No. 7 — "Die Welt" — 11
And because he suffered so, he saw himself compelled to step out of the study into the market-place of life. The scholar became a popular orator and a publicist. In truth he possessed very few outward means for working as an orator and publicist. For there too he was animated by scholarly exactitude, by the conscientiousness of the investigator. As his voice was weak, scarcely audible, so too was his style exceedingly simple, unadorned and unaffected. For nothing did Steinthal hate so much as the empty phrase. Yet in spite of this his speech always made an indescribable impression. The Talmudic words proved true: "What comes from the heart goes also to the heart."
The speeches and writings of Steinthal on Jews and Judaism now lie before us, collected by Gustav Karpeles in one volume. (Ueber Juden und Judentum, lectures and essays by Prof. Dr. F. Steinthal, Berlin. Published by M. Poppelauer, 1906.) I should like to acquaint the readers of "Die Welt" with this book so rich in content, or more correctly, I should like urgently to commend the reading of this book to them. Perhaps I shall succeed, by discussing only a little of it, in so stirring their curiosity that they will thereupon not merely "read through" the whole book but "learn" it, as we Jews were formerly wont to deal with such writings. I may be permitted to begin at once with an essay which Steinthal wrote in the year 1882, on the occasion of the persecutions of the Jews then taking place in Russia, under the heading: "The Jews without End." He had received, sent by an unknown hand, a South German newspaper containing a leading article headed: "Always the Jews Again." On this Steinthal wrote the words which fit exactly the latest events in Russia as well: "What it is that drives the rabble to rabble-like lust for plunder and murder would be a question that already contains its answer within itself; but to statesmen, whenever they believe they have occasion to throw out a 'tub to the whale,' the Jews always present themselves as a suitable victim. Here it is the destructive fury kindled by Nihilists, there it is the agitation called forth by the Social Democrats, here and there it is the discontent produced by politico-economic conditions, whose outbreak is diverted on to the Jews, whereas in its undisturbed course it would turn against quite other things and quite other persons." And concerning the attitude of the "civilised world" towards these unheard-of atrocities Steinthal likewise found the right expression when he said even then: "The European Great Powers look on idly at the atrocities which Russia commits. Their statesmen understand one another, and they know that they must render one another friendly services in order to be able to expect them from one another. The South German newspaper cited promises the most decided effect even upon the most hardened Great Russians, if everything that counts itself as belonging to civilisation were to issue a joint, or at least identically worded, note to St. Petersburg, with the brief intimation: Europe and those of one mind with her remind Count Ignatieff (as is well known, the teacher and master of Plehve, the Author) that the fourteenth century is long past, and that, should Russia still be so far behind, they recommend Turkey to her as a model worthy of imitation, but meanwhile break off all relations with her. — . . . . . Now since the rabble can never cease to behave like a rabble, the Jewish question can only then vanish practically from the order of the day, as it has theoretically been settled for the thinking man, when the leading statesmen shall have become statesmanlike and the states shall have become states of law. As matters now stand, I cannot hope that Ignatieff and his associates will be made to understand that his statesmanlike cunning, besides its Carib savagery, is also very stupid; it will never be possible to open his eyes to how great a favour is done to the Nihilists when the bonds of law and order are completely loosed, and loosed, moreover, with the connivance of the Government. And will it be possible to make our German statesmen observe how, beside the Jew-tub, the German-tub too has been thrown out in Russia? And that in Germany, too, no line can be drawn between Jewish and Christian capital, between capital and landed property? And will the men of Berlin, Paris and London, who guide the destiny of Europe, be able to come to the recognition that the witches' brew of anarchy now being brewed in Russia will soon overflow, and must then be drunk by Europe, and that, on the other hand, an energetic veto against the persecution of the Jews could bring matters to a standstill?"
It is further noteworthy that Steinthal found the best solution of the Jewish question in Russia in emigration. He thought: "When the American primeval forests have been cleared enough, Australia will still offer tracts to be cultivated. The Sublime Porte, too, will doubtless yet be persuaded that it may be advantageous to her if desolate lands are settled by some thousands."
Here, then, is already a suggestion in the sense of present-day Zionism, and Steinthal too was already of the opinion at that time: "But let the principle be: out of Russia."
* * *
In the year 1893, when the "Association for Defence against Antisemitism" was founded in Berlin, Professor Albrecht Weber, who had been invited to join it, expressed the opinion that the Jews should first look into themselves and put away their faults. Steinthal, who was on friendly terms with this scholar, could not leave his utterance unanswered. He first reminded Weber that the Jews do indeed very often look into themselves. One need only know the proverbs of the Jews, which contain a bitter and sharp self-knowledge. However, the crux of the Jewish question does not lie there, but in the false conception of the Jewish character on the part of the Christians. The self-knowledge of the Jews, too, must now be directed to another side; that is, we should confess not the sins which we allegedly commit against our non-Jewish surroundings, but the sins against our own people. "In former times," says Steinthal, "there really was a Jewish solidarity; this is now in the course of vanishing, and many people who cannot separate themselves entirely from Judaism, and therefore do not desert the colours in their own persons, do so for their children, whom they have baptised."
