Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 12.
(continued from page 7)
...I speak. Only they belong to them — for me, and surely for everyone who comes to closer grips with the problem — not by virtue of their outward profession of assimilation, but (together with others who perhaps do not at all profess or feel themselves to be assimilationists) through their inner nature, which compels them to destroy ever more of positive Judaism. And for this the opportunity offers itself to them all the more, since they have to do, at least professionally or as amateurs, with the community as such.
First there is a certain sort of welfare-worker and benefactor. A certain sort, I say. For let no one think that I count here every small or great quack of the social question and of the Jewish question, if he is a Jew and works among Jews. There are quite good-natured, and, what chiefly matters here, quite harmless people among them, who sometimes do good and nowhere do harm. Altogether, the business of welfare and benefaction is a general, perhaps a class phenomenon, but in itself anything but a symptom of national disintegration. This is only to be established when certain traits appear which do not necessarily belong to the system in question. These traits, however, are so characteristic that they cannot fail to strike one.
I do not demand that everyone should at once recognise the loveless, cold, wilful manner in which those Jewish welfare-workers and benefactors work who carry the germ of national destruction into the people. But to one objective mark everyone can attend: whether in the work the provinces of competence are thrown into confusion. The normal welfare-and-charity man may, to be sure, be socially backward, but he does not at least wish to meet the needs of a people's soul with his stores of provender. The nationally abnormal, degenerate, stunted man, on the other hand, does wish it. Or rather, he does not wish it either. But only because he neither sees nor suspects these needs, even when his nose is pushed against them so hard that one would think he must now see them, or at least feel them. He gives and shoves and fancies that he is creating and shaping. He believes he is accomplishing God knows what, and sows only confusion and destruction. Every convert to baptism is more innocent than he.
After the welfare-workers and benefactors come the politicians. Naturally, again, only a certain sort of them. One may think of politics as one will; one may distinguish between politics in the higher and the lower sense, between loud and quiet politics, between the politics of noble and of plebeian men, of the shouters and place-seekers on the one side and of the men of character on the other. But by and large these differences do not touch our question. True, the relative strength of the opposites depends not only upon the rung that has been climbed on the ladder of general human development, but in part also upon national endowments. Yet these endowments belong, after all, to the fund of positive or negative national forces, and it is normal political virtues and vices that arise from them.
But it is something quite different when politics, in its material content, comes down to the destruction of Jewish cultural possessions or of their scanty remnants. Whoever has a scent for such things will, without needing to investigate much, recognise the people I mean: by their staring, dull incomprehension when one comes to speak of the Jewish variant of some general problem affecting the nation, or of an inner Jewish problem itself; by their spiteful, basely pitying smile; by their presumption, for which all wisdom ends at the tip of their own nose. But whoever may not rely upon his scent, him I advise to examine the politics itself as to its content. He need not grow heated at once if some Jewish habitué, on some special question, does not think of Judaism because he loses himself entirely in his favourite cause and is as much grown into his hobby-horse as only a rider can be grown into his steed. The examination may begin only with those who otherwise show themselves not at all one-sided, who permit themselves excursions hither and thither, and who are anxiously concerned only to keep away from the borders of what is Jewish. Those who, whether from reasons of personal interest or from obstinacy, behave as though there did not exist a great, wide land of Jewish culture, although in every case they dimly feel that they themselves were born close beside it. Those who do not speak of Judaism, as though there had never been such a thing, and who brew those false formulas which, like a corroding acid, gnaw away in thousands upon thousands of Jewish souls the roots of their being and of a whole and strong personal life. Who, watching these politicians at their apostolate, would not perceive that they are more dangerous than the converts?
But above all the writing artists! (The publicists I reckon to the preceding group.) That I make still more serious reservations here is self-evident. Nothing is further from my mind than to wish to be a "spokesman of the 'practical men'" — so called because two-thirds of them know how to bungle practically — against the poets, the men of imagination. And the great, solitary geniuses I exclude from my consideration at the outset. It would be a vain endeavour to try to force these wonderful utterers and heralds of the people's soul, these glorious divinators of past and future, into conscious roles of leaders or misleaders. And besides, since the days of Heinrich Heine not a single one of this kind has appeared among the Western Jewish people. How indeed could it be otherwise? But that is another chapter.
Nor, certainly, do I speak of those artists who wrestle within themselves with the Jewish problem, whatever results they may reach, or whether they reach none at all. That they must wrestle, and bear witness of it before all the world, is already, with their will or against it, an affirmation of Judaism. As distinguished from these, those who no longer wrestle, who glide over the inner question-mark of their Judaism frivolously, dishonestly and inartistically, who in naive eagerness for success avoid Jewish milieus and subjects on principle and instead often climb into the most "out-of-the-way" circles of life — these belong already to the deniers of Jewish life.
Yet what do they signify beside the army of literary manufacturers and place-seekers, who are veritable grave-diggers of this life? And this not merely because they are manufacturers and place-seekers. For such hybrids are to be found among all civilised peoples, among some more, among others less. They necessarily grow out of the intellectual middle class. And even if this class is nowhere so strong as among the Jews, the numerical strength of its marauders does not yet sufficiently explain the national intellectual danger they constitute. That becomes clear only when one compares these people with similar elements among other peoples. Among the latter they limp behind the great men of their own nation and proclaim, without any calling, to be sure, the intellectual glory of their people. In Israel, however, they are marauders of foreign intellectual armies. The intellectual world of their own people, though it leaves its negative imprint on their brains, they will not know, will not approach. In the absinthe-reek and cigar-smoke of their coffee-houses, with megalomaniac witticisms and mannered blasé airs, they have passed over their own people to the order of the day. Judaism has become a jest on their pinched lips, a spiteful smile on their sallow faces. And this whole pestilence-breathing army at our backs is not to be taken more seriously than the few people who have their defection certified at the registry office?
Yes, but — it will be objected to me in answer to all this — they still remain ours ... Their children and grandchildren may be different. They may well be, but I deny that it will be the rule. I believe, rather, that they will walk in the ways of their fathers or — make up for the baptism which the fathers unhappily neglected.
