Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 23 · 8 June 1906
11printed page
scan 11 of 24
Facsimile · scan 11 of 24
Scan of p. 11
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 23 — "Die Welt" — Page 11.

(continued from page 10)

…Jewish orphan children. The mistakes made in the placing of the Kishineff orphans ought to give us pause. It is pedagogical nonsense and financial waste to found an educational institution for a single generation of children that happens to present itself by chance. An institution that does not continually renew itself, but that, through the children's growing up and growing out of it, is inwardly dying from the very first day, is impossible. If we wish to found such an institution, it must constitute a permanent institution. But then extraordinarily large funds are necessary, which we can scarcely create within any foreseeable time. — The speaker then combats the utterances of the tendency hostile to work in Palestine. National-cultural work alone is impossible. The schools are financially dependent on non-national philanthropic societies and can be raised only if they become financially independent through initiative aimed at the creation of such cultural funds as could find cultural application in our sense. — Those who are against practical work in Palestine are working against their own principles. Chowewe-Zionist immigration and work proceed in Palestine of their own accord, without our doing. It lies with us, through supervision and organising intervention, to turn this work from a Chowewe-Zionist one into one of political-Zionist character. Whoever does not do this, or prevents it, bears alone the responsibility for misguided, disastrous work in Palestine. Not only from outside, but also from within Palestine itself, from our colonies, comes the fervent call for helpful, restorative intervention by Zionism. Whoever does not take account of this unspeakable, despairing longing also takes upon himself the responsibility when precious Jewish human material leaves the country. It is not Palestine that bears the blame for this misery, but those who hinder the work of economic development in Palestine. (Applause.)

Dr. Sandler, Breslau, asks the physicians present to meet together in the afternoon for a conference, in order to deliberate on practical measures for the extermination of malaria in Jerusalem. The task, he says, is technically not so difficult and not so costly as in other centres of malaria. The speaker further asks that care be taken for a wider circulation of the periodical "Altneuland" among the German Zionists, and recommends that the Esra branch societies also be interested in the periodical.

Dr. Soskin, Berlin: Yesterday it was declared here by Prof. Warburg that the leadership of the movement undertakes nothing in Palestine that has not been resolved by the Congress, but that the personal views of the Commission are that colonisation and the present current towards Palestine are to be welcomed. One must surely be clear that preliminary work and experiments must lead to colonisation. The "Politicals," if they are against colonisation, would have to abolish the Palestine Commission as well. That would be the proper consequence. We do not conceal from ourselves the difficulties of the work, but we wish nevertheless to create the real foundations of a regulated settlement. As regards an unregulated, planless colonisation of Palestine, we have always opposed it. We have never approved the founding of colonies; indeed, when 2 1/2 years ago the Actions Committee addressed to the Palestine Commission the inquiry in what manner a colony might be created for the Kishineff Jews, it replied that we are against the founding of colonies. These, it said, must arise of themselves, as a consequence of our systematic preliminary work. Now too the Russian A. C., in view of the greater immigration into Palestine, has warned against precipitancy. The economic possibilities for newcomers in a half-cultivated country are slight, and a catastrophe — the departure of the elements that have come in — would be bound to follow. Mr. Estermann pointed out that the other nations would long since have exploited the good economic conditions of Palestine if an investment of capital there were profitable. I remark on this that the other nations have better opportunities for investment in other countries, but we must concentrate our work on Palestine, even though the difficulties are great. One chief consideration that speaks for Palestine is, among other things, also that it has only 15% of the population it could hold. Therefore we must create for ourselves there, as soon as possible, an economic and numerical majority, and, for the consolidation of our position in Palestine, enter at once into competition with the other nations. (Lively applause.)

After some further speakers had spoken briefly, the motions received now come to the vote. A motion according to which a Palestine levy should be collected by the local groups, to raise, and up to the maximum amount of, the 15,000 Mk. granted by the Congress to the Palestine Commission, was rejected.

The following motion was adopted by 40 votes to 25:

The Delegates' Conference resolves upon the introduction of a Palestine contribution of at least 1 Mk. for the members of the "Zionistische Vereinigung von Deutschland," further, by 34 votes to 17, the following resolution, brought in by Julius Simon, Mannheim, was adopted:

"The Delegates' Conference welcomes the proposal of Dr. Moses, Mannheim, concerning the founding of a Palestine Society."

Next a motion of Zlocisti, Berlin, comes to the vote, reading:

"The Delegates' Conference of the German Zionists sees in every encouragement of immigration into Palestine by the A.C. a danger to the political work for Palestine, and declines the moral responsibility with regard to the immigration."

This motion, for which a roll-call vote is demanded and agreed to without opposition, is rejected by 40 votes to 33, amid great excitement caused by the ambiguous wording of the motion. The rejection is received with great applause.

Close of the 3rd Session.

Closing Session

At 3 o'clock in the afternoon the closing session is opened by the President, Dr. Bodenheimer, with the following declaration: It has been assumed by some that the Zlocisti motion implied that, inasmuch as the movers decline all responsibility for an encouragement of emigration to Palestine by the A.C., there lay therein implicite an assumption of responsibility on the part of those who voted against this motion because they considered it altogether out of place. I ask that it be entered in the minutes that, in the opinion of the Bureau, there is not the slightest occasion for such a construction; it is, on the contrary, self-evident that anyone could vote against the motion without assuming the responsibility for the encouragement of emigration to Palestine.

Finally, a motion of the Cartel of Zionist Student Societies was adopted, reading:

"Since the Cartel of Zionist Student Societies, as well as the societies united in it, regard themselves, in accordance with a resolution of the Cartel, as members of the Zionist Organisation, may the Delegates' Conference propose that the Zionist local groups support the Cartel of Zionist Student Societies in the propagation of Zionism among the young. In particular, may the local groups be induced to persuade those leaving the gymnasium to join the Zionist student societies."

Thereupon the debates were closed and the elections held. Rechtsanwalt Dr. Bodenheimer was re-elected chairman by acclamation amid great applause. To the Central Bureau were elected almost unanimously Messrs. Dr. Hantke, Dr. Leszynski and Wollsteiner; to the Central Committee, Messrs.: Dr. Adler, Dr. Elias, Dr. Friedemann, Dr. Gronemann, Dr. Halpern, Dr. Hantke, Dr. Kalmus, Dr. Kaufmann, Dr. Klee, Dr. Kollenscher, Hugo Schachtel and Julius Simon.

Dr. Bodenheimer thereupon gave a short résumé of the Delegates' Conference, in which he said, among other things: "We are, that is certain, all agreed that our movement is a political one. The question of Territorialism is entirely eliminated from the Zionist movement of Germany. And so long as the 'Ito' presents nothing clear with regard to its plans and intentions, there is no occasion for us to take up any position towards it. I hope that after this Delegates' Conference, at which opinions have been clarified, peace and unity in our movement are restored." (Lively applause.)

With words of thanks from Mr. Gustav Schwabe to the chairmen, which were warmly acclaimed by the Delegates' Conference, and with a demonstration of sympathy for the President of the A.-C., Mr. David Wolffsohn, the tenth Delegates' Conference closed.

A large number of letters of congratulation and telegrams from individuals and organisations had been received by the Delegates' Conference, among them one from the President of the A.-C., David Wolffsohn, in which he stated that the Actions Committee holds unswervingly to the political character of the movement, while always keeping in view the indispensably necessary preliminary work for Palestine. The letter was received with lively applause and answered with a telegram of greeting. To the widow of Theodor Herzl, too, the Delegates' Conference, at the suggestion of Dr. Friedemann, sent a telegram couched in cordial terms.