No. 51. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.
(continued from page 2)
…Jewish politicians do insist on pursuing Jewish politics in Europe for ever, then let them at least bear the material consequences of their obstinacy. And they now know from their own experience that costly precaution is the cheaper course. Twelve and a half millions have so far been raised in relief funds. Twelve and a half million Marks! Who knows whether there would still be pogroms and persecutions and the whole burden of our misery at all, had the Jews raised the twelve and a half millions some years earlier. But Herzl could take with him on his journeys only his golden heart and the power of his speech! And these twelve and a half millions mean nothing but steam above a hot stone; the hooligans' few holidays have, after all, cost far more. Perhaps the times are changing, perhaps the outcry in Russia will now find its echo — the Conference at Brussels may become a landmark; there it is time for a new "Confiteor."
Now, indeed, the last argument of political naïveté has fallen. Many, to be sure, made many remarks on how comical and unheard-of it was to buy a land, a homeland, like a broker. Now the battles for it have indeed been fought, bloody, savage battles, and the corpses lie in rows. Not in Palestine, but for Palestine. How often will the cost of founding a State now still be given to the Russians instead of to the Jews; how often will a Jewish heroic regiment yet bleed to death because the Jewish slave-mind so wills it? At Brussels they will have to answer Basle.
J. Upfimny.
Melancholy Thoughts on the Feast of the Maccabees.
No people on earth celebrates festivals reaching so far back into grey antiquity as those of our people. Our youngest festival, that of the Maccabees, which we are celebrating just now, is well over two thousand years old. Our festivals are our charters, bearing witness that we are among the oldest peoples of the earth. They are monuments of a better old time, which the fury of the enemy, who destroyed our monuments of bronze and stone, could not annihilate. The Feast of the Maccabees awakens in us the uplifting consciousness that we are the sons of our fathers, who knew how to defend their holiest possessions with contempt of death against an enemy many times superior to them. But in spite of this joyful feeling, a melancholy thought steals over me at the sight of the festal lights. The very thing that makes us proud, the great age of our holy days, is at the same time a saddening testimony for our people. It shows that we gladly turn our gaze away from our present and seek consolation in the far-distant past. Happy peoples live happily in the present and do not yearn for the past. Only oppressed peoples cling convulsively to the glory of vanished days, because the present is for them without comfort. Who would expect the Germans solemnly to celebrate the victory won over the Romans by their ancestors in the Teutoburg Forest nineteen hundred years ago, or the defeat of the Hungarians on the Lechfeld nearly a thousand years ago? Not even the Battle of the Nations at Leipzig, by which Germany freed herself from the yoke of Napoleon, now finds sufficient attention. Even the Sedan celebration, by which one seeks to keep the most important event of recent German history in the memory of the German people, fades more and more from year to year. The Germans are, in fact, a happy people; in the present they stride from victory to victory and draw their proud consciousness from the freshly flowing life, and not from memories of happy days of old. For us Jews, however, the present is so humiliating and so empty of all that uplifts, that we can strengthen ourselves only on the past. That our youngest festival is the Feast of the Maccabees shows that we must wander two thousand and seventy years back in our history before we find a day still worthy of celebration even now. This thought is painful. I can therefore wish our people nothing better in this Chanukah week than that our beautiful Feast of the Maccabees may soon pale before the splendour of the festival that is to immortalise the day on which the re-establishment of the Jewish commonwealth on the soil of our fathers takes place.
Dr. Tykocinski.
The Jewish Curia and Jewish Dignity.
The discussion on the Jewish Curia has begun. When, two weeks ago, we broached the subject in these pages, we spoke exclusively of the probable effects of the Austrian Jewish Curia. That, admittedly, was somewhat premature. For for the present it is not yet the question of its efficacy, but only that of its existence, which stands on the order of the day. Curiously enough, however, these two questions cannot be separated from each other: the same precondition which must first be fulfilled if a Jewish Curia is to come about at all plays the chief part likewise in deciding the question whether the Jewish Curia means a benefit or a harm to the Austrian Jews. And this precondition is called, briefly and plainly: Jewish dignity. Without Jewish dignity, Herr Dr. Byk, we shall get no Jewish Curia. Well, then?
Herr Dr. Byk, Member of the Reichsrat, member of the Polish Club, will himself be astonished that we have apostrophised him in connection with the notion of "Jewish dignity." Indeed, what has he had to do in his life with the notion, and with the thing that stands behind this notion? In his public, political life, of course! As a private man Herr Dr. Byk is highly respectable and estimable throughout; that is not to be touched. As a politician, however, he is an opponent of the Jewish Curia: the very one that is unthinkable and unattainable without Jewish dignity. And because Herr Dr. Byk is the first "official" Jew to oppose the Jewish Curia in this discussion, and because his opposition is paved with all the old, rotten, insincere and unfathomably unfounded arguments that we shall often find in our path in the course of the coming weeks, we wish to occupy ourselves somewhat more closely with his attitude on this question.
Herr Dr. Byk denies that he belongs to a Jewish nation, which in his opinion does not exist at all; he is merely a Jewish "co-religionist" and wishes to be nothing else. His arguments: the Jews lack a language of their own and a land of their own. And because this is so — Herr Dr. Byk is enthusiastic for a "Poland from sea to sea." Evidently this ideal was the burden of the songs that were sung over Herr Dr. Byk's cradle. Herr Dr. Byk is neither able nor willing to belong to a nation that has lost its land and has not yet regained it; that has adopted the vernaculars of its host peoples and has neglected its own classical tongue in consequence. Therefore Herr Dr. Byk has entered another nation. Incautiously, the Polish one. When one has the choice, one should choose the best. Shall I touch with my pen the deep wound in Herr Dr. Byk's heart and remind him that the Poles, though they have not lost their land, have lost their State? Or did that not trouble him upon his entry into the Polish nation? Did he console himself over this "defect" of the Poles with the fact that the Poles
