicising against the article by Mr. Estermann which appears in this number. But I should like to bring out one point which in my opinion is more important than the purely external and political difference between the "Political" and the "General" Zionists. It is an ideological difference. And as such it is of incisive significance.
Zionism has often changed its ideological foundation. The old Zionists of the stamp of the "Chowewe-Zion" founded their Zionism on the people's yearning for Zion, on historical tradition, on the immovable and indestructible faith of the Jews in a free future. The pious, the Orthodox, believed in the same thing after their fashion, but clothed their faith in a different formula, and this formula — Messianism — fettered them, and set up psychical barriers against the translation of the dream into deeds.
Modern Zionism in its beginnings was not a "scientifically" grounded movement. Herzl did not write his "Jewish State" out of a theoretical recognition of the elemental, irresistible course of history. On the contrary, Herzl's view of the world stood in contradiction to the materialist conception of history. He had grasped Zionism and sought to put it into practice by appealing to the will of the people, by coming and saying: "If you wish to live free and independent and sovereign, then declare yourselves for Zionism." That was the original Zionism in Herzl's sense. From his conception of life and of history, from his emphasis on the element of will and personality in politics, he derived his whole political method, his tactics in Zionism. Whether his theory was a correct one or not — in any case it could not be the last word of Zionist ideology. And indeed it developed in two directions — towards a further, higher stage, which sometimes looks like negation, on the one hand, and towards a rigid affirmation which leads to self-dissolution, on the other.
The one party — and that is the majority of Zionists — has developed further Herzl's fundamental idea, the idea of willing and of acting, and has drawn the quite logical conclusion that it is not the form in which the idea is realised that matters, but the process itself. Herzl's theory was that of the creative will. "If you will it, it is no fairy tale." What is more natural than to draw from this the conclusion that, if one regards the will of the people as the highest ingredient, the means of embodying the will of the people must also correspond to it? The extension of this theory is Zionism in its present, clearly crystallised form. Because the people does not wish to set its present in opposition to its future, because we do not wish to cleave, shatter, tear asunder the will of the people, because we regard the will as existing, as awake, only when it is converted into deeds — therefore we have stood up for a policy of slow but sure, purposeful, practical activity in Palestine.
But the idea of Herzl has undergone a quite remarkable transformation with some of his staunchest adherents. And I will assume that Mr. Estermann's argument is the clearest and most precise rendering of the ideology of these developers.
To convert the idea of will in history into that of an immanent, objective necessity — that amounts to very nearly abolishing it altogether. And this transformation Mr. Estermann has accomplished — perhaps without noticing it.
The line of proof of the ideologists of doctrinaire "political" Zionism is roughly this: Every historical movement is necessary. By virtue of inner causality, by virtue of a dialectical development, this or that historical phenomenon must come about, this or that movement must assume a definite form and prevail. So it is with Social Democracy, so it is also with Zionism. This too is a historically conditioned, and consequently unavoidable and irresistible, movement. And if that is once so, then one need only await the course of events — for time, after all, is working for us.
It is a transference of concepts that can bring only obscurity into theory and confusion into life.
This is hardly the place to subject the materialist conception of history, the philosophy of necessity and of historical causality, to criticism. Nowadays there are hardly many thinking Socialists who believe in the "natural necessity" of the social revolution. Why, by