No. 3 Special Edition — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 7.
Abramowitsch: I declare myself against the motion. A restriction of the time for speaking is a brutality. And a Jewish parliament ought not to submit to a brutality, even if the majority so wills it.
Vice-President Dr. Marmoreck: Allow me a request. It is the first time that I venture to ask anything of you. I believe it is in the interest of freedom of speech that the Soskin motion be rejected. — Dr. Soskin has just modified his motion from 15 minutes to half an hour. I repeat my request that the Soskin motion be rejected.
In the vote which now follows the result is uncertain. (Great disturbance). A second vote is taken, in which the Right ostentatiously abstains from voting.
Vice-Pres. Dr. Marmorek: I regret that the gentlemen on the Right have not made use of their vote. The Soskin motion has accordingly been adopted. (Renewed whistling, great prolonged uproar, violent excitement.)
Vice-Pres. Marmorek: You have seen that I endeavoured to safeguard the right of the minority. (Syrkin calls out: that is not true!) Had the gentlemen on the Right voted with us, the Soskin motion would have fallen. They did not vote. I put the motion, and ask you to adopt it, that the gentlemen of the Zione Zion speak for half an hour each and the gentlemen of the opposing party for one to one and a half hours. (Cries: Quite right! Great uproar!)
Dr. Marmorek makes various further announcements concerning meetings and gatherings to take place this evening and to-morrow.
Extraordinary Congress.
Third (Night) Sitting, Saturday, 29th July 1905. Opened at 9.20.
Dr. Nordau (greeted with applause): The Presidium has been informed that there are many non-delegates in the hall. In the course of the sitting votes will be taken. It is important that only delegates take part in the voting. But it will not be possible to check this if many non-delegates are among the delegates. I call upon all non-delegates who are in the hall to leave it, so that a vote can be checked and the vote may be truly exact as the expression of the Congress.
We continue the proceedings on the East Africa project.
Lewkowitsch (speaks in Russian for 15 minutes)
From the floor the word is demanded on a point of order. Dr. Nordau declares that during the speeches of the general speakers the floor cannot be given on a point of order.
Briskmann: For the third time I have the honour of appearing at the Zionist Congress as a delegate. But for the first time I mount the tribune. I have grown accustomed always to think of this tribune with respect and reverence. I know, indeed, that it is the only tribune which the Jewish people has created for itself up to now. I know also that from this tribune great and lofty speeches, historic speeches, have been addressed to the Jewish people, and, for the first time, to the outside world in the name of the Jewish people. I know also that from all the lands of the earth the Jews look up with attention to this one tribune. This opinion of mine regarding this tribune will, I believe, be your best guarantee that I shall not permit myself to say from this tribune anything that may not be said from a truly parliamentary tribune (Cries of Bravo). I shall perhaps enter upon criticism, I shall perhaps express opinions which will be unpleasant to you, perhaps highly unpleasant, but that is surely my right as a delegate; it is surely the very honour of the parliamentary tribune that from such tribunes the opinion of the opposite tendency can be expressed in loyal form. I ask our opponents likewise to have respect for the tribune and for their opponents. (Uproar.) You must have respect for your opponents if only because those opponents come before you openly and proudly, and because they know in what an overwhelming minority they appear here, and yet do not abate the least jot of their opinion, but express their opinion clearly and openly.
First, as to the Uganda question:
The Uganda question has acquired a great significance in Jewish and Zionist life. For two years this question was discussed. Two years ago the Basle Congress occupied itself with this question and resolved that this question must be investigated and laid before it for decision on the basis of documents.
For two years we kept silent, trusting that everything would be done to carry out the resolution of the Congress. At last we began to doubt. After some time it became a certainty to us that this resolution had not been taken as it ought to have been taken by men imbued with the democratic principle and spirit. To-day I stand here to call these men to account, to bring a grave charge against these men. To-day I will say here that in the Greenberg report a phrase was left out, the phrase: that the money for the Uganda project had been given by Christians and that this was a disgrace to the Jewish people. The A.-C. did not translate that for us.
The people in Russia has almost no press, except one in the Hebrew language, which is exclusively in the hands of men who were against the project. (Applause and protests.) Most of the people do not know the Hebrew language. (Oho!) That is no polemic against the Hebrew language. I say: the Jewish people, not being informed, could not protest against it, and therefore the responsibility for what has happened is to be laid not upon the Jewish people but upon the members of the A. C.
What have they done with the resolution of the Congress? Is that perhaps to signify a turning-point in Jewish history? What did they do for the generations that are to come?
The speaker then turns his polemic against the A. C., which he reproaches with never having turned to the Jewish people to collect money. The A. C., he says, did not tender its resignation after the resolution of the last Congress, and thereby it took upon itself before the whole world the obligation of carrying out this resolution. (Applause.) This, however, it did not do. That, he says, is a great historic accusation, an accusation in the name of the national honour, of this Congress, for which the A. C. surely ought to have respect. It would not have permitted