Page 8. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 51.
(continued from page 7)
…pressed elements to attain freedom. The revolution is very cruel, but in victory also very magnanimous. And we Jews have joined the revolution. But the road it inevitably travels, the road of anarchy and destruction, is very dangerous for us. The "disturbances" that are unavoidable in the peculiar course of the Russian revolutionary movement will, thanks to the anti-Jewish tendency fostered by the former régime, make themselves felt first of all on our backs. If the police were inactive during the October days out of ill will, in future they will be condemned to inactivity by their weakness. Dangerous to us are not only the "Black Hundreds," but also the mutinous sailors, the revolutionised soldiers, the peasants who rob everyone, the ruined small landowners, the unemployed policemen, and all the other elements of the dark past. And involuntarily we must ask ourselves whether we shall not have paid too much for the freedom attained. Will not only a part of our people be able to enjoy the fruits of our success, while all the rest find, not a glorious death in the brave struggle for freedom, but a shameful end during the persecution and in panic flight into barns and lofts?
The liberal representatives of the well-to-do classes, too — that is, those elements to whom the greatest part will fall in a reformed Russia — have been frightened by the irresistible course of the revolution. And so the Moscow Congress was convened, and it resolved to check the revolutionary movement and "to pacify the country"! "To restore order, to make the disturbances disappear" means as much as to stem the current of the revolution, whose chief vital nerve, in the given phase of development, is precisely revolt and disturbance. And in this sense the resolution of the Moscow Congress appears to us an act of counter-revolution, and if this act should be carried into effect, then the Russian movement for freedom will end in a moderate liberal patching of the old machine. In this compromise of the Moscow Congress with the government, the interests of the small parties will suffer above all, among them those of the Jews. The behaviour of the "higher" authority towards the Jews is known to everyone, and the Act of the 17th of October, which was intended to pacify the unyielding elements by concessions, together with the events that followed it, show plainly enough that the higher authority means to deal with our unyieldingness by other means and without making us great concessions. The representatives of the Zemstvos and of the towns are well disposed towards us, as is shown by the resolution on the Jewish question — which, to be sure, was not adopted without patronage and back-stairs manœuvres. But that the Jewish question will in no way be an obstacle to the conclusion of the agreement can hardly be doubted. If Count Witte's government should give way on the principal points "except for the Jews," then the Liberals of the Centre and of the towns will not wish to prefer a continuation of "revolt and disturbance," even at the price of great concessions in respect of our rights. And then we shall run the risk, as has often happened before, of being pushed aside on the road to liberation.
I consider the resolution of the Moscow Congress an act of the greatest importance, although it has not come altogether unexpectedly. It is capable of turning the present movement into another channel, and in the present mood it has many chances of success. A new horizon has now been opened to the Russian movement for freedom, and for us Jews there now present themselves two roads, or rather two prospects, for the attainment of equal rights; the one road is dangerous but sure, the other — less sure and also less dangerous. It is hard to decide the question, to take the responsibility before the Jewish people, and to show it plainly and clearly whither it should turn. We are still wholly under the influence of the latest events, and for the present we cannot answer with certainty the question: "Where lies the way out?"
A. Dawidson.
From Russia.
At last the representatives of Russian Jewry assembled in St. Petersburg, and the striking silence concerning the sad and bloody events was broken. But not all had the intention of finally expressing themselves on the massacre that began more than a month ago, that seems never to end, and that has called forth the deepest indignation throughout the whole world. At least this was not the intention of the representatives of the "intellectual Jewry" of St. Petersburg. This was shown above all by the entirely harmless agenda of the general meeting of the St. Petersburg "Jewish Educational Society" on Monday, the 21st of November (4th of December), which, as every year in the quietest times, was confined to the annual report, current business and new elections. It turned out otherwise, however. The Society also counts among its members some who had been unable to keep their harmless calm in recent weeks, and all the less so on a day on which memorial services were held in all the houses of worship of St. Petersburg, with a resolution taken beforehand to observe the day as a fast-day. And these members of the Society felt impelled to consider the causes that had given occasion for this fast-day, and they carried it through that the harmless agenda was turned into a protest meeting.
Protest was made both against the government, which had not merely tolerated the pogroms but at many central points had directed them through its organs. Protest was also made against those sections of the Jewish population that had hitherto stubbornly denied that a special Jewish question existed. A Jewish writer frankly admitted that he himself had long upheld this view in the press, but had now come to the conviction that it is not the measure of suffering alone that is decisive, but the kind and the forms in which it appears; that the Jews, therefore, who take part in the general struggle for right and freedom must take care to safeguard their own particular interests, since these would be looked after by no one else. Mr. B. Goldberg (Vilna) pointed out that the attitude of Russian society depended on that of the Jews themselves, and if the Zemstvos were unwilling to admit a Jewish delegate from Vilna, the fault of the Jews themselves was far greater, inasmuch as the "Jewish Association" had protested by telegraph against the sending of this delegate.
The meeting closed with the adoption of the following resolution:
"Deeply stirred by the calamity of the October days, the general meeting of the 'Jewish Educational Society' feels obliged to take up a position towards the events. On the basis of the material available, the meeting recognises that the chief guilt for the deeds of blood falls upon the government, whose organs not merely tolerated the pogroms but in many places directed them. Most of the guilty have remained in high positions; those dismissed have not been brought to judicial account. The meeting also expresses that Russian society, in the October-
