Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 4 · 26 January 1906
4printed page
scan 2 of 24
Facsimile · scan 2 of 24
Scan of p. 4
English · AI translation, checked against the German

DIE WELT

No. 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 4

ON THE BRUSSELS CONFERENCE

BY DR. ALFRED KLEE

The arrangements at present existing for emigrants who are not without means will need to be improved in many respects. The Austrian committees, for instance, do not yet work as one could wish. The Zionist local groups existing all over the earth will assist those passing through and those arriving with advice, free of charge. A little book with the necessary addresses will have to be compiled for the wanderers. It will have to be examined whether the circle of immigration countries might not be widened by the addition of particular cities of the East, notably of Egypt. Here, to be sure, special caution and criticism will have to be exercised, in view of the economic backwardness of the East on the one hand and of the necessity of immediate work for the immigrants on the other. The keystone would be a Central Information Bureau, perhaps attached to the already existing bureau of the "Hilfsverein der deutschen Juden". But the value of such a central office must not be overestimated either. Only a few points: if, for example, Montreal informs the central office that a number of joiners are needed there, the demand in Montreal will perhaps long since have been met by the time the wanderers to whom the central office has passed on the information are in Canada; quite apart from the fact that in the skilled trades the particular kind required for the place in question can seldom be procured, and that the necessity of a fairly long period of nominal employment considerably lowers the value of the information. In no case, therefore, will the central office be able to assume any responsibility. Whoever follows its advice, given on the best possible information, does so at his own risk.

But if the emigration of persons without means must not be encouraged, there is nevertheless perhaps another possibility of diminishing the number of victims exposed to Russian barbarity. Just as it is proposed to take the pogrom orphans out of Russia, so let children be taken out continually and in general. The annual excess of births is estimated at about 50,000. Let us assume that the parents of 15,000 of these children have their bread, that the parents of a further 20,000 children would not part from them; there then remain some 15,000 children for education abroad. If a great organisation is created for this purpose, with an eminent organising and expert talent at its head, embracing Austria-Hungary, Germany, Holland, Belgium, Italy, France, England, the American states, etc., it will in time be possible to furnish all the children avail-

Editor's note. While we very gladly give space to the above observations, we would not omit to reproduce, at least in substance, some remarks which Dr. Klee places before them and which we left out because they contained no direct suggestions for Brussels but would have necessitated a polemic on our part:

Dr. Klee first discusses briefly that, so far as internal Russian-Jewish affairs are concerned, the Brussels Conference is competent chiefly for questions of economic and cultural improvement. Passing on to the question of emigration and immigration, he further emphasises that, regrettably, no land of their own can be offered to the fugitives. But neither Zionist nor territorialist plans would be discussed in Brussels. As regards the question of emigration, the author holds that one must not, for want of means, encourage an emigration of persons without means.

able — boys and girls of not under 5 and not over 10 years of age — in Western Europe and America with a good school education and with sound technical knowledge suited to their station, such as will enable them to make their way throughout the world in decency and honour. Particular care will naturally also have to be taken that the children are brought up in faithful attachment to their Jewish people. The physical regeneration longed for by all who have insight will soon set in, the more so as child marriages will gradually cease altogether. Zionism could wish for no better human material for its plans of settlement; but wherever in the world these children may one day have become independent, they will be a support to their parents and brothers and sisters, will in most cases draw them after them into the new home, and so help towards the organic solution of the emigration problem. That these Russian-Jewish children will mean for many countries — Italy, Sweden, etc. — a most welcome refreshment of the Jewish population and thereby of Jewish life, and further that the close connection between East and West will be established more intimately and effectively than other measures, however praiseworthy in themselves, are able to do, may be remarked in passing.

The placing of the children must extend to all communities, even the smallest. Precisely in the small communities — I know them particularly well in Germany on the Rhine — there lives much warm Jewish feeling that presses for activity. The increase in the communal budget occasioned by one or two children is not too sensibly felt by the individual. Many childless Jewish couples will undertake this duty of love without payment; in most other cases only smaller subsidies will be required. In Germany alone we have some 2,300 communities! What a wide field of activity, too, for the women's societies existing almost everywhere in Western Europe and America! Moreover, a similar idea was already carried out in the year 1868, on the occasion of the famine in Western Russia, by the veteran Dr. Rülf in Memel and by the Liegnitz rabbi Dr. Landsberg, as representatives of the Alliance; and in a praiseworthy manner the Berlin rabbi Dr. Rosenzweig propagates this idea within a narrower circle.

I do not conceal from myself the difficulties of carrying it out. They lie in part in the legal sphere as well. Nevertheless this question that has been raised seems to me of great consequence, and in Brussels I shall move the election of a standing commission, with its seat in Berlin, for the further pursuit of the matter.

The Brussels Conference is to be a manifestation of the unanimity of the whole of Jewry in this grave and serious time. That remains its first and most valuable task! It is being attended from all parts of the world by Jews of the most various tendencies; the majority of the great organisations and many Jewish communities will be represented — a very gratifying result for a first attempt. The course of the Conference will, it is to be hoped, teach those who still stand aside that their absence was unjustified; the second and subsequent conferences will grow more and more into a general representation of the Diaspora.