No. 1. — "Die Welt" — Page 7.
These reasons are of interest to us neither from a material nor from a psychological point of view. Even though Brandes was the prophet of a bygone age, who to-day can only laboriously, and with incomparably slighter effect, adapt his person and his outlook to new things and make them tell with new men, he none the less belongs among the finest minds of Europe. One has no right to assume that he has lost all of his former scent for what is coming, for budding greatness, all of his critical and analytical power. We therefore had reason to expect that in a serious judgment upon a serious question — and that he meant to take it seriously his public utterance itself proves — he would offer something deeper, something artistic, something captivating in form and substance, such as makes one respect an adversary. He regales us with banalities, with superficialities and insipidities that lie below even the average level of the commonplace.
His chief objection to Zionism is the racial impurity of the Jews. In a dialectical trifling for which the word dilettante would be too much, he concludes, from the fact that this or that scholar has demonstrated among the Hebrews admixtures of blood with other races, how absurd the proclamation of a Jewish nation is. As though the problem of the Jewish national community lay in a greater or lesser purity of blood! A ridiculous argument! If, as a man of learning, he has fetched his equipment from the library of the still obscure and confused racial theories, then, instead of lengthy disputations — to vary a phrase of Goethe's — any hooligan could teach the ideologue how little he asks, in the exercise of his trade, whether in the days of the forefathers the blood of his victim was "purified" by a Chazar or a Spanish strain. If it is the argument of the politician, then we refer him to the other Georg Brandes, who stood up for the independence of the — assuredly far more mixed — Polish people without for one moment thinking of the analysis of blood. No, no: in the case of the Poles, Brandes, who otherwise too has a sharp eye for the typical-individual when he chooses, found out the typical-individual character of a national community quickly and without scruples of conscience. And so there appears to us the Janus image that we know from others as well: Georg Morris Cohen Brandes, who after all cannot well shake off the Jew, even if he mostly presents himself to the public only as the Dane Georg Brandes, is towards all other peoples the cosmopolitan Jew, towards the Jewish people the Jewish cosmopolitan. And does not himself know how typically Jewish that is for certain circles. But that he, the aesthete, the artist, cannot find the firm ground of his own people — that is just what places him, here too, outside his time, which preaches the power and the worth of tribal character not with words but with a thousand signs. It places him also outside those other Jewish aesthetes and artists of our day who are no less cosmopolitans, no less Europeans, bearers of brilliant names too, and who out of their own souls, unburdened by all manner of complaining, have sought and quickly found the way to Judaism. If these men are not all Zionists, neither, to be sure, are they — what one otherwise precisely wishes.
Unoppressed Jews. Enough of polemics. However fully it might still be carried on with regard to the other objections that Brandes raises, it would be wearisome and in the last resort purposeless.
Now to something else. In one passage Brandes writes:
"In the year 1901 I wrote an article: 'Jewish and Christian Roumanians.' It was to be brought out in German in a great international paper. The essay was accepted, but remained unprinted one month, two, indeed three months, in spite of repeated requests on my part. Want of space and similar editorial excuses were pleaded. At last I learned that the paper was afraid of making itself disagreeable to the Roumanian Government, with which it had financial dealings, and the essay was never printed. It is therefore not at every time and in every place so easy to work for the Jews as Dr. Fränkel imagines; one meets, among other things, unoppressed Jews too upon one's way."
We are assuredly less surprised at this "tribal peculiarity" of the so-called Jew press than Brandes, who plainly lacks an understanding of tribal peculiarities. But we confess that the disappointment Brandes experienced here is for us too not without a certain piquancy. Precisely because it is Brandes who is concerned. The outward servility, the inward mendacity of this press could not be lit up more glaringly than is done by his words. One would surely have supposed that at least Brandes, the unsuspected cosmopolitan, whose impartiality in Jewish matters appears sufficiently guaranteed even to non-Jews by his international past, to whose famous name a small weakness would readily be forgiven — that to such a man at least the way into the great papers with editors of the Jewish confession would stand open. That even he cannot break through this wall of speculating and Stock-Exchange Jewry, that papers of this kind are not ashamed to declare their traffic in opinions, without fear or shame, before a Brandes — this proves that this power must be broken by another, one stronger than the strength of any single man. Even if this other power does not yet stand closed in its ranks to-day, it is nevertheless coming up in rank upon rank. Many another wall has already fallen. Already people are growing used to the "cowardly," the protected Jewry being replaced by a fearless, manly one. Already, from non-Zionist circles too, an ever-growing band is beginning to detach itself from the old phlegmatic, sluggish stratum and to face the demands of Jewish life with increasing understanding. The old representation is falling, must fall. Jewish politics, Jewish advocates — these are no longer revolutionary words within Jewry. They are real factors, and they must be reckoned with. But the last block from a sorry past still towers aloft, hard to overthrow, even though many a blow has already struck it —: the "Jew press." It still plies its lucrative trade: juggling with the Jews and their fate — according to need, "protecting" them, as it is called, with blatant, unfit, dangerous means, abandoning them, smothering them in silence, disowning them, wherever the political or the money purse demands it. The block still towers, but it will fall, must fall. The Jewish press will vanquish the Jew press.
Prefect Neidhardt. The Prefect of Odessa, Neidhardt, who lately at Abbazia fell under general social ostracism as the "bloodhound of Odessa" — has had himself interviewed, after famous models. This attempt at a vindication of his honour is a classic document of the infamous, mendacious tactics of the criminal Russian officialdom, which since Ignatiew and Plehwe has organised, staged and fanned the bloodiest pogroms with cold deliberation, with the most fearful exactness, and by the most devilish means, only then to protest in Western Europe its innocence, its indignation, its guiltlessness. Neidhardt's declarations run:
"In face of the unheard-of accusations of which I have been the target, I feel compelled to declare that the charge that I sought, in my office, to favour the deplorable outrages is a calumny. I protest with all decision against the assertion that the mob excesses in Odessa took place with the participation or with the consent of the police. For 4 days, beginning on the 24th of October, Old Style, we had stood face to face with the rising of the revolutionaries. It would have been madness, in this terrible situation, to expect any relief from the mob being set upon the Jewish shopkeepers. It has been asserted that I wished by the mob excesses to terrorise the Liberals and to compromise the newly granted Constitution. Unfortunately the revolutionaries at once did this themselves. In reply to the remark that
