No. 18 — "Die Welt" — 15
(continued from page 14)
...had found in a Piedmontese family the chosen companion of his life, loved with all the fervour of his deep nature. Repose and the comfortable enjoyment of office and dignity were not, it is true, granted him in his larger sphere of activity either; but he had come out of the pellagra ordeal a warrior practised in battle, and with fresh courage he began a new campaign for still more important, because more comprehensive, truths.
At the autopsy he performed upon the beheaded robber and murderer Villela he had found in the skull the occipital fossa which in the animal series occurs regularly in the ruminants, but otherwise only as an extremely rare exception. The finding surprised him. What did this reversion signify, to a formation which the development of the species had left behind for an immensely long time? He sought to obtain other criminals' skulls; he examined and compared, and found in them the same anomalies, and others, that were to be accounted atavistic. Then the insight flashed upon him: the criminal is, in his anatomical constitution, in many respects an atavistic being. While he was engaged in these researches he had, as a court-appointed expert, to deal with the case of the soldier Misdea, who had treacherously shot five of his comrades. He found that the murderer was an epileptic and came from a family in which grave disorders of the nervous system were frequent. In this, too, he saw a pointer, which he followed up. In the prisons, which he was permitted to visit regularly, he established mental or nervous disease and hereditary taint in almost all the convicts, and the analogy between crime and neuropathy forced itself upon him. Out of these observations, pursued for years with passionate devotion, there grew by degrees a coherent doctrine, which he set forth systematically in his chief work "L'Uomo delinquente." Its principal points may be summed up, in their very broadest outlines, somewhat as follows: Crime, that is, an act which offends against the positive penal law and against the prevailing notions of morality, is a phenomenon at once social and individual; it is committed in consequence of external circumstances or inner impulses; upbringing, surroundings, temptation and a momentary surge of passion may make a criminal even of a perfectly normal man; but he is then an occasional criminal, who interests the psychologist and the sociologist, but not the anthropologist; there is, however, another category of criminals, which commits its misdeeds by instinct and is determined to them less by outward seductions or passing passion than by organic impulses. This is the category of the born criminals, which represents a special variety of the species. It is to be recognised by numerous anatomical and biological peculiarities, the search for which, their description and their statistics make up a great part of Lombroso's life-work, and the knowledge of which has been in many ways supplemented and deepened by his pupils. On the whole the born criminal is a degenerate; his anomalies mark themselves biologically as embryonic arrests of development, and the constitution of life and mind that results from them is an atavistic one. Crime itself is atavism. In the far-distant past it was the regular, natural mode of action of man. It is still that of the child and of the savage. Civilisation has taught the normal man self-control, compassion, love of his neighbour and morality; the degenerate has remained at the primitive stage of the existence of the species and cannot raise himself above it; he remains permanently a child; he is a savage in the midst of our civilisation.
This doctrine at first met with the most embittered resistance. The jurists indignantly sought to repel the incursion of natural science into their domain, which they held to be an intolerable presumption. The theologians and metaphysicians called down the wrath of God and of men upon the blasphemer whose doctrine made an end of free will, debased the notions of virtue and vice, declared to be disease or congenital malformation what was dogmatically meant to be sin or guilt, and thereby removed the religious element of repentance and penance from punitive justice. The authorised and officially stamped custodians of the science of criminal law rose against him as one man and desperately defended their theological, metaphysical and formalistic scholasticism against his subversive heresy. The well-known methods of professorial warfare were employed against Lombroso, although he really belonged to the guild himself: first the convulsive silence, then the grand dismissal from on high, next the base abuse and calumny, and lastly the issuing of the watchword: "A chimera, after which a few ignoramuses and fools ran for a little while, but which now excites only a shrug of the shoulders." His findings, which were repeated a thousandfold, were denied. Foolish assertions were ascribed to him, which could then, of course, be triumphantly derided and proved to be nonsense. It was asserted that he took no account of the economic and social causes of crime, although he expressly mentions them and does not enter upon them at length only because it is anthropology, and not criminal statistics, that he means to offer. The folly was imputed to him of wishing to replace the verdict of the judge by an anthropological diagnosis, and to decide upon the guilt or innocence of an accused man not according to the results of the inquiry into the facts, but according to the shape of his skull and of his nose. It would be an insult to Lombroso to defend him against this stupidity or malice. Every person of good faith understands that a new light is shed upon criminality in general when science demonstrates that 75 to 80 per cent of all convicted criminals bear marks of degeneration, and that in a concrete case these marks may nevertheless be absent in an offender without this impairing the value of the propositions derived from investigations in the mass.
A truth cannot be strangled; the one Lombroso found prevailed victoriously. His doctrine created active convictions near and far. Criminal anthropology, which he founded, has been built up into a regular science. It has journals in all the languages of civilisation, a literature that can scarcely any longer be surveyed, fruitful congresses and university chairs, some of which are even occupied by men who introduced themselves as embittered opponents of Lombroso — that is the humour of the workings of the young discipline. Even over the criminological associations in which his name is not uttered, or is mentioned only with abuse, hovers the spirit of Lombroso. His influence is to be felt in all the penal codes and prison regulations that have been enacted or amended in the last decade. The views of the history of culture concerning transgression and expiation, the defence of society and the reformation of the guilty are, under the influence of his teachings, undergoing a slow but irresistible transformation. He is the acknowledged and revered head of a school which flourishes in Italy, branches out through all countries, embraces numerous young talents, and works with fiery and fruitful zeal. He has climbed the loftiest summit of fame and looks down upon a conquered world.
In the course of his studies of degeneration he came upon yet another insight: that of the essential kinship of genius and mental disorder on a degenerative basis. To the demonstration of this relation is devoted the second part of his life-work, the fruit of which is the great work "The Man of Genius." I confess that in this direction I follow the master only hesitantly and as yet without inner adherence. I believe he takes the concept of genius too broadly or too loosely, and applies the designation to many whom I call pseudo-geniuses and in whose works and deeds I
