Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 18 · 4 May 1906
14printed page
scan 12 of 22
Facsimile · scan 12 of 22
Scan of p. 14
English · AI translation, checked against the German

14 — "Die Welt" — No. 18

(continued from page 13)

…man, and quite simply develops the theory of the animal descent of our species, of our kinship with the great apes. He attempts to draw up a genealogical tree which carries the human line far beyond the quadrumana. It even already puts forward the hypothesis, later to revolutionise the whole of biology, that ontogeny repeats phylogenesis in abridged form, and demonstrates this phenomenon in language, which even in its most advanced forms still shows traces of the affixing, agglutination and incorporation through which it has passed in the course of its development, and which for certain families of languages represent the highest stage attained. In a word: in this book the whole theory of evolution is not merely foreshadowed but firmly outlined, and in its bold generalisations and philosophical conclusions it soars to the loftiest points of view of the Darwinian conception of the world. The book appeared in 1859, almost simultaneously with Darwin's "Origin of Species," which Lombroso therefore could not know, just as he did not know Lamarck and Spencer. It made no impression on his contemporaries. Italy stood on the eve of the war from which she was to emerge united, and had nothing to spare for anthropology. Outside Italy, again, the book could not enter into competition with Darwin's fundamental work, for with Lombroso much was intuition that with Darwin was the result of long, laborious, detailed observations and experiments, and in science one experiment outweighs a hundred presentiments. For the world Darwin is rightly held the father of the theory of evolution. Subjectively, however, Lombroso has the same claims to authorship, for he found the theory independently of the great Englishman, who, favoured by fate, forestalled him in its elaboration and publication.

The war in Lombardy determined him to enter the Italian army as a military surgeon, and in it he served for six years. He summed up his war experiences in two treatises on amputations of the limbs, which were distinguished with the Riberi Prize, the only academic reward of which he can boast. His regiment was transferred to Calabria, and here the diversity of popular types which he had constantly before his eyes prompted him to thorough anthropological studies, out of which arose his "Essay towards an Anthropological Geography of Italy." He examined and measured over 4000 individuals and acquired the eye for the anatomical norm and for individual deviations which later greatly facilitated his tracking-down of the anomalies in the born criminal.

After some time Pavia was assigned to the regiment as its station, and Lombroso made use of his stay in a university town to train himself further in psychiatry by regular attendance at the provincial lunatic asylum. His military superiors, however, did not like to see him occupied with scientific work. In their view this was not compatible with the service. They put difficulties in his way and harassed him at every opportunity, until he would bear it no longer and resigned his commission.

He qualified as Privatdozent in psychiatry at the University and took over a ward in the asylum, which was readily entrusted to him because he asked no salary. As he was without means, he did, in order to live, wretchedly paid translations by night for niggardly publishers. Thus he then rendered Moleschott's "Circulation of Life" into Italian, and thereby became the real occasion of the Dutch physiologist's call to an Italian chair. It was a hard time for Lombroso, and sometimes he was near to despair. Then the turn of fortune came unexpectedly: one morning he received the notice that he had been appointed director of the asylum and university professor with an adequate salary. That was an assured existence. That was happiness. He now had firm ground under his feet, and this consciousness kindled in him unknown inward fires. In two feverish nights he wrote his inaugural lecture "Genius and Insanity," which in thirty pages contained in outline all the leading ideas whose development later yielded his world-famous book of the same name.

For the young professor there began a decade of proud struggles and sufferings in the service of truth, which gave him occasion to sound the abysses of human nature, but also to prove a princely nobility of character. The largest contingent of the inmates of the asylum under his direction was furnished by sufferers from pellagra. Pellagra is a frightful infirmity, which begins with a leprosy-like skin disease and ends with the complete destruction of the brain and nervous system. Lombroso traced its origins, then wholly unknown, and discovered that the malady is caused by a poison which develops in spoiled maize, the chief food of the Lombard field-labourers. At a time when nothing was yet known of disease-producing bacteria and toxins, he succeeded in extracting the pellagra toxin from the spoiled maize and in thereby producing the symptoms of pellagra in experimental animals. He came forward joyfully with his discovery and in his guilelessness expected that men would recognise in him a benefactor of mankind. Oh yes! There was but one cry of indignation against him. His university colleagues treated him as mad, the private physicians as a quack, the Government as an agitator and subverter, society as a swindler. Why? For a simple reason: the Lombard great landowners had the lucrative habit of feeding their bad maize, which was not marketable, to their day-labourers, and Lombroso demanded that they be forbidden to use the poisonous stuff as food for human beings. At a public session of the Lombardo-Venetian Institute a colleague told him that he was a dreamer and that his experiments were imagination. Lombroso demanded the appointment of a committee before which he would repeat them; the Institute chose his bitterest enemies as its members. He exhibited the pellagra poison and its effects on animals. The committee could not deny the facts, but it went so far as to accuse Lombroso of having mixed strychnine into the maize extract in order to make people believe in its poisonousness! He appealed to the opinion of Berthelot, and the Paris chemist declared that the extract contained a poison which produced convulsions and, in larger quantity, paralysis, but which, in spite of many similarities, was different from strychnine. Before the authority of the famous Frenchman the Lombards had to bow. Beaten on the field of science, they took their revenge on the social field. The mighty caste of the great landowners and their following in every circle spared Lombroso no persecution and no calumny. He, however, would not be intimidated. The shy, quiet scholar, who anxiously avoided every throng, became a tribune of the people. The man of the laboratory and the sick-room stepped out into the noisy market-place and appealed to the passions of the multitude. He became an itinerant speaker; he wrote polemical articles for the newspapers; he compelled a hearing at every congress, and at last brought it about that the conditions of wages and nourishment of those who until then had been the predestined victims of pellagra were materially improved. Official science passed over his discovery in dead silence until it had become the common property of every class, and then treated it as a commonplace which had always been known and need be credited to no individual discoverer. The old scoundrelly method of authoritatively strangling undisciplined merit!

The ten years' struggle wonderfully steeled his character, but it spoiled for him the small and petty Pavia, so that he felt it as a deliverance when in 1876 he was called to Turin, whither family connections also drew him, since he meanwhile