Special Edition No. 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
…to pass any resolutions whatever with regard to the East Africa question. (Applause on the Left.)
Pres. Dr. Marmorek: Before I give the floor to the reporter of the Credentials Committee, Dr. Wortsmann has the floor for a personal remark.
Dr. Wortsmann corrects certain points concerning himself in Dr. Stein's speech.
There follows the report of the Credentials Committee, read by Mr. Percy Baker.
Percy Baker: In the name of the Credentials Committee I have the honour to report on its work.
We have examined the individual election papers, mandates and protests received, and must regretfully state that a number of informalities have occurred in respect of individual elections in some places Partly this is the result of a mistaken interpretation of the new Organisation Statute, partly of over-zeal in the election campaign (Aha!). On the first point the electors appear to have relied on precedents under the former Organisation Statute, whereby, with only one hundred, surpluses of more than half that number of shekel-payers also carried the right to elect a further delegate. We recommend that in future the Organisation Statute be strictly adhered to, in the sense that only full two-hundreds may elect a delegate. We observe that the new Statute naturally rescinds all earlier provisions on this matter.
We gladly state that the elections in Switzerland, in America and in England were carried out with a care worthy of imitation. As regards the individual protests, we wish to remark at the outset that those received only during the sitting of the Congress could not be given closer consideration, being too late.
Here and there the view appears to prevail that mandates can be confirmed or annulled by the A. C. We expressly emphasise that this is not the case, but that the sole authority possessing this right is the Credentials Committee, that is, the Congress.
The filling-in of the election minutes leaves very much to be desired in many places. When, for example, such scraps (the speaker holds aloft a little slip about 50 cm in size), written in pencil, without date etc., are handed in as election minutes, this might well be regarded as something more than a mockery of the Credentials Committee. We have no reason to doubt the bona fides of those elected and of the district chief concerned. The Credentials Committee has therefore resolved to validate the two elections in question. But in other respects too it should be strictly required that the election minutes show the number of shekel-payers of the group concerned, as well as the number of votes actually cast and the age of the person elected. Naturally only the moneys already remitted to the central treasury can be taken into account. We recommend that election papers and the documents belonging to them be furnished with National Fund stamps.
Well-founded protests giving exact particulars of irregularities have in fact been few. On the strength of one such we recommend the annulment of one election each in Mariampol, Bialystok and Swidosch, where in every case, according to the statement of the district chiefs, one delegate too many was elected on the basis of the shekel-payers on hand. The Congress Bureau will notify the delegates concerned. We recommend that the protest from Grodno be rejected, since a group there wished to vote outside the national organisation, which stands in direct contradiction to § 13, sentence 2, of our Statute.
A difference of opinion between a district chief and his alleged substitute cannot affect the elections, since both were elected by the last Congress as members of the A. C. with equal rights. The quarrel belongs within the competence of the national organisation concerned, or else within that of the Congress Court, but in no case before the Credentials Committee.
We further observe that, in our conviction, delegates are present who have not reached the age of 24 years prescribed by § 12, sentence 1 (aha!). Since, however, the Credentials Committee is in no position to undertake an inspection of passports or birth certificates (Interjection: why not?), nothing remains for us but to appeal urgently to the Zionist conscience of the delegates concerned (Interjection: There's no such thing) and to exhort them, out of respect for the law we have given ourselves and for the dignity of the Congress, to lay down their mandates.
The protests of Messrs. Zibulnik, Finkelstein and associates, which, in an improper manner, were circulated as an anonymous leaflet before their consideration by the Credentials Committee, we regard as a grave infringement of the order of the Congress, because they contain accusations whose untenability the authors of the leaflet could easily have satisfied themselves of. As regards these protests, we here establish that it is not founded on fact that 500 Russian delegates are present in Basle (Dissent)."
Concerning the election in Makarof, Department of Kieff, where Delegate Koller was elected, we observe that the shekel moneys in question have arrived.
The protest from Rowno is invalid, because the signatories are not shekel-payers.
As regards Mr. Slatopolski, we have his word of honour that the circular mentioned in the leaflet did not emanate from him at all. At the close of our report we should like to formulate some recommendations:
-
The date for sending in election papers, as well as any nominations and protests, should be fixed in the Statute, so that henceforth the work of the Credentials Committee may be concluded before the opening of the Congress.
-
A uniform form for election minutes and credentials should be drawn up for all countries, for which the Swiss election minutes may serve as a model.
The year of birth of the person elected must without fail be stated therein.
We recommend that the date for Congress elections be two months, and for any protests not later than one month, before the Congress, to be delivered to the Congress Bureau.
Herewith the work of the Credentials Committee is concluded. (Lively applause.)
Dr. Piekarsky then asks for the floor to make a statement: Ladies and Gentlemen! Some days ago a leaflet on the elections in Russia was circulated. From it, it appears that the elections there were in large part conducted under the sign of election-robbery and election-fraud. (Cries: That is not a point of order.)
In the interest of truth and justice, of morality and of the integrity of our movement, the statements of the leaflet in question were examined by political Zionists. We were obliged to establish that the
