Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 22 · 1 June 1906
9printed page
scan 5 of 18

No. 22 — "Die Welt" — Page 9

PRESENT AND FUTURE

By DR. SIMON BERNFELD *)

Ever since the beginning of the Zionist movement I have consistently held the view that Zionism must embrace all the labours that aim at furthering the material prosperity and the intellectual development of the Jewish people. Consequently all other Jewish organisations which, wholly or in part, pursue the same endeavours are akin to Zionism and helpful to our movement. We differ from them only in respect of the final goal; for whereas those organisations strive merely for the preservation of the Jewish people and of Judaism in the Diaspora, we are convinced, first, that a wholly satisfactory solution of the Jewish question is not possible without the creation of a political centre for the Jewish people, and, secondly, that Judaism, as a national and cultural phenomenon, cannot unfold in its historic individuality amid alien surroundings.

In any case, however, it must stand firm for us that the so-called "work for the present," which many of us urgently demanded years ago, is truly Zionist only if it does not lose sight of the final goal. Otherwise there is no purpose whatever in holding ourselves apart from the other organisations. We must do precisely that which would not be done without us, and which only we can do. Even in Palestine a good deal is now being done from other quarters, and our work there would have a particular value only if it were done in the spirit of our national aspirations. In other words, our work, however modest it may be by reason of our limited means, can distinguish itself from that of the others not in quantity but in quality. The same holds, for instance, in the question of emigration. The Zionist Organisation certainly cannot compete in it with the other great relief organisations that dispose of so many millions; but it would indeed be a beneficent task for us to see that the emigrants in their new home remain true to the national idea.

Of late, for various reasons, we have had to confine ourselves to the programme of the present, and in the sphere of high politics things have grown fairly quiet. That is no fault, for politics cannot be made at will at any time. We Jews least of all can do so, since we have only to seize a suitable moment when it presents itself to us. It is in itself a great merit of the Zionist Organisation that it stands upon the watch-tower, so as not to let the favourable opportunity pass unused when one day it offers itself to the Jewish people. It is otherwise with the inner work, which likewise strives towards the attainment of our final goal. Certainly we are often disturbed in this from without; but the Jewish people has, after all, learned in the many centuries of its history of suffering to defy outward circumstances and to maintain its existence under the most unfavourable conditions. This life outside the conditions of time and place presupposes, to be sure, a strong national force, which lends the Jewish people a strong national will. I confess openly that of late the existence of this force and of this will in the Jewish people has become doubtful to me. But in any case it is the task of Zionism to awaken and to strengthen among the Jews the will to national life. All work for the present can have this one aim only before its eyes, and all of it must likewise be tested by whether it leads to this aim.

The political events in Russia have dealt Zionism a heavy blow. Above all through the fact that these events


*) Editor's note. We shall return to the observations of our esteemed contributor, with which we cannot identify ourselves in their full content.


claim the entire interest of the Jews. Moreover, we cannot conceal that many who formerly found no other way out for the Russian Jews than emigration, and hoped to be able to shape it in the Zionist sense, now believe in another solution of the Jewish question in Russia and have therefore drawn away from Zionism. Against this we can do nothing. The great mass will not be taught. And at present that would be all the more difficult, as a large part of the Russian Jews is positively hypnotised by socialist ideas. Whatever does not accord with the doctrine of the international proletariat arouses in those circles nothing but scorn and mockery. I do not doubt that if an Isaiah were now to arise among us and venture the faintest contradiction of Kautsky, he would be rejected by a part of the Jewish youth as a "besotted bourgeois." But because this lies in the character of our time, it is still not necessary that Zionism should either follow the fashion entirely or remain passive. Precisely now its task would be to hold fast to the national idea and to faith in the future of our people — to do what the others, in their political paroxysm, neglect or even hinder with all fanaticism. It matters not at all whether we thereby lose former camp-followers. We gain nothing if we water down our programme in order to draw the mass over to us; but we do a very great deal if, in this deluge of destruction, we seek to maintain a fixed point, to which later, when disillusion sets in one way or another, all nationally minded Jews, or more correctly all Jews, will after all take refuge.

We have been told that the emancipation of the Russian Jews, which was close at hand, would be of quite another kind than the emancipation of the West European Jews. For whereas our kinsmen in Western Europe strove only for an individual liberation, the emancipation of the Russian Jews is to be a national one, and this does not presuppose assimilation. Before I reply to this, I must clear up the misunderstanding that I expected of the Russian Jews that they should reject civil rights for fear of threatening assimilation. If civic equality is granted them, most of them will undoubtedly make use of it and will not let themselves be deterred by the danger of assimilation. I demand only that we, made wise by experience, should not now repeat the mistake that was made some hundred years ago in the West European states, and in consequence of which a dreadful devastation arose in the Jewish people. The premises in Russia are the same as they were, for example, in Austria-Hungary. Emancipation there has led to this: that smaller sections have detached themselves from the mass, while the mass itself, robbed of its leadership, decays in poverty and ignorance.

It is no consolation to us that Jewish national life has hitherto been well developed among the Russian Jews. It was no different in Germany too. So long as the public schools remained closed to the Jewish youth, it received its education in private schools, learned Hebrew and was brought up in the Jewish spirit. Things certainly did not look a hundred years ago as they look in Germany now. I need only recall that when, in the year 1818, the well-known Temple controversy broke out in Hamburg, which violently stirred the whole of West European Jewry, the polemic on both sides was conducted almost exclusively in the Hebrew language, because a knowledge of that language could still be presupposed in all educated Jews. Not a soul, at the beginning of the emancipation movement, believed that with