DIE WELT
No. 20
GRAVE THOUGHTS
By Dr. SIMON BERNFELD
The events in Russia, so far as they concern our people, are developing as by their nature they must develop. It would be wasted effort to wish to influence them theoretically, or even to set oneself against the popular currents. I have come to the point where I no longer believe in the educative significance and efficacy of history. Every people that awakens to political life always begins as the others before it began. No people lets itself be taught by historical analogies and held back from errors; each must simply make its first attempts at walking for itself, and naturally come to harm in doing so as well.
The centre of gravity of Jewish national life has hitherto been in Russia, where national substance was in fact to be found among the Jews. But whether it will remain so in the future has now become very doubtful to me. Years ago, when even the optimists among us could scarcely still believe in the possibility that the situation of the Russian Jews would improve, the question was discussed at length in the Jewish press whether the national movement among us was a natural one, proceeding from within, or merely the consequence of the pressure exerted upon us from without. I myself, I will openly confess it, inclined rather to the latter view. And not only that: it was also clear to me that among the Russian Jews, if civil equality were offered them in Russia, the Jewish national idea would then have to suffer a far-reaching weakening. One cannot even complain of this, for however sad the denationalisation of our people is in itself, experience has nevertheless taught that the Jews cannot resist this temptation. At the very first attempts at emancipation which the Emperor Joseph II made in Austria, Mendelssohn expressed his misgivings about it in a letter to Homberg. He foresaw, namely, that the benevolent treatment of the Jews would lead more quickly to assimilation than the cruel and inhuman treatment of earlier centuries.
Where I was mistaken is only in this phenomenon, that a large part of the Russian Jews did not even wait until equal rights should come. The mere possibility, the hope of an improvement in their situation, sufficed to call forth an upheaval in the cultural respect.
As has been said, one cannot fight with arguments of logic against a popular current that appears with elemental force. I know of only one publicist of note among the Russian Jews who has remained consistent and true to himself — Achad Haam. But we see how he has fared of late, how all the parties, however disunited they might be among themselves, concurred in this: to eliminate this man from public life. The most disquieting thing in it, moreover, is that the people is in its right, or at least seems to be. It is in fact no trifle when one lives in political and economic servitude and the hope beckons of being able to escape from this distress. The people is not conscious that this is bound up with the destruction of its national life, because this cessation of national individuality does not come about all at once, but gradually. One fears sudden death and the poison that leads to it; but one does not fear the slow-working poison, especially when it is so sweet and pleasant.
The Russian Jews will, whether more slowly or more rapidly, go through the same process of development that the Western European Jews went through in the 19th century. And they will also quite certainly experience the same disappointments. In this conviction I am not in the least disturbed by the attitude of the progressive elements towards the Jewish question; the cry "Equality, Liberty and Fraternity," which now resounds everywhere in Russia, alters nothing whatever in the matter. Exactly so was the course of events in all the Western European states, and when in the springtime of the nations everything stood so fair and blooming, all sang the song of equality and fraternity. It is, however, a well-known fact that almost all the spokesmen of the liberal movement of the year 1848, so far as they lived to see it, afterwards coquetted with reaction and with antisemitism, or even openly allied themselves with them. The only exception is formed by those states where the Jews were few in number and assimilated rapidly. And even there I am not yet sure whether hatred of the Jews does not still smoulder beneath the ashes.
Certainly, historical experiences are neither mathematical nor logical theorems. It is indeed not impossible that things will shape themselves differently in Russia. But that would be in the highest degree improbable. We must surely be prepared that the reaction will set in sooner or later; until then, however, I fear that Judaism as a religious and national phenomenon will have been thoroughly destroyed. And what then? We see indeed what heavy toil it costs us in the West of Europe to fan into flame the last still-remaining spark of Judaism, and how little success we have to show. Should we not at least in good time summon up everything that lies within our power to preserve the national idea in the Jewish people in Russia? Must we then look on calmly while everything falls a prey to destruction, so that later generations may toil to rescue and preserve tiny remnants?
And here I have arrived at the point where I wish to speak to the Zionists. I do not mean by this the Zionist Organisation and its official leadership, which is bound to a definite and precisely circumscribed programme. My admonition is addressed to the national elements in the Jewish people. It is indeed comprehensible that now, when the roof is, so to speak, burning over our heads, the solution of cultural tasks cannot be thought of. But I see that people are nevertheless returning little by little to common work, that the parties are gradually organising and arming for the struggle. The Zionists in Russia, too, have already begun to stir. To my sincere regret, however, I find that our fellow Zionists have of late become so very practical, are so deeply sunk in the plans of "work for the present," that they forget over it the past and the future of the Jewish people.
In most Zionist appeals, to be sure, practical work in Palestine is emphasised. I need hardly defend myself against the suspicion that practical work on the soil of our historic homeland is a matter of indifference to me. But I must nevertheless call it a far-reaching one-sidedness if Zionism should confine itself solely to this one point. Our historic homeland is so dear to us because it is the starting-point of our national cultural life, which, according to our conviction, will one day find its natural continuation there. National cultural life, however, is in any case the main thing. It can therefore by no means be approved if we were all so "practical" that a cow in Palestine became more important to us than all our cultural treasures, which we have tended so carefully in the Diaspora under the most unfavourable conditions. Our ideal is that Zionism shall raise and not depress the level of our national cultural life. Never, never can we content ourselves with the national movement dissolving into a series of agricultural or industrial undertakings in Palestine, may
