8 — DIE WELT — No. 22
(continued from page 7)
…Social Democracy too is a great party in Vienna. . . . Whoever truly wishes to further the development of this city, whoever wishes purposefully to shape this great community, this abode of untiring labour, cannot stride over the workers. . . . Today Vienna has spoken, and what has it declared? What Social Democracy has to fight out with the Viennese Christian Socials is another matter, but that, strictly speaking, concerns no one but these two parties themselves. But who came forward in this election, who could come forward? The two parties that are for electoral reform!"
The only lesson, then, that the leading Socialist paper draws from the electoral struggle is thus not, say, a vow to fight against the antisemitic tyranny until its collapse, — no, on the contrary, it holds out its hand to Herr Lueger in alliance. That these effusions were meant thus and not otherwise is proved by the answer of the antisemitic Moniteur the following day. The "Deutsches Volksblatt" writes on 11 May: "How justified, however, this feeling prevailing among the electorate is, appears from the article in which the "Arbeiterzeitung" discusses Wednesday's election result. Dr. Adler's paper deals very gently (sic!) with the Christian Socials; one reads nothing of storm signals announcing the collapse of the ruling party in the Town Hall; no, rather there rings out from the closing lines of the article something like an offer of compromise. Dr. Adler offers the Christian Socials his honest right hand if they will help him bring the Gautsch electoral reform under roof."
Herr Vergani rejects Herr Adler's honest right hand; this, however, alters nothing in the fact that Herr Adler was ready to give it to him. I shall surely be one of the last to expect or to demand of the Social Democrats that they expose themselves on behalf of the Jews; but that the Viennese Social Democrats, immediately after the victory which they owe not least to their Jewish comrades and fellow-travellers, should have the effrontery to offer an alliance to the Christian Socials and to praise them as a people's party "which has sunk its roots deep in the soil," is too characteristic of the spirit of the Viennese leaders and of the comrades they lead for us not to nail it down. The victory of Social Democracy — however much it may signify politically, since it foretells for them the sure gain of several mandates at the next elections to the Reichsrat — has nothing to say to the Jews.
One must not, indeed, confuse the Social Democracy of the German Empire with the Austrian, though the former too has a good deal to answer for; one need only think of the resistance which the Social Democracy of the German Empire offers to the organization of a Polish party. This naturally does not prevent me from remembering with grateful acknowledgment the truly humane spirit which the German Social Democratic fraction in the Reichstag has repeatedly expressed in the discussion of the Russian Jewish question. In Austrian Social Democracy one will look in vain for a spontaneous championing of the Jewish cause; when, of necessity, it must join in analogous initiatives coming from another side, then regard for the Jewish votes — to which, for instance, the chieftain Daszynski owes his mandate — plays the first part, a consideration which certainly plays no part with the Social Democrats of the German Empire, since no one can maintain that a million Social Democratic votes are furnished by the Jews of Germany, who number in all half a million souls.
However much, therefore, the defeat of the Viennese Christian Socials is to be welcomed in a negative sense, in a positive sense the Social Democratic victory means nothing for the Jews.
But the significance of the Vienna elections is not thereby exhausted. No one sheds a tear for the Liberals. Yet it must surely awaken reflection in Jewish circles when, in the Leopoldstadt, in the second electoral body, Christian Socials were elected in place of the Liberals. The Leopoldstadt is the sore point of Austrian-Jewish politics; but one must lay one's finger on this wound, even at the risk of destroying many an illusion.
According to the last census (1900), out of a total population of 1,674,957 inhabitants, 146,926 Jews are resident in Vienna. For the elections the districts chiefly to be considered are I, II, IX and XX — Innere Stadt, Leopoldstadt, Alsergrund and Brigittenau — in which the Jews live in greater density. The proportion is as follows: District I: total population 58,503, among them 11,393 Jews (against 43,365 Catholics). District II: total population 144,365, among them 52,543 Jews (against 87,343 Catholics). District IX: total population 94,582, among them 17,206 Jews (against 73,123 Catholics). District XX: total population 71,445, among them 11,234 Jews (against 58,504 Catholics).
We see, then, that no Viennese district shows a Jewish majority; even the Leopoldstadt, which Herr Lueger has christened the "Jews' island," shows only a Jewish minority, a strong one admittedly. The proportion between Jews and non-Jews in the Leopoldstadt is roughly 1 : 2. Numerically it is somewhat more favourable; in reality it is, as I shall show later, much less favourable.
Such minorities as the Jewish ones can find their proper expression only under proportional elections. The Gautsch electoral reform bill now before us, however, excludes this method for Vienna. It proposes instead, in order that the minorities may nevertheless have a voice, that individual districts be divided into smaller units for the election. Thus the Leopoldstadt is divided into two electoral districts, one of which is more densely inhabited by Jews than the other. The Inner City is divided into four parts, of which the Quai quarter is densely inhabited by Jews. Probably the more Aryan Rossau will also be separated from the Alsergrund, and in the remaining part the Jews will be offered better chances. I will also mention in passing that the fourth district (Wieden) receives two mandates, although it numbers only 59,996 inhabitants, among them 2990 Jews. The millions of Rothschild procure the Christian Socials a second mandate; that is the irony of history. In the distribution of mandates, namely, regard is had not only to the number of inhabitants but also to the amount of taxes paid. Now Rothschild resides in the Wieden and guarantees the antisemites a second mandate for the foreseeable future. At the last elections in the Wieden, in the fourth electoral body (general class of voters), 1085 Social Democratic votes were cast against 3684 Christian Social.
To return now to our main subject, I cannot, under present conditions, regard the auspices of independent Jewish candidatures as favourable, even in the quasi-Jewish electoral districts of Vienna.
As I mentioned earlier, the proportion between Jews and non-Jews in the Leopoldstadt (and correspondingly in the other districts) is much less favourable than the figures seem to promise. There live in Vienna, namely, some 140,280 Hungarian citizens, half of them Jews, who naturally have no vote at the political elections, the greater part of them in the Leopoldstadt and the Inner City. The number of electors of the second district is 26,694. At the last elections 8048 voted for the Christian Socials and only 7381 for the Social Democrats. This proportion would naturally be sharpened still further to the disadvantage of the Jews in the case of independent Jewish candidatures. Mutatis mutandis this holds also for the other districts.
Nevertheless I am far from describing a national Jewish policy in Vienna as hopeless. On the contrary, I have worked for this idea for years and regard matters more favourably today than formerly. But one must keep before one's eyes that the situation is far more complicated than many believe.
In order to put forward national candidatures in Vienna with any prospect of success, there is needed a heavy, but not impossible, labour of detail and of preparation, of which I scarcely see the beginnings today. I do not speak of the self-evidently necessary agitation to wrest the greater part of the Viennese Jews from the assimilationist spirit which today makes them swear by the Social Democratic banner, just as yesterday they swore by the Liberal. Even if we had gathered all the Jews of Vienna under the national banner, which is still far off, we should, rebus sic stantibus, have no successes at the general elections. We can achieve them only if the Hungarian Jews of Vienna, one and all, were to obtain the franchise in Vienna. That is not impossible under the new Law of Domicile; the Christian Social rulers, to be sure, have sought to bar the way to it by carrying through — against the spirit of the law — that every foreign citizen must pay a maximum fee of 600 Kronen upon admission into the Viennese municipal community. Naturally, for Jewish applicants the maximum fee becomes the minimum fee. Here purposeful work must set in. But this work must indeed be done; without it I hold a victory of our political Austrian ideas to be out of the question, although I know that conditions in the east of the Monarchy are more favourable for the political activity of the Jews than in the west. Much may also be achieved in Vienna by a sensible policy of compromise with non-antisemitic parties, as soon as we have become a power here. But we shall be a power only — that is my personal conviction — when we shall have accomplished the indispensably necessary labour of detail here indicated.