Page 8. — "Die Welt" — Special Edition No. 2.
(continued from page 7)
…directly or indirectly waged a struggle in polemics against the other Jewish organisations, and in one matter, that of the propaganda proposal, invited the other organisations to co-operate, and in another matter, the emigration question, actually did co-operate — then we should be striking our own conviction in the face if we wished to exercise negative criticism upon the activity of the A. C. There remains for us only appreciative recognition and congratulation.
I wish to emphasise with praise that the A. C. has also met our wishes in another direction: by the publication of at least one principal report, that of the Uganda Expedition, which has given our deliberations the necessary parliamentary basis. It is a sin of omission, however, that the report on the El Arish Expedition was not published. You know that we shall be compelled to come to a decision on the El Arish project, for El Arish is a piece of Palestine. For the narrower programme of reform confines itself to a single point, to the method of founding the home.
Gentlemen! You know how matters have developed in this field. The VIth Congress stood under the tragic impression of the official disclosure by our party leadership. The facts compelled Zionism to look about for new paths. It could either hold fast to Palestine, in which case it had to give up the programme and adopt another tactic, or it could hold fast to the principle of autonomy, and then give up Palestine. An attempt was indeed made to find a solution in the form of a middle way, and out of this tendency grew the night-shelter project known to you. Since this project, and presumably other projects too, are not being fulfilled, nothing remains for us but to struggle through to the recognition that the goal of Zionism is not to be reached by way of Africa, Australia, Patagonia, but through Palestine, by way of a systematic, economic and political advance. The vastly preponderant majority of Zionism stands upon this ground.
Autonomy is overrated.
If you have already secured the country for yourselves politically, you must nevertheless first conquer it politically, and this process not even the finest Charter can hasten. Do not forget that mass colonisation, at the pace at which it was formerly imagined, cannot possibly be carried out. All the members of the Palestine Commission have repeatedly shown, in lengthy reports and short polemical articles, that all attempts at rapid mass colonisation undertaken anywhere have always ended in catastrophe; that colonisations can be successful only if, beginning on a small scale, they grow at a reasonable pace into mass colonisation; and that even these first colonisations must be preceded by an experimental colonisation.
Our first principle would have to run: Only such concessions are to be striven for as are the confirmation and formal expression of our actual economic expansion, and we should exert ourselves only for such concessions as we can at once grant a corresponding return for.
Hand in hand with these negotiations, the economic progress in Palestine, the peaceful economic penetration of the country, must take place. Such a system is not the old petty colonisation; that is great Zionist policy, but Zionist Realpolitik.
Consider calmly what losses the former system has brought us. Compelled by this system, we had for long years to hold ourselves aloof from all purchase of land in Palestine. We had to look on while the prices of land round about Haifa and Jaffa rose twentyfold and a hundredfold. This new policy will protect us from such losses.
But under no circumstances can we renounce the neighbouring lands of Palestine, because they signify the natural field of expansion of a Jewish commonwealth, because they belong to the historic seats of the Jews, because in some parts a far-reaching local autonomy is conceded on the part of the Anglo-Egyptian Government, and finally because the situation of the Jewish proletariat is such that we absolutely must think of creating a wide outlet for it.
With that I come to the practical steps of our programme. Let us expect nothing more from mighty protectors, non-Jewish or Jewish! Let us rely only upon ourselves and upon our own means! We may neglect neither diplomatic relations nor relations with other Jewish organisations. But our solution must be exclusively: National self-emancipation. Let us address ourselves in the first place to the governments of those countries in which we wish to win concessions, that is, to the English, Egyptian and Turkish Governments. These will demand no particular pecuniary sacrifices at all if we fill uncultivated tracts with taxpayers and create new economic values. As regards the Turkish Government, we have first of all to demand the removal of those obstacles which stand in the way of a colonisation on a legal basis.
The question now arises, by what path we are to conduct this national work of colonisation. We shall have to conduct agricultural, industrial and urban colonies, and to organise those already existing in Palestine as the nucleus of our Jewish commonwealth.
The Jewish people has the means for its self-emancipation, and these are popular settlement co-operatives, in which even the poorest, by small regular contributions, gains the possibility of raising within a year the sum needed for the purchase of land and the costs of settlement. All our fellow Zionists who return from Palestine confirm that the external conditions there signify only a trifling obstacle for colonists willing to work. Let each one see to it that he creates a new existence in Palestine for himself and his family; in so doing he provides for the nation as well.
Herr Dr. Marmorek reads a list of gentlemen who are appointed as stewards.
Dr. Syrkin (received with applause and hissing): Before I take the floor on the order of the day, I wish to set forth in a few words how the course of the discussion ought to be, and how, unfortunately, through Herr Dr. Ussischkin's reading, it is not. According to my understanding of the standing orders, after the report of Herr Dr. Nordau, the President of the Congress, a discussion must attach itself solely and exclusively to the report. On the questions connected with the tendencies within Zionism, the discussion will begin at another point I therefore regard it as a violation of the standing orders when Herr Dr. Nossig, with a special report on a subject which is not
