Page 6 — "Die Welt" — Special Edition No. 3.
(continued from page 5)
…being colonised. It is therefore possible that we may obtain a concession in the one country or the other.
Zionism is harder to realise in Palestine than in other countries. (Cries: Anti-Zionist!) By the vital question of the Jews I understand the land question. I pass from principles to the practical, and I say that the Uganda project is with us no accident, no mere phenomenon, but something entirely natural. (The Chairman, Marmorek, asks the speaker to be brief, as other gentlemen still wish to speak.)
Professor Warburg read out to us in his report to-day that an expedition had been sent to Uganda and that the country was not suitable for us. There will be a good deal of humbug in that too. (A cry: You are a paid humbug! Great uproar.)
Dr. Marmorek: I must ask the speaker to withdraw that. (This is done). The incident is therefore closed.
Chassan continues: The expedition could not explore the country in so short a time; it made haste to return in order to report to the Congress. In Uganda we have the possibility of realising the aim of Zionism. (Stormy interjections: Enough! He should be ruled out of order! Great disturbance.) The Chairman, Dr. Marmorek, asks that the speaker be heard, as he will soon be finished.
Chassan: I therefore move: The Seventh Congress expresses its satisfaction with what the A.-C. has done, but the negotiations are to be carried further. A new expedition is to be sent. (Great disturbance.)
The Chairman, Dr. Marmorek: The Congress has properly brought its programme, the discussion of the Uganda question, to a close. A motion lies before us to break off here and to continue the sitting to-morrow evening at half-past 8.
There is further a motion by Dr. Hantke and Dr. Kalmus. They move the election of four general speakers for each of the two parties. This election can still be carried out to-day. I shall adjourn the sitting for 10 minutes and ask the gentlemen to repair to two halls for the election.
Herr Jochelmann complains. As he asserts, I did not give him the floor. When I had called upon Herr Jochelmann, it was said that he had exchanged his turn with Herr Chassan; that is why he has come in Herr Chassan's place.
Dr. Braude: In view of the fact that the actual division of the parties into two is hardly exact, and that among the gentlemen who put down their names pro and contra there are after all various shades, and various expressions of opinion ought also to come to their due, I propose that, in the sense of the motion already put by Bodenheimer, we have the general speakers elected by the national groups, so that the shades within each national group may come to their due. But since there is the possibility that within the national groups the majority might be led on to suppress the minority, I propose that, independently of the national groups, the fractions also be represented on their own by general speakers.
There are national groups where we may safely assume that the parties will come to an understanding. In such national groups, on the other hand, where this is not the case, my motion would give the fractions the possibility of being represented. The number of general speakers would not be considerably increased thereby.
Dr. Deiches: I must maintain my motion that, notwithstanding that each tendency elects a certain number of general speakers, the Zione Zion send two eminent representatives to set forth their standpoint.
Dr Syrkin: I speak here in the name of the Socialist-Zionist delegation, which is represented by 30 delegates and has behind it 10,000 organised workmen. We demand of the Congress that 6 general speakers be chosen from our midst (Dissent). You are morally bound to grant full freedom of speech to a minority which is so active in the Jewish public life of Russia. Because this minority is something so pronouncedly different, it has the right to find full expression here Precisely because you know that you hold the power in your hands and that the Congress will probably decide in your sense, you will be answerable before Jewish and all public opinion if you do not comply with this just demand.
Delegate Herbst: I ask you to take into consideration that in deciding the question of the number of general speakers the chief point to be weighed is how the Jews of the various countries, according to their lesser or greater freedom and their economic circumstances, take their stand on this question. I therefore move that we do not restrict ourselves to the number of general speakers to be elected, but also give the various countries and national groups the possibility of making known their position through one speaker.
Vice-President Dr. Marmorek reads out the various motions once more and continues: I believe the most far-reaching motion is that of Dr. Braude. Dr. Braude, however, has not fixed the number of general speakers (An interjection: One each!) There are 23 national groups, and each has at least one or two fractions. That makes between 30 and 60 speakers.
Dr. Bodenheimer: Various national groups have united. Of the rest, the greater part will probably forgo general speakers altogether.
Vice-President Dr. Marmorek: The Congress cannot rely upon so vague an assurance. I shall put the Braude motion to the vote. The vote now takes place. The Braude motion is rejected by a very large majority. Likewise the Syrkin motion (Laughter).
The Hantke-Kalmus motion (election of 4 general speakers for each of the two parties), on the other hand, is adopted by a large majority (Applause).
Vice-President Dr. Marmorek: There is still a motion on the order of business by Dr. Soskin, that each speaker be allowed to speak for only 15 minutes (Whistling; protests on the Right.)
Dr. Soskin: In support of my motion I recall that at the last Congress, in the general debate on the East Africa project, a speaking time of only 15 minutes was likewise adopted.
Vice-President Dr. Marmorek: I once more express the severest censure of the person who, in spite of the warning of our honoured President Nordau, has again whistled.
Abramowitsch: If the majority really means to force its resolutions through in every way, then let it do so at once by waving handkerchiefs. I should like that better than this seemingly parliamentary manner.
Vice-President Dr. Marmorek: You may speak only on the form of the vote, and give no other grounds.
