Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 20 · 18 May 1906
12printed page
scan 10 of 20
Facsimile · scan 10 of 20
Scan of p. 12
English · AI translation, checked against the German

12 — "Die Welt" — No. 20.

(continued from page 11)

…fallow field lay, while I was entitled to expect that Territorialism would be granted as free a scope as Zionism. Even the anti-Zionists, after all, have never addressed resolutions to the Sultan to inform him that the majority of the Jewish people was against Palestine, and that every attempt to establish a Jewish commonwealth in that land must infallibly fail. Imagine, therefore, my astonishment when it turned out that a member of the Inner Actions Committee had sent resolutions against Territorialism to the British Colonial Minister.

To assert that no body may undertake the work which Zionism has rejected is surely most unreasonable. Still more outrageous, however, is it to let Christians express the conviction that we are capable of colonising in no land save Palestine, especially Christians of the stamp of Mr. Cathcard Wason, M.P., who in 1904 moved the adjournment of the House of Commons in order to call attention to the public danger arising from Mr. Greenberg's efforts to found an alien settlement in East Africa.

I am glad, however, to see that, under the influence of Mr. Joseph Cowen, the oldest English Zionist society, Bnei Zion, has reminded the Zionist leaders that their true duty lies rather in working "in harmony and connection" with the Jewish Territorial Organisation, while similar symptoms of a desire for co-operation reach me from other influential Zionist quarters as well.

Yours most faithfully, Israel Zangwill.

Reply of Mr. L. J. Greenberg

82 Fordwych Road, Brondsbury W, May 14, 1906.

My dear Zangwill, my attention has been drawn to the letter published in the Jewish papers this week which you addressed to the secretary of the Zionist Society in Antwerp. I rejoice with you in being able to hold the conviction that no reproach of "rowdy conduct" can be levelled against the Antwerp Zionists. I hope you will always be able to keep in check the craving for such behaviour among those who work with you in the Territorial Organisation, just as I am certain that every Zionist worthy of the name will repudiate in the most energetic manner any such excess, against whatever opponent it may be directed.

In the evident endeavour to justify your course of action since the last Congress, and since you were unable to submit, in accordance with parliamentary usage, to the defeat which you suffered there, you now assert that the Territorial Organisation has created the body which the friends of the East Africa project had regarded as the executive for that project. But without scruple you omit to mention that the intention to form this body existed only in the event that the East Africa Commission should have made a favourable report and the Congress should have resolved to carry out the scheme. Since neither of these preconditions, on which the scheme depended, was fulfilled, the intention to create a special organisation ad hoc necessarily had to be abandoned. To insinuate now that any one of us ever intended to create an organisation such as the Territorial one for the execution of the East Africa scheme is among the finest flowers of Zangwillian humour. It has a counterpart at most in your notion of the "peaceful" attitude which you claim to have adopted towards Zionism since you revolted against the Zionist Organisation. To strive to belittle Zionism, as you have constantly done; to proclaim to the world, as you do in your letter to Antwerp, that we have committed ourselves to an impracticable and therefore useless undertaking; to give communications to the press in which the movement initiated by you is described as "Neo-Zionism" — these, I take it, are the irrefutable proofs of your "peaceful" attitude, to which one might further add the assertions of your colleagues in the Territorial Organisation, never repudiated by you, that Zionism "has run aground on a sandbank," that it has consumed itself, and that out of its ashes the Territorial Organisation has arisen. How truly "friendly"! For my part I prefer the open opponent, the man who feels himself justified in fighting us and who at least has the courage to avow himself our opponent.

You further complain that "a member of the Inner Actions Committee" sends resolutions "against Territorialism" to the British Colonial Secretary. I presume that you mean by this the resolutions which were recently passed in Liverpool. It is not true that I sent these resolutions to the Colonial Secretary, but I take fully and entirely upon myself the personal responsibility for these resolutions having been submitted to the meeting and communicated to the Government, although the suggestion did not originate with me. I can, however, find nothing in these resolutions that was directed absolutely "against Territorialism." They were declarations in favour of the founding of a Jewish State and against the substitution of another country for Palestine for this State. You say that the reason why the Territorial Organisation was called into being was to save for the Jewish people the offer which the British Government had made in East Africa. But this was never made for the purpose of founding a Jewish State, and therefore the resolutions in question contain nothing "against Territorialism."

But your complaint against the resolution proves precisely its justification. We found that in certain circles the formation of the organisation of which you are President was taken as a sign that the Jewish Nationalists had renounced Palestine and were filled with the desire to found a State in some territory or other that might be found in its stead. It was necessary to correct this view. Moreover, we found that zealous efforts were being made to lead, among others, members of the British Government to believe that the Zionist movement was in fact dead, that it "now formed only a rump," that you were the real successor of Herzl, that the Jewish masses and above all the whole of Jewish national feeling supported you. It was of course necessary to correct these false opinions, and I consider that we were fully justified in doing so in the form of giving expression to our attachment to the Basle Programme and to our conviction that every attempt to establish a Jewish State outside Palestine must end only in failure. If Territorialism has been represented to the British Government as a movement which aimed at substituting some other country for Palestine for the founding of a Jewish State, then you must surely approve all efforts made to correct this false opinion of the nature of Territorialism. And on the other hand, if it was represented as a "movement founded in the attempt to save for the Jewish people the East Africa offer," as you express it in your letter, then the resolutions cannot be regarded by their recipients as directed "against Territorialism."

I confess I am not of your opinion when you complain that "Christians are allowed to express convictions." The