Page 6 — "Die Welt" — Separate Edition No. 4
(continued from page 5)
…principle should return, and have therefore included in the statute a provision that the members of the executive cannot be elected to the presiding board of the Congress.
A further addition has been made with regard to the payment of the shekel. The Inner A.-C., foreseeing the differences of opinion which would show themselves at this Congress, and foreseeing the resolution which would be passed on this point, has included a provision which was hitherto lacking. Hitherto, that is, the shekel was often accepted from anyone who offered it. One thereby ran the danger that many persons who did not belong to the Zionist movement came into the Congress, and one was exposed to the danger that someone could occupy a part of the Congress with money. To prevent this, the provision was included that a shekel may be accepted only from those who profess the Basle Programme. It has also happened that people professed the Basle Programme and then disavowed it. For this purpose the provision was included that if a shekel-payer declares that he does not stand upon the Basle Programme, or if the Congress Court establishes this, he forfeits his right to vote.
A third important addition to the statute of organisation is found in the development of the Congress Court. Under the old statutes the Congress Court has hitherto had only the right to decide disputes between bodies of the Zionist movement. In the new draft this competence is extended so that the Congress Court may also decide between functionaries and members of the movement. In recent years it has happened that functionaries of the movement have been dragged through the mire in the most infamous manner. The movement has no means against this, but it is necessary that discipline be maintained in the movement. We do not possess the executive power of other authorities, and nothing remains to us but to punish those members of the organisation who offend against it with the means at our disposal. In consequence the provision was included that the Congress Court may function at the same time as a disciplinary court, if the A. C. demands it.
These are the most important alterations which the A.-C. has proposed. It still remains for us to discuss one of the most important questions, namely that of centralisation or decentralisation. You know that hitherto the A.-C. had its seat in one place, and that under the provisions of the statute hitherto in force the members of the A.-C. were obliged to reside in one and the same place. After Herzl's death a great discussion arose in public as to whether this should continue so or not. The Inner A.-C. has taken a middle course. In order to do justice to both demands, it has laid down that the Inner A.-C. shall consist of 5 members, but that at least 3 members shall reside in one and the same place. The reasons for this have been discussed publicly on many occasions, so that I need not set them forth further.
In the name of the Inner A.-C. I recommend to you the adoption of this draft as the basis of the special debates. (Lively applause.)
Dr. Bodenheimer: "Honoured members of the Congress! Permit me first a small preliminary remark. My report has been announced as 'Statute of Organisation'. In the 'Welt', however, it was notified in the correct form, namely as a report on the policy of the Zionist movement and the problems of organisation.
Ladies and gentlemen! It is perhaps an awkward matter to-day to speak once more in extenso on the policy of the Zionist movement, since agreement was already reached yesterday upon points of principle of that policy. I hold it, however, to be absolutely necessary, in connection with the organisation, to give also a retrospect of the policy hitherto pursued and a prospect of the policy of the future.
I observe that I speak entirely independently of every opinion represented here in the Congress. I do not speak on behalf of the A.-C. Nor do I speak on behalf of the Zion Zion, nor on behalf of the political Zionists. I nevertheless have the hope that what I shall set forth to you on my own account may perhaps form the foundation for the construction of a political party, a political faction within the Zionist movement, which is fitted to unite men about it from all the lands of Zionism. You must therefore forgive me if, although it is not otherwise my habit to deliver a report from the page, under these special circumstances I base my address upon a manuscript.
The speaker further sets forth the following:
One must first be clear about the programme before one can speak of the policy of the movement. Agreement upon the policy then in its turn determines the principles to be laid down for the organisation. Dr. Herzl, in his policy, had endeavoured to refrain from all practical colonising activity until the Charter in Palestine should be obtained. To obtain it he had entered into communication with the European governments, in order to acquaint them with the philanthropic purpose of our endeavours and to set forth their own interest in this solution of the Jewish question. With this policy, naturally, only a small circle of persons could occupy itself. There thus appeared in the policy the endeavour to arouse the interest of the masses by initiating a policy of work in the present. Chiefly from the standpoint of the policy of the present there then arose the East Africa project, which as a reaction brought about a preponderance of the endeavours towards practical colonising work in Palestine. The speaker then polemises against territorial plans outside Palestine, which he assumes would entail the creation of two different rallying-points for the Jewish people instead of one single point of concentration. The speaker therefore regards the first sentence of the Basle Programme as the unshakeable rock upon which the policy and the organisation of the movement are to be built. As regards the policy of the movement, the speaker emphasises with particular sharpness the danger of practical colonising activity in Palestine without previous autonomy. This, he says, contradicts the principle of a "do ut des" policy and makes political negotiations more difficult by increasing the value of their object. The general principle must therefore be laid down of giving not a man and not a groschen to Palestine before the minimum of privileges is guaranteed without which an unhindered development of Jewish colonisation on a large scale would be unthinkable. This principle admits of two exceptions. The first, which is of a material nature, is to be seen in all labours which fall within the framework of preparation for a mass or rapid colonisation, such as the investigation of the geographical, geological, agricultural and