No. 2. — DIE WELT — 7
(continued from page 6)
…saddening and shameful one, above all for him who has at heart the interests of the entire Jewish people and not merely those of single classes, that in so grave an hour certain Bundist groups thought it tactful and fitting to hold aloof from the other Jewish organisations. But the "Bund" is not merely tactless and petrified in its doctrinairism; it is also not sincere. Now, post festum, so to speak, it blows the great trumpet, sets itself up as the sole representative of the Jewish people, has its advocates at home and abroad extol its courage and proclaim that it alone it was that led the self-defence, and leads it still. That is worse than untrue. Unhappily, that is the customary party policy of the "Bund" towards the Zionists!
But we will not dispute further with the "Bund"; in our view it has politically arrived almost at zero. The Russian Revolution and its accompanying phenomena have cut its vital nerve; it is the "Dupeur dupé." For all that, one may nevertheless lay its catalogue of sins before it.
We can now regard "Bundism" with the eyes of the historian; we are past the first stages of party strife, in which one sees the mote in another's eye and will not see the beam in one's own. The "Bund" has a past behind it. In the transformation of Jewish society, in the process of recasting the forms of Jewish life, it has played a significant part that is not to be mistaken. In its day, too, it showed a deeper understanding of the nature of the Jewish question when it broke away from the general Russian Social Democratic Party and became autonomous. But the representative of the Jewish people it never was. On the contrary, it has all too often set the interests of the Jewish people behind those of the party. It was able to lead its band boldly into battle; it has perhaps taught the Jewish youth to die — to live it has not taught them. In political movements good will does not suffice, and no one asks after motives. The "Bundists" have in the end achieved a negative success. And that we must hold up to them whenever they give themselves out for what they are not — the saviours of the Jewish people.
"The Three Isms." Zionism is beginning to become a social factor. It is no longer regarded as a small, insignificant movement, irrelevant to the world at large, but as a historical fact which must be reckoned with. In an article in the "Nuova Antologia," one of the greatest reviews of Italy, we recently found an essay by the well-known Italian thinker Prof. Chiapelli on Imperialism. And it is significant that on this occasion, in discussing one of the most important political phenomena of the present day, he too could not avoid making mention of Zionism. It is gratifying that our movement is viewed from a higher vantage-point. The labour of those who have deepened it, of the ideologists and theorists of Zionism, has borne its fruit. In this respect a pronouncement which we find in an Italian Socialist paper of Milan, "Il Tempo" (No. 273), founded by Claudio Treves, is of great interest. It is an essay on the "Crisis in Zionism," which bears the signature "Alfa Lamoa." The "crisis" is the split of the Zionist movement into "Zionism" and "Territorialism." It is not our intention in this connection to pass judgment on the views favourable to Territorialism which are put forward in the article cited. But we wish to bring out the method with which the author approaches his task. He establishes the existence of a permanent crisis, of a deep malaise in modern life. "Men have lost their equilibrium." And he continues his argument: "A reflex of the general crisis which is shaking everything is noticeable also in the three 'Isms' of the present day: in Socialism, Zionism and Positivism. They are three facts and three movements, akin to one another, made brothers by their common origin: the impulse towards renewal which dwells in all the forms of the economic and moral spheres of life of the civilised world. All three movements now find themselves in a period of inner cleavage, and, in spite of their destiny to combat the morbidity of men and of minds, have themselves been infected by the malady of the century. . . . A grave but salutary malady . . . The severe criticism, the revision of fundamental doctrines, which this crisis imposes upon the three 'Isms,' preserves them from ossification, from dogmatism. . . . Free criticism befits free men. And if the present crisis shall result in an increase of this free criticism in the domain of Socialism, Zionism and Positivism, it is no sign of senile decay, but of growth. For all three 'Isms' answer to the present tendencies of social life: Socialism to the social tendencies, — the striving to raise the proletariat, — Zionism to the moral, — the liberation of a people still in part enslaved — Positivism to the intellectual — the striving to attain certain truth." . . .
We can scarcely discern the philosophical connection of the three movements wholly in agreement with the sentences quoted above. The question must be cut into much more deeply. But in any case the fact is noteworthy.
It depends perhaps upon ourselves to gain a place on the list of the great social phenomena. And we shall have to keep step accordingly. Noblesse oblige.
A Jewish Parliament. In our leading article we pointed out in brief words the singular project of convening a Jewish Parliament. It would not be without interest to go somewhat more closely in this place into this rather grotesque-seeming project. The author of this project is Mr. B. I. Belisha of Manchester. Its aim is to secure for the Jewish people a real and permanent representation, which should restore the unity of the Jewish people and sit in council upon all the affairs of Jewish life. In this Parliament, which would thus have to represent the whole nation, all parties are to have seat and vote and are to subordinate themselves to it in a certain measure. At the head of this national assembly, which would have to sit in Paris or London, and that for a whole month together, there is to stand a responsible Cabinet of 15 members, elected by the Parliament. Such are the main features of the new project. We need hardly point out that we, as practical politicians, recognise the impossibility of such a Parliament under the prevailing political circumstances. A Parliament must have an executive at its side; otherwise every resolution of the Parliament is at best a pious wish. This executive we cannot obtain so long as we have no national independence. But we emphasise the symptomatic character of this project. The idea of unity and independence among the Jews is ripening more and more. There is an English saying: "What Lancashire thinks to-day, England will say to-morrow." We hope that what isolated Jews dream of to-day may perhaps, in the future and under other circumstances, become reality. A Jewish Parliament — but on Jewish soil.
Fresh Pogroms. The Russian mob is not yet sated. It wants fresh Jewish hecatombs. Every day fresh reports arrive from the sorely tried south-western Rayon