Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 21 · 25 May 1906
9printed page
scan 7 of 20
Facsimile · scan 7 of 20
Scan of p. 9
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 21. — "Die Welt" — Page 9.

(continued from page 8)

…has cause to feel the people of the state. This character of an absolute state of nationalities, however, means a very great deal for the endeavours of the Jewish people after national equality of rights. The absence of a national master of the house, the most dangerous opponent because the most jealous, is decidedly to be entered on the credit side.

It must not be overlooked, to be sure, that the Germans for a time laid claim to be the Austrian people of the state kat exochen. And even if to-day only scanty remnants of this view survive, which will hardly ever again be called upon to exert general practical effects, — towards the Jewish claims they remain at all events only a hostile disposition. And this disposition is further strengthened by what remains of the assimilatory tradition, which is, so to speak, native to the soil in the German people. But dispositions too evaporate gradually, once their immediate exciting causes have vanished and forces working in the opposite direction have taken their place. In our case: when the development of Austria shall have destroyed to the end the dream, already, alas, so pale, of its Germans to be the people of the state, and the advancing Jewish renaissance their senile assimilation ideology, become full of contradictions in its old age and tinged with antisemitism. In the end they must, after all, come to say to themselves: Better than if they accrue to others, — and to rejoice that matters are at last cleared up.

The Poles are quite other people. Of greater consequence if only because they regard the Galician Jews, that is, the by far preponderant majority and the most nationally marked part of Austrian Jewry, as belonging to their special sphere of interest, they are the most dangerous and the most irreconcilable. One need not even inquire whether the Pole is inclined to national intolerance at all, or whether one has to do with caste outrages of the Schlachta, the Polish nobility; the constitutional position of the Poles in Galicia suffices for an explanation. They play in this province the part which the Germans once claimed for the whole of Austria, the part of the Polish people of the state. For them there is no doubt that Galicia is a Polish land, although they actually make up hardly half of the population, and the other half consists of the Ruthenians, who nearly equal them in number, and of the Jews. From this fiction, however, the greater vehemence of their resistance to Jewish-national endeavours after equality of rights follows of itself.

Yet their privileged position has already begun to totter. Doom is advancing upon them from two sides. On the one side in the form of the growing democratic movement, which threatens politically to dispossess the representative of Polish power-nationalism, the Schlachta, and certainly will dispossess it. On the other side as the revolt of the Ruthenians against the manner of national nullification hitherto favoured towards them. In the present Austrian electoral-reform campaign both movements have come forward a good step. The Poles, for their part, are now indeed making efforts to extend the provincial autonomy of Galicia. But even should they have some success with this — an ample extension is, moreover, wholly out of the question for the present —, they will nevertheless not be able to maintain their sole dominion in the land. It is going infallibly to its end, and that is the significant thing for us. For in the face of a democratic Polish Galicia, and with the more or less helpful assent of Ruthenian Galicia, the Jews have better prospects.

It would be little agreeable, to be sure, if the development went somewhat too far, if it went so far that the Ruthenians obtained the fulfilment of their demand, now put forward more for purposes of demonstration, for the division of Galicia into a western Polish and an eastern Ruthenian province. Then the West

Galician Jews would have to take on the Poles alone, and the East Galician Jews the Ruthenians alone. But this eventuality lies at all events at so great a distance that by then the Jews may have advanced sufficiently in inner rallying and outward organisation of their forces to be able to carry through, or rather to maintain, their national equality of rights on the ground of the State as a whole. Moreover, the Ruthenians, among whom two-thirds of the Galician Jews live, will have to take into account the conditions of neighbouring Bukovina, in which their kinsmen have to reckon upon the goodwill of the Jews.

As regards the Czechs, no resistance is to be expected from their side. For they have had only harm from assimilation, which appeared chiefly as German assimilation. Recent times, it is true, have produced a Czech assimilation as well. And whoever knows the conditions must even admit that, since it shows more criticism and self-criticism, more true struggle, than the German, it is less unsympathetic. Nevertheless, neither on this side nor on that does one know what to do with it. It lacks the necessary tradition, and in its youth it strikes one as doubly anachronistic.

Social Democracy, as represented by its leaders, is to-day a bitter enemy of all endeavours that tend towards a recognition of the Jewish nationality as such. But precisely its resistance is the least to be taken seriously, because it will and must be paralysed by the inwardly working nature of this party. Just as it has in general already departed a good way in emancipating itself from the anational and antinational velleities of its men of dogma, so will it also disavow its present dogmatists of assimilation. Above all, the Jewish leaders, who have stood still at the oldest liberal bourgeois standpoint, will not be able to hold their own against the onrushing East-Jewish proletariat. In national questions Social Democracy, just because it devotes itself predominantly to the social question, is somewhat slow of understanding; on the other hand, it never skips a point that must be understood.

The chief guarantee of an eventual success of the Jewish endeavours after national equality of rights, however, is and remains the Austrian State as a whole itself. From it, from its nature, the Austrian Jews can ever draw fresh confidence whenever the struggle grows hotter at any point and the prospects darken. Nor need they reckon with the dilettante prophecy of Austria's speedy downfall. To-day in serious circles the explanation of Austria as a state that exists only for the sake of the Habsburg dynasty is rated no higher than, say, the "scientific" definition of religion as a police institution of the propertied classes. To-day it is known that Austria is a political and economic necessity for the fragments of peoples that dwell upon her territory. To-day one sees in Austria the battlefield on which one of the greatest and most beneficent ideas of the future will have to fight one of its most blessed battles. To-day one may hope for a strengthening and rejuvenation of Austria on the basis of national autonomy.

From this the part of the Jewish people that lives in Austria can, will and must profit. Naturally, for the success, and especially for its greater or lesser speed, much depends on how the Austrian Jews proceed, whether they do not permit themselves the luxury of too many omissions, rash steps and roundabout ways. Above all they must naturally be clear in broad outline as to what they have to do.

II.

It would be the greatest mistake if the Austrian Jews confined themselves to pursuing merely politics in the narrower sense, party and parliamentary politics. This can accomplish anything real and lasting only when behind it ge-