DIE WELT
No 4
CORRESPONDENCE
(In this column the Editors will gladly give space to all communications — including those from other party camps — in so far as by form and content they lay claim to general interest.)
Dear Sir, Your assumption of the editorship of "Die Welt" gives me occasion to ask you to publish the following suggestion:
Redemption of the Shekel by a Single Payment *)
(A proposal for raising money for Zionist purposes).
The proposal rests upon the system of the life annuity.
Just as a bank, against the deposit of twenty to thirty times the amount, will pay a certain sum yearly as interest, so an insurance company will pay the same sum as a life annuity against the payment of only some fifteen to twenty times the amount. But if in this way, on a purely business footing, a life annuity of a thousand marks yearly can be paid out of a capital of, let us say, 15 to 20,000 marks, then a Zionist institution could very well pay the Shekel yearly for tens of thousands of Zionists, each of whom pays in 20 marks today for this purpose.
The great advantage of the matter lies in this, that with only moderate activity on the part of the Zionist Organisation probably a quarter to a sixth of the present and newly joining Shekel-payers would in the course of some time be won for this method, and that thus in the first year some half a million to a whole million francs, and in later years some hundreds of thousands of francs each year, might be brought together.**)
The Application.
I should be in favour of these moneys being invested in the purchase of land, the building of houses and improvements. In distinction from the National Fund, which wishes only to buy land that for the present is likely to lie fairly dead, the new fund should be applied partly to making National Fund land productive (by general improvement, by laying out plantations — perhaps especially olive plantations, whose special suitability I have stressed for many years — by building houses, sinking wells and everything else that raises the rental value of the land), and partly to the new acquisition and making productive of further lands in Palestine and its nearest neighbouring countries.
By this application there would be gained:
Employment for many hundreds — perhaps thousands — of Jews. With, for example, 250,000 francs available yearly, at a wage of 1.25 francs a day ***), more than 650 workmen would thereby find their livelihood, that is, 650 families with more than 3000 souls their maintenance!
It would further be gained that every year a great number of homesteads would be prepared for people of lesser means, or even for those not sufficiently able to work. An investment, for example, of a few thousand francs in olive plantations means a permanent provision for life and for generations to come.†)
There would further be gained an increase of Jewish possession of land, and indeed of land made productive. That is far more important than a possession many times larger of fallow land. And there lies in it, moreover, a healthy complement to the endeavours directed solely to the acquisition of land, whether of the National Fund or of other agencies. It is often difficult to alter defects in the statutes or programme of an institution — but there complementary institutions are in order. The making productive or improving of land that would otherwise lie fallow brings, after all, a corresponding increase of rent, and is therefore a commercially sound activity.
The Advantages for the Shekel Fund.
The collection of the Shekel would be materially simplified and the regularity of payment considerably increased.
At present it frequently happens that in a Congress year a materially higher number of Shekels comes in (often double!!!) than in a year without a Congress, because on account of the elections the societies display a far greater activity and far greater zeal in collecting in the Congress year. An essential part of the Shekolim is thus lost to the Fund every second year. To the extent of the redemption of the Shekel (in the sense of this proposal) this loss would be excluded.
Other losses, such as arise from forgetfulness on the part of the collecting bodies or of the party members, from removal, absence or passing discontent, would likewise fall away to the extent of the Shekel redemption.
Moreover, the effect of the Shekel redemption (by a single payment of twenty times the amount, so that the yearly Shekel makes 5 % of the sum paid in) is an "eternal" one, whereas the franchise bound up with it is "only" for life. — That is a difference. I know of Jewish societies in which there is a membership by yearly subscription, a life membership by a larger single payment, and, for a still larger single payment, a perpetual membership. These deceased members, whose subscriptions, if they were invested to bear suitable interest, "live for ever", then usually receive a place of honour at the head of the membership lists. We too could thus establish a parallel institution to the "Golden Book" of the National Fund.
Questions of Technique.
Our Bank, or the National Fund, or the special administrative institution that receives these moneys, sees to their separate application in the sense set out above, but in such a way that an interest or a rental yield appears guaranteed, out of which
- 5 % yearly is to be paid over to the Shekel Fund in the names of those who paid in,
- A reserve fund of an amount to be determined is to be accumulated, which can cover the shortfall of any bad years,
- a surplus is to be applied to such undertakings of a directly colonising nature (such as experimental stations, information, schools for agriculture and agricultural industry) as yield no immediate return.
The Shekel Fund at once sends the payer an acknowledgment of receipt (perhaps in the form of a "diploma"), together with the Shekel receipt for the current year, and a notification to the local group concerned. In the following years the Shekel receipt is each time reported to the person concerned and the notification — likewise yearly, on account of the franchise — to the local groups, to the latter possibly in lists.
Death or formal withdrawal from the party (which, of course, entails no refund) is to be reported by the local groups to the Central Office, so that the statistics and the yearly accounts may not be in error. The sums thus "lapsed" are carried over to special lists, for which no Shekolim as such are paid any longer.
Some details of financial technique belong to the Commission.
Disadvantages.
I see none. But I "hear" some, and will try to answer the most obvious of them now at once — others on a later occasion.
In doing so I will confine myself to the objections of principle.
How a disturbance of the statistics or of the electoral machinery could be prevented I have already shown above. The chief objection will therefore relate to the "abuse of the franchise" that is to be feared.
Should the person concerned change his Zionist opinion as far as anti-Zionism, then as a man of decency he will make no use of his franchise. With an even moderately normal development of Zionism such a defection of groups of any consequence is, moreover, as good as out of the question. We can also note on Shekel and redemption receipts that only "the acceptance of the Basle Programme combined with the payment of the Shekel" confers the franchise.
With this the chief objection ought to be disposed of, For all the lesser questions of principle and of technique a way out will likewise be found, if only one is willing.
Berlin, January 1906.
Davis Trietsch.
*) After a suggestion which I found years ago in "Die Welt", but which has so far remained without result.
**) With greater activity on the part of the Organisation a still far more considerable result could be achieved.
***) See: Report on a journey of inquiry to Saida, by Dr. S. Soskin. "Palästina", Vol. I, p 209.
†) There is a proverb: He who plants olive trees provides for his heirs as well. — In the statement of reasons for the "Olive Tree Fund" of the Palestine Commission it is set out that an outlay of 600 marks per hectare (at 100 trees) suffices to obtain, already from the 6th year onward, a surplus (after payment of all costs — including those for harvest and sale) of 300 francs per hectare yearly. If we reckon the price of olive land at 100 marks per hectare, that would mean that one can draw 600 francs yearly (from the 6th year on) from a capital investment of 1400 marks (= 1750 francs). On National Fund land even the purchase price of the land would fall away, and, assuming a rent of 10 %, one would then obtain from an invested capital of 1200 marks (= 1500 Frcs.) a yearly yield of 600 Frcs. less 25 Frcs. for rent, that is, 575 francs (almost 40 %!).
